2 ms·
The phenomenon is not unique to the FP community by any means, though it is more prevalent there in my experience. I've seen it in OOP, C, Java, et al communiti
by jandrewrogers 11y ago
The phenomenon is not unique to the FP community by any means, though it is more prevalent there in my experience. I've seen it in OOP, C, Java, et al communities as well and I think it is more attributable to how people interact with the language philosophies than the languages themselves.
In my opinion, the phenomenon arises from a simple fact: all of these programming models are terrible for writing some significant subset of software functionality. Just because you can write any piece of software in FP, OOP, etc does not mean it isn't an objectively poor engineering decision some of the time. Nonetheless, I frequently see assertions in various communities that these apparent deficiencies are really due to insufficient cleverness on the part of implementors rather fundamental weaknesses in the model for the use case, while ignoring real-world engineering constraints like cost, performance, and maintainability.
The perception of arrogance, or lack thereof, largely reflects the willingness of a community to acknowledge the fundamental weaknesses and deficiencies of their chosen programming model when interacting with people outside the community. Too often, people that question the objective limitations of a particular model are told that if they were smarter or better educated, they would not worry about those limitations. For obvious reasons, this comes across as arrogant.
One of great changes in programming languages over the last 20 years is the extent to which they have become relatively model agnostic and allow you to switch models fluidly. FP remains one of the last bastions of single model purists in my experience, which may explain why they are perceived as more arrogant by outsiders.