10 ms·
Time Warner Cable owes $229K to woman it would not stop calling
- backprojection 11y agoI find it odd that there's no universal system for blocking calls from specific numbers. I'm guessing you could implement a spam filter, so Harassment/telemarketing wouldn't be a problem.
- zitterbewegung 11y agoConsolidation of all of the phone companies would help but then you run into the problem of someone changing their phone number when you block them .
- krschultz 11y agoIndeed, our current phone system makes it incumbent upon the person getting harassed to change their number. 25+ years ago there was someone angry at my parents that used to call in the middle of the night until they changed their (unlisted) number, over and over. Not sure why the person eventually stopped, I guess the game got old. It kind of points to the fact that long before the internet existed, we were bad at building systems that allowed victims of harassment to have any recourse against abusers.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoHow did they repeatedly obtain the unlisted number?
- jdeibele 11y agoThe caller didn't get the new number, they repeatedly called the old number until it was changed. Or that's how I read it. The wording is a little confusing.
- leephillips 11y agoI'm not sure I understand correctly what you mean, but you can either block or send to immediate voicemail individual numbers if you use Google Voice for your phone number.
- anigbrowl 11y agoI don't find it that odd, but what I do find odd is that in these days of smartphones the software dialers don't make it trivially easy to block incoming calls. You have to choose an app if you want to block calls and most people are understandably a bit hesitant to replace the default app that came with the phone with some third-party one of unknown provenance. This is a pity, because if users could easily share telemarketing blocklists and so on you could shut down abusive calling industries very very easily.
- jen729w 11y agoNot true for the iPhone: just add the number to a contact, and block the contact. I have a contact "Blocked Telemarketers" for exactly this purpose. Every time a new one hits me, I just add its number to this contact. Trivially easy.
- NeutronBoy 11y agoSame for Android. Add to a contact, in the contact options you can send it straight to Voicemail.
- click170 11y agoI use a similar feature on Android. What I really want though is a very simple feature. I don't want my phone to accept phone calls unless the number is in my address book already. Its so straightforward and already implemented in other communication mediums, I do not understand why it is not a feature yet. Just one vendor including this feature would force all of them to. My parents do this the old fashioned way. They don't pickup unless they recognize the number. In fact, my colleagues do the same, and this has actually caused problems for On call if the colleague calling at 4am isn't in the callee's circle of friends.
- jordanthoms 11y agoAndroid 5+ (or maybe 5.1) includes this - you can set it to priority notifications only, and then turn calls on but say to only include calls from your contacts.
- HarryHirsch 11y agoThis is the best argument against "personal responsibility" ever. I don't want to protect myself from Comcast bothering me, I want them to observe courtesy. We have laws for that.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoGood luck with getting bill collectors and salesmen to observer courtesy. Hasn't happened in 5 centuries.
- wtallis 11y agoIt goes hand in hand with the fact that there's no reliable system for identifying the origin of an incoming call. Telcos won't let Caller ID information be reliable enough to be used for blocking purposes, so there's clearly a lot of money in aiding and abetting the telemarketers/scammers.
- UnoriginalGuy 11y agoLet's assume caller ID info is perfect, that doesn't actually solve the issue. If a telco gives a local business e.g. 100 numbers, and when those numbers call out it says "Whatever business, 123 main street, somecity" you'd just see the VoIP provider's info each time a scammer calls you. Right now you can often determine the address/owner of a telephone number, but that doesn't tell you who REALLY called because the VoIP company never passes on that info even to the telcos. What we need is a law that forces VoIP providers (inc. Skype) to forward some real caller ID info onto the telcos, and then the telcos need to forward that info to the end user. The insecurity of the caller ID system (i.e. it is trivially spoofed) is a legitimate problem however, since even if the VoIP provider did pass on the info, the scammer could override it.
- mintplant 11y ago> you'd just see the VoIP provider's info each time a scammer calls you Then we could blacklist VoIP providers that act as a haven for scammers, as we do with hosting providers that offer the same to email spammers.
- nitrogen 11y agoIt seems it would be better just to outlaw spoofing the identity of another entity (to prevent SWATting), but still allow blocked number calls. Spoofing numbers for fraud should also be deterred somehow. Even without this, one could develop Bayesian filters to detect likely spam calls and run them through a captcha first.
- raverbashing 11y ago> It goes hand in hand with the fact that there's no reliable system for identifying the origin of an incoming call. Probably because of legacy issues In the same way you don't know the internal IP of a connection to a webserver Caller ID is sent by the initiating exchange, and it is not used for the backwards connection See the ISDN specs for more details
- ars 11y agoI think most VoIP providers let you block calls. Google voice does as well. As do most Cell providers, plus you can install apps on jailbroken cell phones that will do that. It's really only POTS that doesn't have such functionality.
- guessbest 11y agoThis can be implemented on a PSTN, but I doubt any providers would bother to do it for a single, private customer. Shame really.
- CWuestefeld 11y agoThis is precisely why I moved to VoIP. At least a couple of times a month for about a year, we'd get a fax call at around 2am. The phone company refused to do anything about it, saying that if it wasn't explicitly harassing, it was OK. That makes me not want to be their customer anymore. So we switched to a VoIP service, which we can set up blacklists or whitelists for as we like. No more problems. I think the underlying problem is that the TelCo just doesn't care: they're happy to lose you as a POTS customer. They lose money on residential service, so if they can go by the book for regulatory purposes and still shed those unprofitable customers, they're winning.
- byuu 11y agoMy phone has a call-blocking feature, and I even use a service that routes private callers through an 800-number to get their unspoofed ANI. Yet one debt collector calls me from 200 different numbers. They change the number every 2-3 days. (it's for a debt I consider invalid, and beyond the 10 year statute of limitations anyway, so I won't ever pay it.) I think what we need is an Adblock for phone numbers that categorizes all spammers, debt collectors, etc and blocks them instantly on everyone's phones.
- Magicstatic 11y agoWith this ruling by the FCC, you might not need to anymore... http://www.autodialerauthority.com/fcc-approves-new-autodialer-restrictions-to-protect-consumers/ http://www.autodialerauthority.com/fcc-approves-new-autodial...
- joshmn 11y agoI'm guessing you're talking about Trapcall? TelAPI has such neat features.
- byuu 11y agoYep, didn't want to seem like I was advertising. It's a bit pricey, and annoying that we have to use such tricks to unmask private callers.
- rwallace 11y agoSounds like the practical near-term solution would be a white list: only allow calls from a list of known callers.
- RogerL 11y agoIf you mean what I think you mean I think that is unworkable for most of us. Drop your car off at the shop for some work. Mechanic calls you from his cell phone because it's handy and the shop line is tied up. You never get it. Or school nurse calls you about an emergency. Neighbor calls you to tell you your dog got out from the back yard. That kind of stuff is about the only reason I have voice service - I don't use the damn thing to talk for the most part.
- prawn 11y agoIn Australia, there's not even a useful national system for registering to not receive unsolicited commercial calls. I can register a personal number on a Do Not Call list, but there are exemptions for political parties, charities, religious organisations and market researchers. Market researchers and charities make a lot of calls. There is no equivalent for business numbers. And then on top of that, there are countless telemarketing calls from overseas. The latest frustration on my business number is outsourcing spammers calling to explain that they will be sending me (spam) email in a moment and telling me the title of the attachment, etc. So, spam plus an interrupting phone call - fantastic! Thanks subcontinent!
- tomjen3 11y agoThere is a danish guy who started answering all business spam calls with "we do not use X" here - so they would call up and ask for whomever was in charge of lighting and he would say "we do not use lighting here", then spin a story about how they just used very bright monitors etc. You might be able to have some fun with them at least - or just abuse the heck out of them (unfortunately telemarketers seem pretty blasee about it). As for your private line, if you don't recognize the number just don't answer it? My cellphone blocks all calls during the night (with an exception for families) but I think it can block all numbers not in my contacts.
- prawn 11y agoMy co-tenant pays various utility bills so I already respond that I don't pay an electricity bill, water bill, etc - that usually leaves callers quite puzzled. It's the pointless interruption I can't stand.
- chris_overseas 11y agoI've been using an Android app called "Mr Number" [1] for a few years now to help block nuisance calls. One of it's more useful features is its use of crowdsourcing to identify spam numbers and automatically block them right from the first time they try to call you. There's a bunch of other similar Android apps (presumably for iOS too?) that are worth a look too, depending on your particular needs. See the "Similar" section on the link below. [1] https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.mrnumber.blocker https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.mrnumber.b...
- ajanuary 11y agoiOS doesn't expose the necessary APIs to be able to filter calls.
- robin_reala 11y agoHuh? What does Phone / Recents / ⓘ by the number that called you / Block this Caller do then? Edit: oh, API for use by another app. Gotcha.
- geon 11y agoiOS has that capability internally, obviously. But there's no API for 3:rd party apps to access that data, or to intercept calls.
- dredmorbius 11y agoI'd used Mr. Number for a while, and even recommended it at one point. Its increasingly overreaching permissions demands, especially over contacts, lead me to drop it. I've since switched to a feature phone due to concerns with Android privacy generally, though my frustrations in not being able to screen or filter calls, on a whitelist basis, are high. Telephony generally is in desperate need of radical updating, with both control and privacy as major concerns.
- 72deluxe 11y ago
- cmdkeen 11y agoThere's a new device in the UK, "BT Call Guardian" which basically has a whitelist/blacklist system and then anyone else gets answered by the device, without your phone ringing. The device explains what is going on and asks the caller to say their name. The phone then rings and the device says who is calling and you then decide whether to answer, ignore or add to blacklist. One of my colleagues absolutely swears by it.
- kennydude 11y agoI'm sure this is a rebadged thing as I've heard of something similar a few years ago, so it should be better than BT doing it themselves.
- tempodox 11y agoiOS has that, for numbers in your address book.
- EGreg 11y agoThere is a lawyer who makes a nice amount every year (more than an average Silicon Valley salary) suing the telemarketers that call him. I was wondering if such a lawyer would partner with others -- but anyway he released a book on how to be a parasite on parasites and get paid doing a service to society. Does anyone have a link? http://www.amazon.com/How-Sue-Telemarketer-Stephen-Ostrow/dp/0615338178 http://www.amazon.com/How-Sue-Telemarketer-Stephen-Ostrow/dp...
- ajmurmann 11y ago$229K? Time Warner won't even notice that's gone. Should have been $229 million otherwise they won't learn anything from this.
- Hermel 11y agoWhy should business units that are part of a large company be punished harder than those who are part of a small company? Do you also believe that people with high life expectancy should stay longer in prison? A fine should be based on the damage done. The 1500$ per phone call in this case already seem excessive to me. What's the damage of getting distracted by an unwanted phone call? 2$? 10$? 15$?`Certainly not 1500$.
- wpietri 11y agoThat is one way to do it, but not the only way. Scandinavia, for example, bases fines on income: http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/03/finland-home-of-the-103000-speeding-ticket/387484/ http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/03/finland-... The theory here is that punishment is meant to change behavior, so the impact has to be proportional. > What's the damage of getting distracted by an unwanted phone call? Even on this theory, you have to scale the damages in relation to the odds of getting away with it. Suppose I run a store and steal a dollar from each customer. Let's say only 1 in 1000 notices and cares enough to talk to the police. Should my fine be $1, which is negligible? $1,000, so I break even? Or greater, so that there's an actual penalty?
- vacri 11y agoThe public transport system in my hometown of Melbourne has a two-tiered fine system if you're caught travelling without a ticket. ~$75 if you pay on the spot (but you forfeit the right to contest in court) or $250 if you don't. They were actually losing a few court cases, so brought in the two-tiered system. I call it the 'fuck the poor' system, because poor people generally don't have the ability to pay $75 on demand. Paying $75 is a lot more convenient than having to find time and the know-how to contest things in court. For comparison, a day's travel costs ~$7.50. I'd heartily welcome an income-scaled penalty system, even though I am not poor myself. A fine that is crushing to poor people is a mere momentary inconvenience for wealthy people, which isn't the point of being penalised.
- tomerico 11y agoIs there anything I could do in a similar situation? I receive robocalls from several sketchy locations multiple times a day. I installed a call blocker on my phone which sometimes works, but would love to make it stop.
- guessbest 11y agoI use Google Voice. It picks up the spam pretty efficiently.
- michaelrkn 11y agoI sued a telemarketer once and got a few thousand dollars: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4023834 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4023834
- squeaky-clean 11y agoThat was a great read! And thank you for providing sources on the laws. I've been getting cell phone calls for years now, several times a week, from companies asking for someone who isn't me, mostly debt collectors, but also home security sales. It's always the same name, and I'm pretty sure this person is using my phone number as a fake number for themselves (or maybe it's just an area code mistake or something). I've told them many times they have a wrong number and to stop calling. Do you know if this still applies when someone else has a relationship with the business but is providing false information? I'm not great at reading legal documents, but it seems like the definition of telemarketer only applies to sales and charitable donations (so it won't apply to the creditors)?
- staticelf 11y ago$229K for 150+ calls? Please tell TWC to call me! Unfortunately for me though, there is never such crazy amounts when suing in the country where I reside.
- interpol_p 11y agoIt seems reasonable. The article states that almost half the calls occurred after she had sued them and well after she had objected to the calls and corrected her identity with the company.
- notahacker 11y agoA payout of $229k is a terribly large payout for a minor irritation caused by sheer incompetence on the part of the defendant. Lives and limbs are frequently valued lower. I mean, the average British mobile phone owner probably receives 100 or so irritating automated telemarketing calls a year, all of them worthless spam and many of them originating from the same party - can we all have $229k too?
- keithpeter 11y agoI'd settle for £22.90 actually, I've had to change number to get away from the spam calls but my investment in the old number was really low.
- dickbasedregex 11y agoAttacking a bank account is really the only thing that makes a difference. Also, by all means, make an example out of a few of these organizations. Adhere to the law or suffer.
- morganvachon 11y agoIt's a punitive charge, designed to get the company to realize the cost of their gross negligence. Besides, I'd be willing to bet that 90% of it went to the plaintiff's lawyers.
- vacri 11y ago
- fractallyte 11y agoBetter yet, encourage nuisance callers! If you're in the UK, it's possible to set up a 'premium rate' phone number - which means the caller has to pay to call you. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-23869462 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-23869462
- anotherevan 11y agoI have an old analogue modem hooked to our phone line, so when we receive an incoming call the number pops up on my computer screen (and the lounge TV screen if XMBC is being used at the time.) It is also cross-referenced with my address book so if it is a known number, it also displays the name of the caller. One problem though is here in Australia, a lot of telemarketers, etc., have the caller ID comes up as private. Also, my mum, mother-in-law, sister-in-law and one of my clients all have private numbers, so that’s five likely sources when I see a private number. The problem is there’s only one of those sources I actually want to talk to (not saying which one, but it aint the telemaketers.) Would love a device similar to the one cmdkeen mentioned available in the UK that will screen unknown numbers and voice prompt them. I’ve occasionally pondered using Asterisk or similar open-source PBX to create a system like that. However it is in the queue behind about four other pet projects…
- freehunter 11y agoMy mom used to have a private number for work reasons, and I told her if she called me to leave a voicemail and I would call her back. I don't pick up private numbers for any reason.
- incarnate 11y agoTelstra are selling the "Call Guardian 301" as well now which sounds like the same device as cmdkeen mentioned: https://www.telstra.com.au/home-phone/handsets https://www.telstra.com.au/home-phone/handsets
- anotherevan 11y agoHey thanks for that! I'll check it out.
- tomjen3 11y agoIt seems the solution here is to get your mother-in-law to stop calling you from a private number. Really private numbers are like slapping people in the face - you need to pick up on telemarketers just so that you will pick up on if I happen to call.
- rjempson 11y agoShe won the lottery.
- kendallpark 11y agoIt is refreshing to see the common person prevailing against Big Corp.