5 ms·
Dijkstra: Battle Between Managers / Beancounters & Technologists [pdf]
- RiderOfGiraffes 17y agoHTML, and hence searchable: http://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/EWD/transcriptions/EWD11xx/EWD1165.html http://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/EWD/transcriptions/EWD11xx/EW...
- aerique 17y agoThanks, although I'm glad the OP linked the PDF since EWD has a really nice hand-writing and I would have missed that otherwise. That said, a pretty timeless piece if somewhat black-and-white.
- hristov 17y agoI love re-reading this. BTW I always wondered about that PL/I ad and I finally found it! It is somewhere in this PDF: http://www.sas.upenn.edu/~nathanen/files/cbi-gender.pdf http://www.sas.upenn.edu/~nathanen/files/cbi-gender.pdf It is hilarious. PL/I must be incredibly easy if this cute blonde can handle it!
- Deestan 17y agoThe ads on the last two pages were breathtakingly horrible. It is hard to imagine how that sort of advertising could ever have been legal.
- eugenejen 17y agothat was the world before 1970. Law is just a set of Boolean functions of the society that defines the law. It was illegal in 1860 to have a half black half white president in U.S.
- anamax 17y ago> It was illegal in 1860 to have a half black half white president in U.S. No, it wasn't. Disagree? Point to the relevant part of the US constitution. (The 3/5ths clause isn't on point, and before you point to it, ask yourself who benefits from a higher number and who benefits from a lower number. Hint - slave states wanted a higher number....) There were free blacks in the US from before the revolution. The males were eligible to vote and hold office.
- mpakes 17y agoFascinating take on things from the perspective of academia. I've always held the same distrust of the term 'Software Engineer,' given that software development is rarely as rigorous and disciplined as actual 'Engineering.' I love Dijkstra's writings (and his penmanship, for that matter). I also quietly enjoy that most of them end by referencing my alma mater. Hook 'em Horns. :-)
- telemachos 17y ago>> The mediocre mistrust the exceptional man because they don’t understand him, and they fear him because he can do things beyond their comprehension. As far as human memory is concerned, this circumstance has led to bloody conflicts — Christ was neither the first nor the last excentric to be crucified. Someone read far too much Nietzsche that week.
- Confusion 17y agoYou cannot possibly read too much Nietzsche :). However, you can take it too serious or too literal.
- MarkPNeyer 17y agoMaybe i'm out of my league by criticizing this incredibly intelligent man's arguments, but here goes. First, Dijkstra argues, "There is no such thing as 'making money': some people succeed in transferring money out of the pockets of others into their own." The implication of his argument is that economic activity is zero sum - you can't create value, you can only take it from someone else. This is patently false - there is far more wealth in the world now than there was 100 years ago. If it is impossible to 'make money,' then where did this extra wealth come from? When I buy a computer from Dell, it's a win-win situation. Dell gets money from me, and i get a powerful tool which I could use to develop software, which I could then sell to others for more than the cost of the computer. The software that I write is wealth that I have created - the world is better off with the software in it than without the software. Dijkstra then expresses his animus against banks, saying they become rich by trying to speculate at someone else's expense. This may be true of investment banks, but what about a bank that makes loans to new businesses? Exactly whose expense are the banks profiting from? The business gets ahead because it needs capital to get off the ground, and the banks get ahead because they earn interest on money that would otherwise be sitting idle. I agree with his main argument, that 'software engineering' is a rather meaningless term, but I disagree with his hateful attitude towards the industrial world.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- lsd5you 17y agoOn making money, to a first approximation he is right. Value can of course be created, but the majority of marketing activity ('money making') is concerned with a market share land grab and nothing more. Banks aren't intrinsically sociopathic, but i think their unique position at the center of all the economic transactions means that they are especially prone to bad behaviour and distortion. They do need special regulatory treatment. You'd put even the kindliest rottweiler on a leash as a precaution, but it would be senseless to extend this to all dogs.
- gsk 17y agoIt seems you misread Dijkstra. He uses 'making money' within the context of financial 'industry' and questions the legitimacy of that 'industry' which does not produce any goods, thereby pointing out one of the many euphemisms adopted by financial sector to swindle people out of money. (Of course, one can legitimately disagree here and say that moving money where it is most useful is a useful thing to do and that's one of the good things financial sector does). Between, this essay did not seem to me at all to indicate a hateful attitude towards the industrial world.