3 ms·
...YouTube isn't really to blame for all of this... In the case of ContentID, which bypasses the DMCA, yes, they are to blame, along with all the media compani
by nitrogen 11y ago
...YouTube isn't really to blame for all of this...
In the case of ContentID, which bypasses the DMCA, yes, they are to blame, along with all the media companies that demanded its creation.
- dragonwriter 11y agoContentID doesn't bypass DMCA. It is neither required to take advantage of the DMCA safe harbor with regard to suits by copyright owners not compliant with the DMCA safe harbor provisions for suits by users hosting media, but it doesn't bypass anything required by the DMCA. People sometimes confuse the things which trigger DMCA safe harbor provisions with mandates but they aren't, and the only reason to be guided by them is to take advantage of the safe harbor attached to them. Real businesses often want to have better relations with big money content suppliers than the minimum required to avoid copyright liability, and can already structure their relations with end users in a way that they would have no liability for any take-down in any case, so exceeding what is necessary for the safe harbor on the content owner side while not concerning oneself with the safe harbor on the end-user side if perfectly rational, and doesn't bypass anything. It might underscore why the DMCA isn't as balanced as it seems on the surface but instead radically tilted in favor of content owners, since only one of the superficially parallel safe harbor provisions is even relevant to most hosts.
- raquo 11y ago> ContentID doesn't bypass DMCA AFAIK ContentID claims mechanism merely mimics DMCA mechanism – ContentID infringement claims are not actually DMCA notices. That means that false-positive ContentID claims basically carry no legal consequences, unlike false-positive DMCA claims (perjury). That means you can throw automated infringement notices at users knowing that X% of them will be false positives. That wouldn't work with DMCA.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> AFAIK ContentID claims mechanism merely mimics DMCA mechanism It doesn't even do that, nor is it intended to. This isn't bypassing DMCA, though. > That means you can throw automated infringement notices at users knowing that X% of them will be false positives. That wouldn't work with DMCA. Sure, but DMCA isn't even relevant. DMCA notice provisions are a requirement for content owners to bypass the DMCA liability shield for third-party hosts in filing infringement claims -- they have to file notice in accordance with the DMCA, and then if the content host doesn't act within the parameters of the safe harbor, they can pursue whatever infringement action they would, absent the DMCA liability shield, have had against the content host. DMCA notice requirements do not protect users from infringement claims, they protect content hosts. (And counter-notice requirements protect content hosts from liability claims from users stemming from take downs based on the DMCA notices.) There are no DMCA provisions that exist to protect users posting allegedly infringing content.