3 ms·
"...blue photons, which are the most efficient type of photon..." Argh. Plants require light at 450 nm (blue) and light at 650 nm (red) to experience normal g
by logfromblammo 11y ago
"...blue photons, which are the most efficient type of photon..."
Argh.
Plants require light at 450 nm (blue) and light at 650 nm (red) to experience normal growth, and 730 nm (far-red) is also required to flower normally. (That last one may be important to growers of certain plants valued for their flowers and/or fruits.)
Phytochromes and photropins are the plant pigment-hormones that govern the plant life cycle. They respond to those 3 critical wavelengths of light to allow the plant to guess the time of day and the season of the year. Some plants also need a dark phase to "sleep", but it doesn't have to be as long as an actual night.
Blue light is likely most efficient at forcing the increase in green plant mass. That is, it makes bigger leaves and longer stems. That isn't always what you want for indoor farming.
The ideal indoor grow light would have a programmable, timed output of those three critical wavelengths of light, with a different ideal program for each type of plant. You may wish to start with red light, to germinate the seeds, go to blue light for rapid growth, then manipulate the plant into flowering out of season by switching between the two reds.
Transcend also needs a smaller, programmable 650/730nm light to offer a complete indoor farming solution, particularly for plants that do not get natural sunlight. It wouldn't need to use nearly as much energy, as it is being used primarily for hormonal signaling rather than photosynthesis.
- deckar01 11y agoMost efficient to produce not most efficient for plant growth. Context: "The company has developed a wavelength conversion system that uses phosphorous to convert blue photons, which are the most efficient type of photon, into any other color photon."
- logfromblammo 11y agoIf you're using phosphors, you do want to make blue or UV. It's far easier to step a photon down in energy than to absorb multiple lower energy photons and emit one at higher energy. But the highest efficiency color for LEDs to produce largely depends on what Cree and Nichia are doing this year. Unfortunately, most of the readily available numbers tout luminous efficiency rather than raw light power. That's fine if you're looking for a reading light, but chlorophyll does not have the same absorption spectrum as the opsins in the human eye. You have to look for "wall-plug efficiency", which is less commonly reported. So with respect to photons emitted per watt, I'm not sure which LED chemistry takes the prize. It depends on the temperature and input power, too. You can achieve 200% wall-plug efficiency, but only if you're converting picowatts of electricity into picowatts of photons in a hot LED. This is not possible (economically) for grow lights. The benchmark for grow lights is the low-pressure sodium lamp, at about 38% efficiency. LEDs maybe get 30-65%, considering transformers, internal resistance, quantum efficiency, reflective losses at the die-capsule interface, etc. Higher efficiency comes from more expensive components. As for chemistry, InGaN efficiency drops at longer wavelengths, and AlInGaP efficiency drops at shorter wavelengths, leaving a big efficiency trough in the green range. (Fortunately for this, plants don't need green.) I suspect that AlInGaP LEDs in the orange range are more efficient than visible blue InGaN LEDs, but this is hard to show with a lazy web search. So when you say "most efficient" you really have to be very explicit about the application. That was my implied complaint about that sentence in the article.