10 ms·
Why Is the Federal Government Afraid of Fat?
- CuriouslyC 11y agoA large part of the issue is that in the traditional American diet, a significant portion of fat intake is in the form of saturated fat. There is a decent amount of research showing saturated fat has inflammatory effects in the body and directly causes insulin resistance. For a long time doctors have had success encouraging patients to eat diets excluding America's primary sources of saturated fat (red meat, bacon/lard and butter). In addition, dietary fat intake does influence triglycerides, LDL and VLDL; fairly good correlations exist between these levels and heart disease. It is only recently we have discovered that sub-types of these particles exist, and not all of them have the same impact on health. Additionally, the knowledge that excess carbohydrate intake can actually have a larger impact on these levels is somewhat more recent. The bias against mono- and poly- unsaturated fats given all the research that exists on their beneficial health effects is still bat-shit crazy, though.
- debacle 11y agoYou're spreading a bit of misinformation here about the nature of saturated fats. The evidence that specifically saturated fats impact insulin resistance is very weak - the change was very low in the studies that took place, and there was no control group in the studies. More recent studies, which generally don't get the same level of publicity, found no correlation between the two (though do confirm the adipose inflammation relationship): http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19828712 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19828712 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20938439 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20938439
- CuriouslyC 11y agoI wouldn't say it is misinformation, though I agree that the issue is far from decided. I appreciate the references and I would love to look at any more you have. One issue with Tierney et al. is that EPA/DHA have been shown to partially ameliorate the insulin desensitizing effects of saturated fatty acids. See http://ajpregu.physiology.org/content/302/5/R598 http://ajpregu.physiology.org/content/302/5/R598.
- thesis 11y agoI'm having trouble with your comment. Do you mind expanding on it? It seems like you are against both saturated fats and carbs. Is that correct?
- CuriouslyC 11y agoI'm not against all saturated fats, actually short and medium chain fatty acids are incredibly beneficial for health. The issue is more with longer chain fatty acids, particularly palmitic acid (which is the fatty acid your body synthesizes to dispose of excess carbohydrates). I am definitely not against carbs in general, though sugars containing fructose are definitely a bad choice in terms of general health. In my opinion, carbs are healthier than fats as long as you can dispose of them quickly; elevated blood glucose is a real problem though. For people who are sedentary and have poor insulin sensitivity, mono- and poly- unsaturated fats will generally be a better choice in terms of overall health.
- Jdoemk2 11y agoI think you're really far off with that assessment. The vilification of saturated fat has been widely shown to be based on poor evidence, and there are many arguments for it being healthy. Furthermore, it is not clear-cut that mono- and poly- unsaturated fats are as healthy as you say they are.
- logfromblammo 11y agoIt isn't even that clear-cut that saturated fatty acids with different lengths have equal effects on health. Butyric acid (C4:0) and stearic acid (C18:0) are both saturated fatty acids. I would be very hesitant to claim that they are interchangeable for the purposes of human body chemistry.
- CuriouslyC 11y agoJust some research studies on the metabolic effects of saturated fats that might prove interesting: Overfeeding Polyunsaturated and Saturated Fat Causes Distinct Effects on Liver and Visceral Fat Accumulation in Humans. http://diabetes.diabetesjournals.org/content/early/2014/02/11/db13-1622.abstract http://diabetes.diabetesjournals.org/content/early/2014/02/1... Substituting dietary saturated fat with polyunsaturated fat changes abdominal fat distribution and improves insulin sensitivity. http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00125-001-0768-3 http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00125-001-0768-3 Saturated fat stimulates obesity and hepatic steatosis and affects gut microbiota composition by an enhanced overflow of dietary fat to the distal intestine. http://ajpgi.physiology.org/content/303/5/G589 http://ajpgi.physiology.org/content/303/5/G589 The influence of the type of dietary fat on postprandial fat oxidation rates: monounsaturated (olive oil) vs saturated fat (cream). http://europepmc.org/abstract/med/12037652 http://europepmc.org/abstract/med/12037652 Saturated Fatty Acid-Mediated Inflammation and Insulin Resistance in Adipose Tissue: Mechanisms of Action and Implications. http://jn.nutrition.org/content/139/1/1.short http://jn.nutrition.org/content/139/1/1.short Stearoyl-CoA Desaturase-1 Mediates the Pro-lipogenic Effects of Dietary Saturated Fat. http://www.jbc.org/content/282/4/2483.short http://www.jbc.org/content/282/4/2483.short A saturated fatty acid–rich diet induces an obesity-linked proinflammatory gene expression profile in adipose tissue of subjects at risk of metabolic syndrome. http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/90/6/1656.short http://ajcn.nutrition.org/content/90/6/1656.short Substitution of saturated with monounsaturated fat in a 4-week diet affects body weight and composition of overweight and obese men - Here they show consuming monounsaturated fat instead of saturated fat causes weight and fat loss. http://journals.cambridge.org/action/displayAbstract?fromPage=online&aid=911460&fileId=S0007114503001788 http://journals.cambridge.org/action/displayAbstract?fromPag... I would love to look at counterpoint articles if you have any.
- lsniddy 11y agoThat is curious, considering our rates of heart disease and diabetes were a fraction of what they were today when people ate more saturated fats (e.g butter). And when switching to a diet where saturated fat is the primary energy source, people tend to lose weight and see an increase in insulin sensitivity.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- irishcoffee 11y agoOff-topic, but every time I see the phrase "a fraction of what it was" I get a bit miffed. 99/100 is a fraction. 101/100 is a fraction. Every thing that gets measured in time intervals is always going to be a fraction of what it was before, bigger or smaller.
- roel_v 11y agoThat's one meaning of the word. It also means 'much smaller than it once was'. Funny thing with words is that they can mean different things in different contexts.
- irishcoffee 11y agoDoes it? http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/fraction http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/fraction
- roel_v 11y agoDid you even read you link? The very page you link to says "3. bit, little <a fraction closer>".
- kazinator 11y ago"A fraction of what it was" is a common idiom, which uses fraction in the ordinary sense. "Fraction" is related to words like "fracture" and "fragment". When you fraction something into pieces, they are always smaller than the whole (barring strange spatial partitionings: Banach-Tarski paradox and all that). Maybe you were playing hooky in grade 3 when the teacher explained that 101/100 is an improper fraction, which can be rewritten as 1 1/100: the whole number 1, combined with a proper fraction. See? "Improper!" Mathematics recognizes a special status for fractions where the numerator has greater magnitude. Also, ever heard of the "integral" and "fractional" parts of a floating-point number? See the ISO C99 function modf, for instance.
- merpnderp 11y agoI think that is based on pretty crappy science. People who cut out refined carbs and sugar, yet eat a very high fat diet have healthy levels of triglycerides and LDL. The science is to the point that the only real danger of high fat diets is colon cancer. But adding fiber to the diet can offset those risks. And of course people want mono and poly unsaturated fats, but they're more expensive and harder to eat in quantity than saturated fats. Plus when I went on a high fat diet (nothing but fat, protein, fruit and vegetables), I cut my triglycerides and LDL in half, lost 40lbs, dropped my blood pressure to well into the athletic level, and felt better than ever before. All in 6 months. [Edit to add personal note]
- CuriouslyC 11y agoCongrats on the weight loss. The fact that you lost 40 pounds in that time frame indicates to me that you were running about an 800 calorie a day deficit. This is important because calorie restriction has been shown to directly improve those numbers, as has weight loss. It is very likely if you cut your calories by the same amount, and lost the same amount of weight with a diet higher in carbohydrates and lower in fat, you would have had similar results. With that being said, if those dietary restrictions allowed you to lose weight with ad libidum feeding, then they were the right choice for you.
- GordonS 11y agoIt's a lot harder to restrict calorie intake with a diet mainly comprised of carbohydrates. I find it very easy with a high fat diet, just because fat keeps you feeling fuller for longer. For example, I can eat 2 eggs for breakfast and not think about food for 4+ hours. Before I would eat an oat-based muesli with dried fruit (no refined sugar), which contained twice the calories - I'd invariable be hungry within 2 hours. Maybe it's also possible that the drop in blood glucose after eating carbs has a hunger 'signalling' effect.
- innguest 11y agoBecause fat is good for the brain and for the body (it makes you slim and a fast thinker) whereas carbs are the opposite - obese people have 8% less brain tissue. The government wants dumb unhealthy people that depend on it so it can perpetuate its existence.
- debacle 11y agoThe federal government isn't afraid of fat, but carbs, most extensively from corn and corn syrup, are a huge industry in the US, and the agriculture industry is a massive lobby. Politicians aren't going to tell you to eat fats not sugars when your sugar addiction is keeping them in office. http://www.theguardian.com/business/2012/jun/11/why-our-food-is-making-us-fat http://www.theguardian.com/business/2012/jun/11/why-our-food...
- lsllc 11y agoThis. As always with politics, follow the money!
- mapgrep 11y agoThis doesn't make sense. Corn is used much more heavily as feed stock for animals than as a sweetener or dietary carb for humans. Corn growers thus have more invested in encouraging high-fat diets than low-fat diets. About 4.2 billion bushels of U.S. corn per year are used to feed livestock (dairy, beef, hogs, poultry). About 1.4 billion bushels go toward uses including sweeteners like HFCS, as well as toward cereals (and booze). This per: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corn_production_in_the_United_States#Production https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corn_production_in_the_United_...
- sarciszewski 11y agoHeh. I switched to a high fat, moderate protein, almost zero carbohydrate diet back in April and lost 40 lbs so far.
- innguest 11y agoAnd yet when I say that the government doesn't like fat because it makes people healthy (less dependent on the government) and faster thinkers (less likely to blindly trust the government) people downvote me. Impact of obesity on the brain, memory and intelligence: https://www.sciencenews.org/article/obesity-messes-brain https://www.sciencenews.org/article/obesity-messes-brain "Obesity has been associated with a reduced total brain volume and diminished gray matter density." http://www.mpg.de/4280661/obesity_brain_structure http://www.mpg.de/4280661/obesity_brain_structure "But as scientists are learning more about the critical role white matter plays in cognition, new research suggests that obesity may target white matter integrity, leading to a decline in human cognitive performance." http://www.dana.org/News/Obesity_Linked_to_Changes_in_Brain_s_White_Matter_Structure%E2%80%94and_Cognition/#sthash.nYWxFdXP.dpuf http://www.dana.org/News/Obesity_Linked_to_Changes_in_Brain_... EDIT: downvoting is one way to cope with cognitive dissonance but it does not help motivate those that are trying to lose weight.
- acconrad 11y agoCorrelation does not imply causation my friend. Carbs do not imply obesity, neither does fat. Only excess calories (of any macronutrient, including protein) will lead to bodyweight storage, and eventually obesity.
- sarciszewski 11y agoIt's no secret that there are a lot of terrible people on HN with over 500 karma, but usually it doesn't help to complain about them. You just give them a chance to downvote you again.
- alextgordon 11y agoFat is calorie dense. There's ~380 calories per 100g of sugar but 880 calories per 100g of olive oil. 70% of the US population is overweight. Being overweight is bad for you. If your diet contains a lot of fat, you're consuming more calories than if you substituted the fat with something else (e.g. by avoiding deep fried foods, and eating leaner meat). If you are not overweight, then feel free to eat as much fat as you like, but know you are unusual.
- thesis 11y agoOnce upon a time I did the ketogenic diet which bases the bulk of your daily calories from healthy natural fat. No carbs allowed except for carbs from fiber. I, along many other people who have did this diet have lost a lot of weight. It's simply not true that you can't lose weight by eating primarily fatty foods.
- alextgordon 11y agoMost Americans could not sustain a ketogenic diet for any amount of time, so it is pointless for the purposes of a national health body.
- mason240 11y ago>Most Americans could not sustain a ketogenic diet for any amount of time Why not?
- LanceH 11y agoBecause they grew up with a ton of grains on the bottom of the officially government sponsored food pyramid.
- Spivak 11y agoThat isn't the real reason, it's that the bottom of that food pyramid is cheap, they're used everywhere as fillers, and they make that cheap food more palatable. It can't be national policy because there's a huge portion of the population that couldn't afford that diet.
- chrisdbaldwin 11y ago>Based on years of low-fat messaging, most Americans still actively avoid dietary fat, while eating far too much refined carbohydrates. This is the crux of the problem; years of social programming is hard to reverse. Try to explain to someone that fat is good and carbs are bad. It shouldn't be hard to convince someone, but even the basic premise is tantamount to heresy to most Americans. Fat gives you clogged arteries! Fat makes you fat! Carbs and sugar are the American Way™.
- sageabilly 11y agoBecause whenever they set dietary guidelines last the common way of thinking was that "fat is bad" and since it's the government progress is ridiculously slow and also because resetting dietary guidelines is probably way down on the list of "Things that we should really fund this year"? I've seen comments here and elsewhere pop up across the entire internet in response to this article saying that obviously it's a government conspiracy and a lobbying issue and they're all trying to keep us fat and stupid but that's some serious tin foil hat lines of thinking. Also: But rather than focusing on total fat or other numbers on the back of the package, the emphasis should be on eating more minimally processed fruits, nuts, vegetables, beans, fish, yogurt, vegetable oils and whole grains in place of refined grains, white potatoes, added sugars and processed meats. Which seems to be saying "hey, if you don't eat processed stuff and instead eat more whole foods from a variety of sources and strive for lots of variety in your diet then you're probably going to be healthier and less likely to gain a bunch of weight" which seems to be pretty ridiculously obvious nutrition science.
- alecco 11y agoArmchair dieticians in post an this thread. Not all carbs or fats are the same. Good ones of both are part of a healthy diet. But hey, making it simply black and white is appealing for the uneducated masses.
- kayfox 11y agoFrom the article: "Dariush Mozaffarian is dean of the Friedman School of Nutrition Science and Policy at Tufts University. David S. Ludwig is the director of the Obesity Prevention Center at Boston Children’s Hospital and the author of the forthcoming book “Always Hungry? Conquer Cravings, Retrain Your Fat Cells, and Lose Weight Permanently.”" Armchair dieticians?
- acconrad 11y agoWe don't know much about our bodies. I feel like every time a major news publication publishes an op-ed or a study, they're contradicting themselves[1]. One week eggs are bad, the next they're good. Same with dairy, carbs, and red meat. Then you mix in the whole "diet" complexity: Atkins? Paleo? Keto? Vegan? How do I choose? When you study the longest-living peoples of the world, you also find extremely varied diets: the carbohydrate-rich Greeks rely heavily on fruits, veggies and whole grains. They also love goat's milk and wine. While natives of costa rica are primarily relying on "evil" white rice and beans, and heavy on pork and chicken. The people of Japan are also heavy on white rice, and virtually no fat in their diet, since their diet is primarily plant-based[2]. The truth is that everyone's needs are different. As an anecdotal example, I was convinced that keto was the right way, and that carbohydrates were not going to help me. Did I lose fat? Yes. Did I feel great? Sure. It turns out that even with great HDL and Triglycerides, my LDL and fasting glucose were still high. And I'm not alone in this problem from keto either [3]. After switching to a broader, less-restrictive diet, which now includes whole grains (quinoa, oatmeal, and wild rice), beans, and fermented vegetables (kimchi, sauerkraut), lots of fruits and vegetables (including starchy carbs like sweet potatoes and squash), I've lowered my LDL and fasting glucose (yes, now that carbs are back in my diet). Different things work for different people because everyone has a different metabolism. It seems that, if you study the longest-living people, the trends are as follows: * Don't overeat. * Eat mostly plant-based, whole or minimally-processed/refined foods. * Leave 10-20% of your diet for indulgences. Virtually all of the longest-living peoples drink alcohol or coffee on the regular. And even then, by allowing yourself that affordance, you don't risk binge eating or rebounding for days/weeks/months on end. * Ignore fad diets. Stick with the whole foods that you like to eat, get in some variety, but don't be dogmatic about dietary approaches, because not only will you likely not adhere to such restrictions, but you'll probably find yourself being contradicted by another study in the next 3-10 years. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2014/02/09/opinion/sunday/why-nutrition-is-so-confusing.html http://www.nytimes.com/2014/02/09/opinion/sunday/why-nutriti... [2] http://www.nsca.com/uploadedfiles/nsca/inactive_content/program_books/ptc_2013_program_book/aragon.pdf http://www.nsca.com/uploadedfiles/nsca/inactive_content/prog... [3] https://www.google.com/webhp?#safe=off&q=keto+fasting+glucose https://www.google.com/webhp?#safe=off&q=keto+fasting+glucos...
- 11y ago
- jerf 11y agoBecause they can't change their recommendations without admitting they were wrong, and governments generally can't do that. Or, at least, the speed with which they can change their recommendations is sharply bounded by ensuring they never quite have to admit fault. Admitting you were wrong is basically begging to have your funding cut, your reputation trashed, your influence removed, your job cut. The closest thing a government can do to admitting being wrong is if they can say a previous government was wrong, but now we're right. But for these administrative posts there's never a clear turnover for that to occur. Public policy adds the additional problem that if they admit they were wrong about what was possibly the single clearest message the government has sent the US public in the last 50 years, "Fat is bad for you!", the public will very likely and entirely rationally start asking very pointy questions about how such volume could be combined with such error, and what else being communicated with such volume and confidence today may also be wrong. The government has a ton of moral capital tied up in fat being bad for you, so it has to be bad for you. It has to be bad. It just has to. As an individual, you may find it profitable to consider whether this is the sort of incentive structure that produces an authority you want to bet your life on. Considering whether there are similar issues where the government may have gotten stuck on a particular answer and now can not change its mind pretty much regardless of what facts come in left as an exercise for the reader.
- cornholio 11y agoBecause fat has 9 calories / gram, carbohydrates have 5 and water has zero. So while a tint of olive oil in your salad might have some theoretical health benefits if you are skinny, replacing those deep fried chips with baked chips has immediate benefits if you are overweight - you will probably eat the same quantity anyway but half the calories. Fat makes you fat without a proportional decrease in your appetite, it's as simple as that.
- msandford 11y agoRight, because carbs do wonders for satiety and fat doesn't do anything...
- saiya-jin 11y agoone thing i don't get with all these sways of opinions... everybody is so obsessed with what they eat and how much, nitpicking contents of this and that, instead of trying to match their intake with amount if activity per day. I know it's hard, i know you have to produce that nasty thing called sweat to actually achieve anything, but for christ sake... just do some activities! ideally daily, with some variability. But even half an hour early morning run every day will make huge difference in life. it will make your life longer, and more interesting in the process, in practically every aspect (yes, including sex). We are all unique, so find whatever makes you sweat and feels like fun & challenge. Heck, after not consuming processed sugars for few weeks, eating something with them is rather disgusting experience, same goes for overly fatty foods. Taste for anything natural improves HUGELY. of course, ideal scenario is good food + healthy activities. but the more you do work out, the less importance there is on quality of food to make you stay & feel healthy (this one is more complex topic, so let's say keep eating healthy). what i would propose is similar to tobacco treatment - anything clearly unhealthy, add a tax that will go directly to health system treating all those heart attacks, diabetes and other conditions that people bring upon themselves by being weak and/or stupid. i know it's not that simple, but at least that's a move into some direction...
- rhaps0dy 11y ago>after not consuming processed sugars for few weeks, eating something with them is rather disgusting experience I confirm this. I used to love honey with anything, but now that I've been avoiding it for some time, It repulses me. Maybe I should stop eating so many nuts too, and see if they become disgusting.
- mod 11y ago> add a tax that will go directly to health system treating all those Maybe I'm being a bit cynical, but I'm not sure we have any tax that that goes directly into any direct remedial use for any type of issue. I can't think of one, anyway. If tobacco tax does, then color me impressed (and surprised).
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- brandonb 11y agoWe know shockingly little about nutrition, but this paper is a great summary of what we do know from both association studies and randomized trials: http://circ.ahajournals.org/content/123/24/2870.full http://circ.ahajournals.org/content/123/24/2870.full In particular, table 2 summarizes what we know about each type of food (sodium, saturated fat, trans fat, carbs, sugar, ...) and what type of study we know it from (e.g., randomized trial or association study?): http://circ.ahajournals.org/content/123/24/2870/T2.expansion.html http://circ.ahajournals.org/content/123/24/2870/T2.expansion...) The best type of evidence you could have is a randomized trial of clinical end points--divide people randomly into (say) low fat and low carb diets, run the study for a few years, and measure what percentage of people have a heart attack. That's column 4, and it's nearly empty. The only things we seem to know are that total fat seems to be neutral, and substituting polyunsaturated fat for saturated fat reduces heart attacks. In the absence of that gold standard evidence, we're relying on weaker but more convenient types of study designs -- randomized trials that measure surrogate metrics (e.g., blood cholesterol and blood pressure), or various types of association studies. As of now, those seem to be telling us that alcohol, dietary fiber, and unsaturated fats help our risk factors for a heart attack, and trans fats, sodium, carbs, and cholesterol make our risk factors worse. But those conclusions can easily change since they're based on a surrogate, and indeed, we've already seen the recommendation against eating cholesterol reversed: http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/02/19/nutrition-panel-calls-for-less-sugar-and-eases-cholesterol-and-fat-restrictions/ http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2015/02/19/nutrition-panel-cal...
- upofadown 11y agoThe article talks about some dietary ideas that turned out to be wrong while at the same time saying stuff like "... the emphasis should be on eating more minimally processed fruits, nuts, vegetables, beans, fish, yogurt, vegetable oils and whole grains in place of refined grains, white potatoes, added sugars and processed meats.". A wrong thing in no way makes other stuff right.