5 ms·
There are lots of nice people in FP circles and nobody ever said there wasn't. But I think the author is taking the use of the word "arrogant" much too literall
by eropple 11y ago
There are lots of nice people in FP circles and nobody ever said there wasn't. But I think the author is taking the use of the word "arrogant" much too literally--its users generally don't mean arrogant, they politely mean asshole.
My sense, from spending a decent chunk of time in a couple different communities, is that they don't do enough policing of their jerks and that that makes itself most apparent to novices rather than established people. Many programming communities don't handle jerks well, for a host of reasons around social standing and conflict avoidance, but of the ones I regularly participate, I don't think a guy like Scala's I-think-I-can-use-the-adjective-"infamous" Tony Morris--though granted, he seems to wish he was Haskell's Tony Morris--would be tolerated past weeks, to say nothing of years.
I really like functional programming. But I find that notions like "shared-immutable programming" are more accepted by people who've been burned by the more socially toxic sections of the universe. The rebrand helps remove the association with the jerks, and that should speak to the impact of those jerks.
- dec0dedab0de 11y agogenerally don't mean arrogant, they politely mean asshole. Is it possible to be arrogant without being an asshole? I always took arrogant to mean a specific type of asshole.
- hyperpape 11y agoI think it's worth not saying "arrogant" when you mean "asshole". The reason is that there are people who will politely imply that anything but functional programming is worse, and they're different from the people who will do that while acting like you're scum or stupid for not realizing it. There's a fine line as to whether any statement is arrogant and a lot of it actually comes down to presentation. To what extent do you act like your views are obvious, or abuse the word "objective"? Is the person who maintains that FP is better arrogant or not? I think that comes down to a mixture of framing (let's be clear about which things are "objective" and which are opinion), and intellectual humility. In any case, I think we should separate that from the fact that there are at least a couple of true assholes out there.
- eropple 11y ago> I think it's worth not saying "arrogant" when you mean "asshole". Well, sure! But you have to recognize the sorts of people you're dealing with, yeah? Software developers, as a whole, are not exactly awesome at the interpersonal thing, especially when conflict comes up. So circumlocutions and euphemisms are kind of foreseeable there. Which is of course a really unfortunate thing, because it allows useful idiots to go "well, I don't see arrogance" in a way that lets them implicitly excuse the real rot in the pile, but there you have it.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- rjsw 11y agoThe person who used to spam OCaml stuff to comp.lang.lisp matched your definition.
- bad_user 11y agoWhile I have received some helpful advice from Tony Morris on the Scalaz mailing list, I think that attitudes like his are poisonous. And actually, it's because of such issues that some are attempting a Scalaz fork: http://underscore.io/blog/posts/2015/06/10/an-introduction-to-cats.html http://underscore.io/blog/posts/2015/06/10/an-introduction-t... On the other hand such an attitude is not representative of the Scala community, which is filled with really nice and helpful people. I just went to Scala Days in Amsterdam and everybody I've met was super nice. Try it sometimes. What is "shared-immutable programming"?
- eropple 11y ago> What is "shared-immutable programming"? "Share nothing that isn't immutable." =) I like it more than "shared-nothing", because I share tons of stuff, it's just all inherently thread-safe and simple.
- mcguire 11y agoCould you list us some programming communities that do handle jerks well? 'Cause I'm having a hard time thinking of any.
- eropple 11y agoI think that the Ruby community (at least, the parts I run into--I can't speak to Rails, but Ruby proper) has stabilized into a generally friendly environment. For a long time I steered clear of Ruby because of the outside perception of a lack of seriousness and a lot of silly slap-fighting, but since moving to it for most of my devops-type stuff over the last couple years I've had generally fantastic experiences, the whole MINSWAN thing seems to be taken seriously. It seems like the Rust community has taken a lot of the DNA of the Ruby community around personal interaction, too? Not really connected there, so just speculating. I also think that the parts of the .NET community I'm exposed to on a regular basis are professional, calm, and not prone to asshattery. YM, of course, MV. =)
- Tehnix 11y agoGenerally it is unpleasant dealing with unpleasant people. Sometimes though, if a question has been asked many times or if people end up talking past each other, hostility can arise and the ones answering can start becoming a bit snarky. I would say #haskell is usually very friendly, but no community is perfect. I noticed the above once and it was actually quite easy and simple to fix it. I simply joined in on the ongoing question session and started implying that we should perhaps answer a bit more nice to the newcomer.