3 ms·
There's always going to be a limit to how well any macroscopic analogy can possibly describe what's going on with photons and light, but some metaphors work bet
by jameshart 11y ago
There's always going to be a limit to how well any macroscopic analogy can possibly describe what's going on with photons and light, but some metaphors work better than others. the trouble with the 'light is a particle and a wave' meme is that people try to combine two mental images - a cannonball flying through the air, and n ocean wave moving up and down, or a sound wave moving back and forth, and get a completely weird mental image of a cannonball flying along a sinewave path, or speeding up and slowing down. This isn't helpful.
Instead, you need to extend the metaphor in a different direction. Let's keep photons as cannonballs flying in straight lines. But now, imagine the cannonballs are constantly spinning. Some are spinning fast - they have a lot of rotational energy - they rotate with a high frequency. Others are spinning more slowly - low frequency, low energy cannonballs.
Now, which way are they spinning? Some have topspin or backspin, meaning they have a horizontal spin axis; some have sidespin - their axis of spin is vertical. Others might be spinning in a spiral - as if the barrel they came out of was rifled - so their axis of spin is aligned with the axis they're flying along.
You can imagine lots of cannonballs all flying along the same path, at the same speed, but they can all have different spin frequencies, and be spinning around different axes. Amplitude means more cannonballs. Higher frequency means more cannonballs spinning faster. Polarization means all the cannonballs are spinning round the same axis. Coherence (like in a laser) means all the cannonballs are spinning at the same speed and are pointing the same way as they pass the same point.
This maybe works better as a way to layer on the additional attributes a photon has - a frequency and a polarization - than to try to imagine some sort of transverse wave pattern. It also helps you deal with the idea of 'how do different photons carry different amounts of energy?'.
But, this is just a metaphor. Photons aren't really spinning cannonballs. It doesn't explain why thin slits cause polarization (and gives you a probably somewhat intuitive but definitely very wrong explanation for why bouncing photons off a surface causes polarization, so be careful.). It won't get you one jot closer to understanding quantum mechanics (no classical metaphor can do that), but it might just help you visualize how light can have mixtures of frequencies, polarizations, and amplitude, while still being just a bunch of particles.