4 ms·
Phillip Greenspun writes (accurately, I think): "Journalists keep referring to the years of “austerity” that Greece has endured. Government spending has been cu
by CapitalistCartr 11y ago
Phillip Greenspun writes (accurately, I think): "Journalists keep referring to the years of “austerity” that Greece has endured. Government spending has been cut so much that it is now only 58.5 percent of GDP (heritage.org). What does a country that hasn’t suffered austerity spend? Singapore’s government clocks in at 14.4 percent (same source). How about a command-and-control centrally planned Communist dictatorship? China is at 25 percent. A socialist cradle-to-grave welfare state? Sweden is at 52 percent.
Are the Heritage data wrong? If not, how is it possible that Greece continues to be cited as an example of a country where the government doesn’t spend enough?"
http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/philg/2015/07/08/greek-austerity-government-spends-58-5-percent-of-gdp/ http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/philg/2015/07/08/greek-austerit...
- ojbyrne 11y agoAs the comments mention, government spending in Greece went from 110 billion euros in 2007 to 88 billion euros in 2014. Unfortunately GDP went from 230 billion euros to 180 billion euros in the the same time period.
- daodedickinson 11y agoCountries with much worse pensions than Greece are being asked to bail out much more lavish Greek pensions — it is both moral hazard and injustice. Let's keep everybody fed and work on the medical aspect, too, and figure out how to make the Eurozone fair, which could be a minimum pension / benefit level of the lowest country, adjusted for local prices to other countries, and if you want something above that you can't demand that poorer nations pay for it.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- icebraining 11y agoCountries with much worse pensions than Greece are being asked to bail out much more lavish Greek pensions Which countries are those? How much are they being asked to pay?
- Xylakant 11y agoFor example the baltic states http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jul/09/poorer-than-greece-the-eu-countries-that-reject-a-new-athens-bailout?CMP=share_btn_tw http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jul/09/poorer-than-gre...
- icebraining 11y agoHow much are they being asked to pay?
- elorant 11y agoHe probably means Slovenia, Estonia, Slovakia, Latvia and Malta. But that doesn't mean much, those are all countries with a much smaller economy than Greece's so it's natural that they pay smaller pensions.
- Xylakant 11y agoWhy is it natural they pay smaller pensions? It's smaller in terms of how much money each pensioner gets per month that he's talking about, not smaller as in "total amount of money spent".
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoActually most of the money was loaned by the Eurozone - mainly Germany - as welfare for German corporates who benefited from Greek government spending on German exports. (Including essentials like submarines and other military equipment.) The suggestion that some huge percentage is financing lazy pensioners is simply wrong - if only because those same pensioners paid money into the usual pension pot while they were working. The issue is more that the lunatic imposition of austerity killed Greek economic output, making existing spending commitments unaffordable.
- MagnumOpus 11y agoTo your first point: It is pretty ludicrous to claim that giving money to the Greek government, who then gives it to Greek public sector sinecure holders, who then buy a Mercedes (for instance) is welfare for the German company. It is the Greek who end up with the goods. To your second point: The pensioners did not pay into a pot. Greece doesn't have a _funded_ pension pot, they have an unfunded "generational contract" like most other countries public pension system - i.e. the current pensioners paid in small amounts for the smaller number of shorter-lived pensioners that drew benefits 30-40 years - and they themselves now draw pensions for longer and in larger numbers. As such the "lunatic imposition of austerity" is only bringing the Greek pension age and institutional standards in line with the rest of the continent - which they failed to do for decades prior.
- elorant 11y agoWe don’t buy Mercedes only. We also buy German tanks and submarines and French military airplanes. Which we shouldn’t if Europe were to guarantee our borders as it’s their obligation.
- nickbauman 11y agoGreece is the 5th oldest nation on earth demographically speaking. That's a lot of old people collecting pensions.
- gizmo 11y agoWhen you drastically cut government spending in a depressed economy the GDP takes a nosedive. Greece's GDP dropped by a staggering 25%. That's the equivalent of a 4.25 trillion drop in GDP for the US. So the government spending that remains is large compared to the GDP that remains. But of course the cuts were still massive. The percentage of GDP that's called "government" is pretty malleable. There's no real difference between a for-profit railroad monopoly that depends on government subsidies, and a nationalized railway system. But in one case the railroad is classified as private industry, in the other case as government spending. This applies throughout the economy. For instance, the work US military contractors do would be considered government work in Europe. So you can't simply compare the government-to-GDP ratios between countries. When it comes to austerity the issue is the change in government spending, not the size of the government. The sudden change is what shocks the economy. Government spending in Greece went down by a lot, services got cut, salaries got cut, pensions got cut. The name for this kind of policy is austerity. So you shouldn't take anybody seriously who puts austerity in Greece in scare quotes.
- Amezarak 11y ago> Journalists keep referring to the years of “austerity” that Greece has endured. Government spending has been cut so much that it is now only 58.5 percent of GDP (heritage.org). It seems a little misleading to say this. Greece's GDP has tanked since 2008, why would you expect spending/GDP to fall even if they made cuts? Worse, in countries with any kind of safety nets, plummeting GDP (and thus rising unemployment) means more people will take advantage of expensive government social services. There is simply no way to cut your way out of debt in a deep recession when you already have high debt. See also Krugman's posts here: http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/07/07/debt-deflation-in-greece/?module=BlogPost-Title&version=Blog%20Main&contentCollection=Opinion&action=Click&pgtype=Blogs®ion=Body http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/07/07/debt-deflation-i... http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/07/07/milton-friedman-irving-fisher-and-greece/?module=BlogPost-Title&version=Blog%20Main&contentCollection=Opinion&action=Click&pgtype=Blogs®ion=Body http://krugman.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/07/07/milton-friedman-...
- fleitz 11y agoIt does need to be paired with growth, however, there is no indication that Greece is prepared to start growing their economy.
- Amezarak 11y agoIt is impossible for the Grecian government to do anything about growing their economy when their creditors are demanding spending cuts and tax hikes that actually worsen the economy. The troika has been pushing "expansionary austerity" and it has been a monumental failure that has dragged down Europe. Would the Grecian government be able to provide pro-expansionary policies without being hamstrung by the troika? I don't know. But it seems like a moot point.
- gizmo 11y agoWhat does that even mean? What should the Greek government do to "start growing their economy", that they've been unwilling to do so far?
- 11y ago
- bobcostas55 11y agoNot just that, but they've also been running huge deficits every year. That's what the loans from the Troika have been funding, after all. The deficit has been >10% of GDP every year since 2009, except 2013 when it was "just" 8.5%.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- JulianMorrison 11y agoPercentage of GDP is misleading because the economy is a Great Depression scale crash, no business, no jobs, and high reliance of the population on the government simply because there is no other source of money. When the economy tanks, strain on the safety net increases, this should be obvious.
- crdoconnor 11y agoThe % of GDP is irrelevant. A dollar spent by Singapore's private-but-not-really-private SBS on a maintaining a metro line is intrinsically no different to a dollar spent by Greece on its metro line. Both employ people. Both are productive investments. Austerity is about shrinking public sector spending. If it's done during a period when the private sector is also shrinking its spending, the effect on employment and growth can be cataclysmic. The Heritage data isn't wrong. The Heritage just picked the wrong data to make an intentionally misleading point.
- elorant 11y agoSingapore is the world’s best place to do business. As for China, big parts of the country are underdeveloped. How about we compare similar things? Austria 50%, Belgium 53%, Denmark 58%, Finland 55%, France 56%, Italy 50%, US 42%, Germany 45%. And no, Greece's spending isn't at 58,5%, it's 51,9%. Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_spending https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_spending And that without taking under consideration that Greece’s GPD has been reduced by 25% in the last six years. So yet another time in the last couple of weeks someone is trying to make a negative point about Greece by distorting the truth.
- tedunangst 11y ago> And no, Greece's spending isn't at 58,5%, it's 51,9%. Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_spending https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_spending Why in the world would you cite Wikipedia without any attempt at source verification? Wikipedia's source for that table is http://www.heritage.org/index/explore?view=by-variables http://www.heritage.org/index/explore?view=by-variables which clearly lists Greece at 58.5.