3 ms·
This trend of submitting posts sniping at Greece\Germany is starting to get ugly and isn't really suitable for HN, can we please stop?
by smcl 11y ago
This trend of submitting posts sniping at Greece\Germany is starting to get ugly and isn't really suitable for HN, can we please stop?
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoIt won't stop because there are lot of angry leftists (mostly Europeans) who are upset that Greece might actually be forced to pay its bills and what that means for the welfare state model the EU has built itself on. So they snip from the sidelines about nazis, war, banks, conspiracy theories, etc that has nothing to do with the subject at hand. Greece is something of a canary in the coalmine here about Europe's leftist policies. The economic situation in other countries like Portugal, Spain, Italy, Croatia, Bulgaria, etc shows that there's a larger problem here. They don't want to pay their bills or cut services. They just want an endless gravy train and soon might suffer the same consequences as Greece. Only the most wealthy, least corrupt, and productive EU states can have a proper welfare state and even some of them have problems with youth unemployment, job growth, low military spending, almost no defense against an expansionist Putin outside of the US Military (whose spending they are first to criticize), etc. We're witnessing the end of the welfare state as we know it, and apparently a lot of Europeans can't handle that basic fact. Apparently from the knee-jerk drive-by downvotes, they can't handle this comment as well.
- ojbyrne 11y agoIf your second last sentence is true, then you can't have monetary union. Break up the Euro.
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoThis is also my opinion as well. A shared currency is just a bad idea and that's something the English realized early on, or at least the Thatcher administration did. Her 1995 book "Path to Power" pretty much predicted this situation.
- tedunangst 11y agoEngland's realization was also assisted by Soros, so to say.
- cristianpascu 11y ago>> Only the most wealthy, least corrupt, and productive EU states can have a proper welfare state and even some of them have problems with youth unemployment, job growth, etc. That's so true! While Romanian women (the etc. in your list of countries with problems) work 12 hours/day for $10, so cool, polite, wealthy, less corrupt teenagers in developed countries can have cool and cheap Che t-shirts.
- abrahamepton 11y agoYeah this is all pretty wrong. >> upset that Greece might actually be forced to pay its bills and what that means for the welfare state model the EU has built itself on. 1) Those aren't just Greece's bills. Steve Waldman put it best: "The European financial system was architected to make lending to Greece — and Spain and Portugal and Italy — a money machine for bankers with little career risk over a medium term. Sketchy credits tend to punch above their weight in terms of volume of issuance, so there was a lot of nice paper to buy. The bankers who lent to these states understood perfectly well that there was in fact a long-term risk, an uncertainty, a constructive ambiguity. They lent anyway, and took home very nice salaries and bonuses for doing so." (http://www.interfluidity.com/v2/5965.html http://www.interfluidity.com/v2/5965.html) 2) This has nothing to do with implicating the welfare-state model; as you note, there are a ton of Euro welfare states with extremely robust economies. Some Euro welfare states have been chronically mismanaged (Greece, Italy, probably Spain) and now they're in trouble, in part for reasons not of their making. >> Only the most wealthy, least corrupt, and productive EU states can have a proper welfare state Oh, so in other words, if you take out Sweden, Denmark, the Netherlands, Germany, France, Norway, Finland, Belgium and Switzerland, the European welfare state is a total disaster, huh? >> and even some of them have problems with youth unemployment, job growth, low military spending, almost no defense against an expansionist Putin outside of the US Military... 1) You know who else has problems with youth unemployment? The United States. Per the BLS (http://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t02.htm http://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.t02.htm), 16-19-year-old unemployment rate among white people was 15.7% in June 2015, and 31.8% among 16-19-year-old black people. THIRTY TWO PERCENT. But yeah, European welfare states are the only ones with a problem here. 2) US military spending is insanely high - we spend as much as the next 7 countries combined (http://pgpf.org/Chart-Archive/0053_defense-comparison http://pgpf.org/Chart-Archive/0053_defense-comparison). So it makes a certain amount of sense for Europe to throttle back their own spending a bit, though ideally they would spend more and we would spend much, much, much less.
- fnordfnordfnord 11y agoWhy can't we instead just talk about how bad this article is? Is it necessary to hide everything that is disagreeable?
- criley2 11y ago> Is it necessary to hide everything that is disagreeable? It's disingenuous for you to imply that we want Divisive Political news hidden for it's disagreeableness. Why cannot we disagree with it based on its relevancy to "Hackers" and "News" regarding hacking? This isn't the forum to discuss Global Finance. It's not GloFi News, it's Hacker News. What's so wrong with staying on topic? Better yet: someone (me!) should write a Hacker News for politics and global finance, just as design-related topics have moved to other link aggregators.
- fnordfnordfnord 11y ago>Why cannot we disagree with it based on its relevancy to "Hackers" and "News" regarding hacking? Of course you can, that usually starts another chain of yes-it-is/no-it-isn't but you surely can; it's not what GP did though.
- smcl 11y agoI am just tiring of seeing politics articles laden with rhetoric whose sole purpose is to provoke. They are not constructive, insightful or at this point even interesting. You suggest that there is some merit in a "let's discuss how bad the article is" discussion, but I think that's a wee bit of a stretch. The article disappeared fairly quickly anyway so it looks like I wasn't alone in thinking this way. Another reason I posted the comment instead of downvoting was that I can't downvote stories yet (I've only ~1200 karma), after seeing countless versions of these articles pop up I thought I'd add my $0.02 via a comment.
- fnordfnordfnord 11y agoI think that provocative articles and comments often inspire really good retorts/comments as opposed to more well-balanced articles, at least sometimes. Yeah, the blatant inflammatory baiting rhetoric sucks and I am happy to downvote those comments, no matter what their alignment is. I hope that's enough to discourage it. I do see flare-ups of partisan hackery from time to time, but I think batting it back down with comment voting and the occasional polite reminder works well. >The article disappeared fairly quickly anyway So it's not much of a problem then. >I can't downvote stories yet (I've only ~1200 karma) If there is an amount of karma that allows you to downvote sumbissions, it's more than 6743. I can flag them, is that what you mean?
- msellout 11y agoI thought the upvotes define what is "suitable" for HN.
- davidw 11y agoNope: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html This is basically 'politics' as can be seen from the flamey comments already being posted.
- smcl 11y agoMy comment was added because I didn't feel a down vote was enough to convey what I thought, and actually I cannot even down vote on articles as my karma isn't sufficient :)