3 ms·
I agree. A single post would just end up unmanageable and dominated by whoever had the top comment. (I always yearn for a 'by date' sort for HN comments as ofte
by andybak 11y ago
I agree. A single post would just end up unmanageable and dominated by whoever had the top comment. (I always yearn for a 'by date' sort for HN comments as often the top comment hijacks the discussion on a tangent and it's annoying to find people discussing the primary topic)
- dang 11y ago> I always yearn for a 'by date' sort for HN comments We can't make a big flat list and sort those by date without losing the threadedness of the comments and thus their context. But we could sort siblings by date at each level of the tree, including the top level. Is that what you mean?
- andybak 11y ago> without losing the threadedness Sometimes this would be a good thing. Top-level (and in general 'higher up the tree' comments completely dominate. It's rare for the direction of a HN thread to shift much after a reasonable number of comments as everything gets buried quite far down. I'd really like a 'what changed since i was last here' button. Quite often I come back to a long thread I was especially interested in and I'm completely unable to find out if anything of value has been added. > But we could sort siblings by date at each level of the tree More options = better. The intended audience of HN can cope with a few more things to click. Treat us like power-users.
- dang 11y agoHN has always treated users like power users. That's part of its design. But there are other considerations, such as its minimalism and the fact that there is a single shared view of the content.
- andybak 11y ago> a single shared view of the content So is the lack of options to resort and reorder comments an intentional thing? It would be interesting to hear the reasons for it and what benefits you consider it brings.