4 ms·
Obviously the situations aren't the same, but are you saying that Germany deserved more lenient terms in the late 1940s than Greece does now? It seems to me tha
by mikeash 11y ago
Obviously the situations aren't the same, but are you saying that Germany deserved more lenient terms in the late 1940s than Greece does now? It seems to me that we ought to be more lenient with the country that didn't just go out and kill a couple dozen million people in an attempt to conquer the world.
- drzaiusapelord 11y ago>that didn't just go out and kill a couple dozen million people in an attempt to conquer the world. Every country that has been a world power is pretty much guilty of this. Why aren't we picking on the English for the old empire or the thousands of wars and skirmishes on the continent between these powers? Or on the crusades? Picking on Germany is stupid and more Yanis Varoufakis-like hysterics. His over-the-top rhetoric and calling his own lenders "terrorists" is what's wrong with the world, not what's right. Apparently, Greeks are willing to say or do anything except actually collect taxes and cut public spending. Thus far, Greece has been on the receiving end of historically generous loans.
- jrcii 11y agoThe Crusades were hardly an attempt to "conquer the world". For the most part it was an attempt to counter already occurring aggressive, violent Islamic expansion.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mikeash 11y agoIt's nothing to do with "picking on" Germany. Merely pointing out that immediately after they went out and did this, and destroyed their own country in the process, they got really favorable terms to rebuild. And now they're insisting on harsher terms for others. Why did Germany deserve better terms after their adventures? Or if it's not a matter of deserving them but just a purely pragmatic question of those terms being useful to avoid a future catastrophe, why doesn't that pragmatism apply here?
- lmm 11y ago> Why did Germany deserve better terms after their adventures? Or if it's not a matter of deserving them but just a purely pragmatic question of those terms being useful to avoid a future catastrophe, why doesn't that pragmatism apply here? It was even more "pragmatic" than that; it wasn't about preventing German civilians from starving or anything so humanitarian, it was the US wanting to stop the spread of communism. There's no similar "threat" in Greece today. Maybe if IS starts getting recruits near Greece the calculus will change.
- drzaiusapelord 11y agoI respectfully disagree. 50% of the impetus to "save Greece" has a lot to do with not letting Greece fall into Putin's sphere of influence and potentially losing a strategic NATO ally. Tsipras has visited the Russian embassy many times and has flown to Moscow a couple times as well. These weren't social calls and the agenda was kept secret for a reason. Greeks admire Marxism and the old USSR and probably wouldn't mind moving into a Russian sphere of influence, either, especially if Russian taxpayers foot the bill for their unaffordable social programs. EU negotiators are dealing with a lot more than just pensions and lack of tax collection here. They're dealing with a potential Russian base, missiles, AA, subs, warships, etc permanently on their border and aimed at their capitals and civillian centers. The Ukrainians are a good example of what happens when the Russian military is your neighbor. Allowing Russia to trivially attack their borders and put up a Mediterranean blockade is unacceptable to the EU/NATO, but Tsipras is probably crazy enough to make this happen unless he gets the terms he demands. That said, the firing of Yanis Varoufakis probably means Tsipras is serious about cutting down the stupid Greek extremism that has made these talks impossible and probably wants to stay in the EU/Eurozone/NATO and will play ball on some level. I guess we will see.
- elorant 11y agoExiting the Eurozone, which is what Grexit is all about, doesn’t mean we’ll exit the European Union too. We have no reason to do this and no one in Europe has ever made a hint about it. And then even that wouldn’t be enough for Russians to get a base here. We’d also have to exit the NATO alliance which we’ll never do because it ensures that Turkey can’t attack us since they’re a member too. And on top of that we’d also have to ask US to leave the naval base they have in Crete. All in all, we’d have to alienate pretty much everyone in the western world to allow Russians to get a foothold here. And besides, what’s the point? We don’t trust Putin and he certainly doesn’t have the money to bail us out.
- yk 11y agoTwo things, first we do not 'pick on Germany.' We acknowledge that Germany had the most murderous government in all of history. And no, Britain did never set a explicit policy of extermination and it did not construct factories of death. [1] And second, Greece was not only on the receiving end of loans, but also on the receiving end of a completely boneheaded 'rescue' policy. [1] Yeah, these are technical terms. See Timothy Snyder, Bloodlands, 2010 for definitions.