2 ms·
Would he deny that there are good programmers who can do things that bad ones couldn't no matter how much time they were given? This is true in other fields; w
by pg 19y ago
Would he deny that there are good programmers who can do things that bad ones couldn't no matter how much time they were given? This is true in other fields; why should programming be any different? And if one programmer can be infinitely more productive than another, he can also be 20x more productive.
- greendestiny 19y agoYeah the problem is the scope of the problems he's imagining. Given a task that takes a great programmer several months to complete, I can easily imagine a team of average programmers taking man-years to complete it. The open-source community is full of such projects and before anyone says they are all copies, so are most average software company's products. There isn't much data on single average programmers taking years to do projects because they just don't work alone and on one project for that long. A mean measure probably isn't a good way to break down the difference as it's likely to be infinite far too often.
- acgourley 19y agoThey would only be 20 times better or infinitely better at those particular tasks though. That seems right to me, it seems like only really Hard problems allow people to show what they are made of, and the easier problems keep the pack more bunched together. It's an important distinction, because a lot of programming is not of the demanding sort described above. It might even be that for some jobs, in some job markets, you don't want to try to hire the best. The cost in salary, recruitment, lost time and turn over might trump the 2-3x gain a top level programmer would offer in a non-challenging environment.
- pg 19y agoPart of performing a task is redefining it.
- shawndrost 19y agoThere are tasks that are strictly defined from the outset: there is an existing code base and tech stack, and you must conform to certain company conventions, and the requirements are strict. I would guess this work constitutes 90% of paid development (and ~2% of useful code). I don't think your argument really applies to those tasks.
- aswanson 19y agoBut I think his point was that those people who can't solve those problems in infinite time are at such a low end of productivity that almost every decent programmer is some coefficient c better than the one that can't do it, where c >> 10. There are tough problems in programming, but unless you are breaking ground in p-np complete type proofs, are there really any day to day problems in almost any development setting that a decent programmer can't attack?