6 ms·
What? Did Greece just emerge from the largest military conflict on the planet utterly destroyed? Or did they more or less mismanage their eco? Not collecting
by mc32 11y ago
What? Did Greece just emerge from the largest military conflict on the planet utterly destroyed? Or did they more or less mismanage their eco? Not collecting taxes and generous retirements (hair dressing considered hazardous as mining thus eligible for early retirement, for example) is not comparable to emerging battered and destroyed from the bloodiest conflict in history.
And it's not as if their debt hasn't been restructured.
- bildung 11y ago> What? Did Greece just emerge from the largest military conflict on the planet utterly destroyed? No, but neither did Germany. In fact, despite bombings etc. the industrial infrastructure post-war was bigger than 1933 (because it was heavily built out during that period). edit: Here is a source from German public television (skip to 4:20): https://www.planet-schule.de/sf/php/sendungen.php?sendung=9175 https://www.planet-schule.de/sf/php/sendungen.php?sendung=91...
- yc1010 11y agohere is an interesting fact: Greece lost 11% of their population in WW2, Germany lost 8%
- mc32 11y agoNo, it was destroyed. We relieved their debt because we didn't want them to have to take wheelbarrows full of money to buy loaves of bread as happened after the treaty of Versailles which plunged Germany into nationalism and anti-west sentiment and gave rise to the socialist regime which brought on WWII. And beside the infrastructure destruction there were the ravages of war, disease, psychological, nutrition, etc. Not to mention the obvious generation of men who died. A whole generation of men dead from warring.
- bildung 11y ago> No, it was destroyed. No, it really wasn't :) Heres a documentary from German public television. The interesting part starts at 4:20. I hope you can hear the English language, it has been dubbed in German: https://www.planet-schule.de/sf/php/sendungen.php?sendung=9175 https://www.planet-schule.de/sf/php/sendungen.php?sendung=91...
- Amezarak 11y ago> which plunged Germany into nationalism and anti-west sentiment and gave rise to the socialist regime which brought on WWII. The national socialists came to power as a consequence of the severe deflation in the 1930s, not the hyperinflation 10 years earlier.
- crdoconnor 11y agoIt was more about building an industrial bulwark against Russia than a desire not to see Germans suffer. After all, they did the same thing to Japan too, which didn't have a treaty of Versailles.
- mikeash 11y agoObviously the situations aren't the same, but are you saying that Germany deserved more lenient terms in the late 1940s than Greece does now? It seems to me that we ought to be more lenient with the country that didn't just go out and kill a couple dozen million people in an attempt to conquer the world.
- drzaiusapelord 11y ago>that didn't just go out and kill a couple dozen million people in an attempt to conquer the world. Every country that has been a world power is pretty much guilty of this. Why aren't we picking on the English for the old empire or the thousands of wars and skirmishes on the continent between these powers? Or on the crusades? Picking on Germany is stupid and more Yanis Varoufakis-like hysterics. His over-the-top rhetoric and calling his own lenders "terrorists" is what's wrong with the world, not what's right. Apparently, Greeks are willing to say or do anything except actually collect taxes and cut public spending. Thus far, Greece has been on the receiving end of historically generous loans.
- jrcii 11y agoThe Crusades were hardly an attempt to "conquer the world". For the most part it was an attempt to counter already occurring aggressive, violent Islamic expansion.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mikeash 11y agoIt's nothing to do with "picking on" Germany. Merely pointing out that immediately after they went out and did this, and destroyed their own country in the process, they got really favorable terms to rebuild. And now they're insisting on harsher terms for others. Why did Germany deserve better terms after their adventures? Or if it's not a matter of deserving them but just a purely pragmatic question of those terms being useful to avoid a future catastrophe, why doesn't that pragmatism apply here?
- nickbauman 11y agoIn their last loan in the restructuring almost 90% of it went directly back into the ECB's coffers. Nice trick if you're a bank!
- pkaye 11y agoI thought they also got around 50% debt relief and cuts to interest rate payments.
- Xylakant 11y agoActually, a lot of the money that went to banks went to greek banks (some subsidaries of german and french ones, but still greek). The alternative would have been that those banks go bankrupt and the customers of those banks loose most of their deposits. Would that have been a better option?
- donohoe 11y agoThere was no debt forgiveness after WW1 and that helped lead path to WW2. It was about learning from history. You cannot compare this to the disastrous economic mismanagement by successive Greek govs.
- hencq 11y ago> Did Greece just emerge from the largest military conflict on the planet utterly destroyed? A conflict that was furthermore started by an illegitimate government (literal nazis). On top of that most of that debt was because of reparations for the previous largest military conflict. Reparations that arguably led to the nazis taking power in the first place. I understand why people like comparing the situations, but they are really completely different.
- elorant 11y agoDid Greece just emerge from the largest military conflict on the planet utterly destroyed? Yes, we did. And utterly doesn't even give it justice: http://www.truth-out.org/speakout/item/24456-the-math-of-mass-starvation-and-murder-germany-in-greece-during-world-war-ii http://www.truth-out.org/speakout/item/24456-the-math-of-mas... EDIT: Someone downvoted me for this so I guess they're too lazy to read the article. In which case, I'll just copy paste the important parts. They destroyed 25% of the country's forests; 56% of the roads; 50% to 90% of the bridges; 65% of automobiles; 60% of the trucks; 80% of the buses; 100% of the trains and railways; 80% of the factories; 100% of the water and sewage infrastructure. ...principal harbors were blown up. Installations, machinery and quays were destroyed." The Germans also blew up the strategic Corinth canal. In addition, the Germans sank 74 percent of the Greek ships and destroyed 100 percent of telephone communications. "the occupying forces applied a systematic plan for the destruction of Hellenism: the burning of villages. 1,770 Greek villages lie in ashes. In certain parts of the country, particularly near the frontiers, destruction by fire reached the proportion of 90 % of the villages of every region." The Germans and their allies killed or were responsible for the death of 13% of the Greek population.