8 ms·
China’s Family Planning Goes Awry
- wglb 17y agoAn excellent article about the profound demographic implications of China's decades old one-child policy.
- teyc 17y agoThere will be change, but not necessarily bad. 1. The lack of marriageable women is a problem that can be solved by time. Men are prepared to marry at 40 if their work prospects are good. 2. The advent of low trust societies that doesn't rely on guanxi, but on merit can be a boon rather than a detriment. Cronyism can only go that far in a society where all are alone. 3. The absence of economic growth is a political one. In an overpopulated country, there is no such thing as sustainable growth. Whereas in the past, there are wars, disease, famine and mass slaughter to reset the population numbers, controlling fertility is the least worst option, and one that can be done voluntarily. 4. Looking after the aged is a necessity in the ages of pre-mechanization. Today, the basic needs of many can be provided by a few.
- pyre 17y agoThe one thing that they don't mention is the female children that are abandoned so that the parents can try for a son (due to cultural preference for a son to be the family successor and support the parents in old age). (i.e. not aborted, but born and then abandoned; causing the need for orphanages to take them in)
- DTrejo 17y agoThere is no inexpensive way to check the sex of a child before it is too late to abort?
- pyre 17y agoI assume that maybe the abortion is too expensive or the check is. This might only be happening in rural (i.e. poor) areas. I don't know all of the details. In the example that I saw of one of these orphanages, the girls were all in their teens. Maybe this is a problem of the past (due to newer tech)?
- evgen 17y agoPortable ultrasound machines is the reason. Now it is cheap and easy to determine fetus gender, rather than waiting for the child to be born before you decide to abandon it.
- ams6110 17y agoYeah it's rather difficult to check the sex of a child before it's conceived.
- thijsterlouw 17y agoit is illegal in china to check the sex of an unborn child (of course if you pay enough at private clinics, you can still do it). Public hospitals probably will not dare to do it.
- oldgregg 17y ago"Never fight a land war in Asia." ...unless you have 30 million single, angsty, poorly educated men...
- evgen 17y ago> The lack of marriageable women is a problem that can be solved by time. Men are prepared to marry at 40 if their work prospects are good. This is a very naive conclusion. Human societies deal reasonably well with a large female:male ratio (usually after a war) but large male:female ratios usually leads to war, revolution, or unpleasant social changes like fast increases in violent crime rates and similar problems. This has happened in the past on smaller scales, but in this case you are talking about regions with 10s of millions of young men who have almost no chance at reaching the societal norm of a wife and child -- they are not going to be pleased when the reality of the situation starts to make itself apparent. If men are prepared to wait until they are older and richer then you will find this cohort out-competing their younger, poorer peers for an ever-dwindling supply of young women. This just leads to a repetition of the cycle but with more and more competitors fighting over the pool of "resources." This is not a situation that is just going to fix itself unless there is a radical change to family planning laws, societal norms, the role of women, etc. The only thing that can really be said is that the solution will be painful and its consequences could end up being quite far-reaching...
- bilbo0s 17y agoYou haven't been to China have you. Do you have any idea how many women from Korea, Malaysia, Indonesia etc. etc. etc. are DESPERATE to get into China? SOLELY for the purpose of latching onto a man? Even African women are trying to get in on the action. Student visa my @$$! Not unless they are studying for an M-R-S degree! I have seen this first hand. A shortage of 30 or 40 million women? Believe me when I tell you . . . the Chinese Government knows this won't be a problem. It really won't. Believe me.
- baguasquirrel 17y agoSo then the problem is exported to other countries. Two of those countries you just named have fundamentalist Islamist elements.
- gaius 17y agoIslamic countries have already had this problem - what do you do when rich, powerful men have 4 wives, and female children are lower priority for food, medical care, etc, so there are already fewer of them and extra-marital sex is frowned on? Well, many of those young men band together and go and live in the mountains... We call them Taliban.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- ivenkys 17y agoFascinating article on the change in demographics and composition of the family unit in China.
- jrockway 17y agoUpmodded because the Captcha at the bottom of the article displays its source code. https://www.feer.com/manager/includes/veriword.php?rand=hello https://www.feer.com/manager/includes/veriword.php?rand=hell... Change "rand" and watch the background change.
- brianobush 17y agoInteresting how a simple policy can lead to large imbalances in the natural population (at many levels: SBR, social, labor, etc). Wonder what other policies that other countries have instituted that lead to similar manifestations?
- mitjak 17y agoHow exactly is this a simple policy?
- whatusername 17y agoBecause you can state it in one sentance. Compare it to an ETS or something similar. You could create the laws for a one-chile policy very very simply.
- Kliment 17y agoIndeed, there don't seem to be too many Chiles sprouting. Seriously though, linguistic complexity as a measure of legal policy complexity (comparable to Kolmogorov complexity maybe?). It's not a bad idea. Would translating legalese to human increase or reduce the linguistic complexity of specific laws?
- Evgeny 17y ago"Through locally determined birth targets, vigilant surveillance of prospective mothers, and state pressures ranging from the threat of job loss to crippling financial penalties and involuntary forced abortion, the policy has already driven China's birth rate far down—below the replacement level" So what about the countries where the birth rate went below the replacement level naturally, without government intervention? Are they facing the same problems in the future as China or not, and why? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sub-replacement_fertility http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sub-replacement_fertility Today about 42% of the world population lives in nations with sub-replacement fertility.[citation needed] The countries or areas that have the lowest fertility are Hong Kong, Macau, Singapore, Taiwan, Ukraine and Lithuania.
- mbrubeck 17y agoYes, many countries with low birth rates are facing the same problems. This long NYT Magazine article from 2008 has some interesting stories from different countries (mostly in Europe): http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/29/magazine/29Birth-t.html?_r=1&partner=rssuserland&emc=rss&pagewanted=all http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/29/magazine/29Birth-t.html?_r...
- dkokelley 17y agoI think the difference might be that in China, the TFR is regulated, while the nation's economy is growing rapidly. In a declining economy, it would make sense that fewer children are being born, since the parents on average can't support as many, but in a growing economy, we would usually see many more children being born because times are good, and parents can afford to care for more children - something that isn't being allowed in China. Also keep in mind that according to that Wikipedia article, the US is also below the replacement level. I think the article intends to focus more on the social implications that the policy has.
- Mz 17y agoIn a declining economy, it would make sense that fewer children are being born, since the parents on average can't support as many, but in a growing economy, we would usually see many more children being born because times are good, and parents can afford to care for more children - something that isn't being allowed in China. WWII dragged America (and the world) out of The Great Depression and into the post-war boom. Part of how that happened: American families were forced into having two incomes (so the wife could work in the factory and the husband could be in the army), no new children being conceived/born (what with hubby being off at war on another continent) and war time rationing forced very high savings rates on America -- as high as 50% at one point -- because there wasn't much to spend your dual income on (especially since they were also encouraging people to grow "Victory Gardens"). We went from people moving every 13 months to take advantage of new rental deals (where you got the 13th month free if you could make your rent the first 12) before the war to Levittowns sprouting like mushrooms to try desperately to meet the sudden high demand for middle class housing after the war. So it's not like something like this has never happened before. Maybe nothing so protracted, but the precedent I am aware of is generally considered to be a good thing.
- ars 17y agoSome of the problems can be alleviated if you don't assume that people stop working at 64. If people kept working at an older age, and that age kept increasing, the workforce size could stay stable, and possibly even grow. The unmarried men problem is unsolvable barring a war. (And with the very very low death rates of wars these days, even that might not "help".) Expect to see china legalize prostitution soon. They are almost not going to have a choice. There is one other effect you will see. There is going to be intense competition for wives in china. Only the best will get one. Over time this natural selection should have very interesting implications for china. I'm not sure what women in china look for (height? looks? brains?), (I'm not going to assume it's the same as in other countries). But whatever it is, these women will be shaping china's future. One thing you should not expect is a dramatic change. It will be gradual, very very gradual. So I guess people will adjust.
- chrischen 17y ago> I'm not sure what women in china look for (height? looks? brains?), (I'm not going to assume it's the same as in other countries). But whatever it is, these women will be shaping china's future. They look for wealth. Most would probably want to lift themselves out of poverty. > The unmarried men problem is unsolvable barring a war. (And with the very very low death rates of wars these days, even that might not "help".) I'd bet that the PLA is less developed than the US armed forces enough that the casualty rate would be much higher if they were in Afghanistan or Iraq. The US should contract the PLA to fight in Afghanistan and Iraq. Kill 2 birds with one stone.
- middus 17y ago"Kill 2 birds with one stone." I find your post extremely disgusting.
- jefftown 17y agoMaybe everything is just going to get a lot gayer in China. Not that there is anything wrong with that, it seems like a pretty good solution actually.
- donaldc 17y agoI've been wondering for a while now why China doesn't back off to a two-child policy. Most of the problems caused by the one-child policy would go away or be greatly eased, and yet the population would still attain stasis. I've put it down to organizational inertia. Really, given that population trends in most countries are headed towards or are under replacement level, they could probably just ditch the n-child policy altogether, but I don't think the government of China is capable of making such a momentous change any time soon.
- snagage 17y agoFrom what I understand, if both mother and father are single children - there actually is a two-child policy in action
- donaldc 17y agoPerhaps, but there doesn't seem to be any terribly good reason at this point not to always allow two children.
- tokenadult 17y agoI've been wondering for a while now why China doesn't back off to a two-child policy. People with enough money or connections can have all the children they desire. Men who divorce and remarry get at least one child per wife, and women who can pay fines can have more than one child also.
- donaldc 17y agoExcellent point! That explains it...
- jhancock 17y agoThe policies are uneven (at least unevenly enforced) throughout China. Currently: * Peasants (a crude/outdated name, but its the one commonly used) have little to no government punishment for having more than one child. Most don't because they cannot afford it and do want to attempt to give their one child the best they can to enable them to move up in society. * Farmers (a subset of peasants) also can't afford it, but having more hands to help many times outweighs the costs of education and health care which they can't afford for even one child. * Couples of any class who are single children are allowed to have 2 children. * Wealthy that rely on government for their continued prosperity (which is most) usually do not have more than one child despite their ability to afford government fines and lack of social support.
- snagage 17y agoAlthough the content of the article is interesting, I don't like how the author is basically concluding: Because the one-child policy is introducing dynamics that are different from the past, it's dangerous. Most things are not any different from those currently experienced by western countries: declining fertility rate, aging population, etc. The only thing that's really in the unfamiliar territory is the male:female ratio imbalance. What would really have been unprecedented was if the one-child policy was not implemented and population kept growing unabated. I personally think there would be alot of social problems had this been the case.
- cakesy 17y agoWhat a fantastic piece of ignorance. Of course, as far as economists are concerned countries should just keep growing forever, and never worry about the ills that such stupidity would bring. The working population is the most important thing ever, nothing else matters. Thankfully China has ignored morons like this guy.
- wheels 17y agoThe thing that's different from China and the West in this case is that China is doing this before its economy has matured. Growth of a labor force and economic expansion tend to go hand in hand, often through immigration if not birth rate.
- baguasquirrel 17y agoI couldn't agree more. What would be sadistically amusing in the context of this problem is if another "black swan" event occurred, like a famine caused altered global weather patterns. All the countries with shrinking populations ought to fare a lot better if some such thing were to happen. Who knows what the future will bring? It's arguable that they should probably turn around that one-child policy now, but China's had far too many people anyway. 1 billion is far too many for a space that small. China's hinterland ain't no American dream. The actual habitable land in China is only about a third to a quarter of what you see on the map.
- araneae 17y agoYes, an aging population is a problem in any country that's seen a drop in fertility rates. This effect is actually the worst in Japan, followed by Italy. re: lack of women The nice possibilities are polyandry, in which one female marries multiple males. Another is the the devaluing of males. I.e. because of the rareness of females, males may some how compensate their families, and girls could become more valuable for parents to have. A third "nice" possibility would be to import females from other countries, or for males to emigrate to higher female areas. This would diffuse the problem, although if China's population becomes high enough it will just spread the problem to everyone. The not-so-nice possibilities include increased male-male competition for mates (which happens in all species, including humans; single males are much more likely to be murdered or be murderers than their married counterparts/women in all cultures.) In history, it would be quite common for violence to occur at least in part for the purpose of procuring more females. We can't predict it, but there's likely to be some sort of fallout. Maybe there's a technological solution: androids? Virtual reality brides? Prostitution? The excess boys need something to keep them occupied. Perhaps porn will be sufficient.
- kalendae 17y agoin terms of just fertility rate problem (not the gender ratio) the difference between japan, western europe, and china is that china has more or less the option to change policy and tune the fertility number where as others do not.
- daltonlp 17y agoIt's been one generation since the Once-child policy was introduced. I believe that in another generation, China's example will be seen as a smart and forward-thinking idea. It'll be pretty easy to test whether I'm right or wrong. To the south of China is India, a country of comparable population size with no centralized family planning.
- wheels 17y ago> It'll be pretty easy to test whether I'm right or wrong... Whoa, there. That's assuming that all other important variables in the social dynamics happen to be identical between India and China. That's so far from the truth that it'd be difficult to make any conclusions from a sample set of those nations.
- baguasquirrel 17y agoOh even better. Then we have the effectiveness of a totalitarian free-market regime, a perversion of the Soviet communist model, vs. a social-bureaucratic regime, a perversion of the Western republican model. I can't wait for the fireworks and popcorn on this one.
- araneae 17y agoWell, the irony is that re: population control, it seems to happen naturally with the development of Western civ ideas (i.e. feminism.) China doesn't even begin to have the lowest r(growth rate); Japan has that honor, followed by Italy, then the rest of Europe. The second you give women the opportunity to work instead of raise a pack of squalling children, they seem to prefer work. However, China is very anti-feminist and is aborting all their women, thereby impeding the natural events which could lead to an even lower r. So I'm not sure it's correct to say that their lead is the best to follow if you want global r to decrease, human rights issues aside.
- forensic 17y ago>The second you give women the opportunity to work instead of raise a pack of squalling children, they seem to prefer work. Debatable. Women in the West were forced into work due to declining wages. A single income was no longer enough to support a family, and as more women went to work the other families would bid up the price of goods. Are women choosing to work or doing it out of necessity and social pressure?
- herdrick 17y ago* any future increase in demand for labor will only be supplied by increasing wages * Heavens, not that! Look, less available labor means higher wages. That's good.
- darien 17y agoUnmarriageable men = rise is prostitution, gangs. Also suicide rate is higher for unmarried men. For middle-case men who cannot marry, China would be wise not to over-regulate MMRPGs like WoW lest create more unease. Think about it. Rise in prostitution = rise in STDs. Investing in China's medical services sounds like a long term growth prospect. Also less women means that women will be more likely to marry into families with the most disposable income. Therefore it is likely that spendthrift wives will expand the fashion and cosmetics markets for some time.
- wooster 17y agoThere have been fairly cogent cases made elsewhere that having too many young unmarried men in a society is a setup for international aggression. For example: http://mitpress.mit.edu/catalog/item/default.asp?ttype=2&tid=10694 http://mitpress.mit.edu/catalog/item/default.asp?ttype=2&... Hudson and den Boer argue that this surplus male population in Asia's largest countries threatens domestic stability and international security. The prospects for peace and democracy are dimmed by the growth of bare branches in China and India, and, they maintain, the sex ratios of these countries will have global implications in the twenty-first century.
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoThe author is missing a crucial point. Any decline in working population has to be offset against productivity growth. Otherwise it means very little for overall wealth and for the ability of a society to replace traditional family based social security with a formal rights based social security system. In my view, the potential for productivity growth in a country like China is enormous. Knowledge and skills and capital, it's all there, but it is still advantageous in many cases to use manual labour instead. With rising wages and a shortage of labour this equation will change dramatically and productivity will skyrocket.
- forensic 17y agoThe most efficient use of excess males is war. The most efficient solution to an excess of geriatrics is euthanasia. (Baby boomers should be worried about this.) These are bitter pills to swallow. Chinese social planners are not fools. They know very well that it is better for their excess males to die in battle (and win boons for the country) than for those males to be cooped up in the interior where they will inevitably cause strife. Even with the most massive pacification campaign in history, that glut of childless-males is guaranteed to cause massive social unrest. If anything could conquer Asia and India, it would be a gigantic excess of childless males in an authoritarian society. Alexander the Great would have never dreamed of such a perfect country to conquer with.
- berntb 17y agoBut war is fast going robotic? OTOH, China, the world's factory, can certainly make lots of robots. :-) :-(
- Retric 17y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_sex_ratio http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_sex_ratio The global average is ~1.06 males per female. With China's population of 1.3 billion people that works out to ~25 million extra men. But the global 65+ ratio is 0.79 males/female. So a basic solution to gender imbalance has traditionally been older men married to younger woman. With death culling enough young men to fix the problem. When that is not enough, the widow population can fill in for an even larger shortage. China's gender imbalance might seem huge, but individual city's have often faced similar problems so it’s not hard to find past examples of the situation.
- tokenadult 17y agoThe percentages matter, but the numbers matter too. Taiwan had nearly a 10 percent surplus of men when Chiang Kai-shek's defeated armies settled there in 1949. Women who were young in the 1950s in Taiwan (I have spoken to many of these about that era) remember fondly that they could be very choosy about whom they married. Many men in that era never did marry. (Taiwan has had tolerated prostitution throughout the postwar period, which presumably is how the unmatched men dealt with being unmatched.) Today, Taiwan is a HUGE destination for young women from poorer countries (there are a lot of poorer countries than Taiwan, notably Vietnam) who are brought in as "mail-order brides" for older men. But for China to do the same, the Communist Party would have to explicitly give up the claim that it eliminated prostitution after "Liberation" in 1949, and the number of women needed to move into China--from countries that themselves often have shortages of women--would be enormous. Absolute numbers matter. It's much more difficult for China to deal with this problem than for any other country, because of the sheer size of the problem.
- dang 2y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20100216070004/http://www.feer.com:80/essays/2009/december51/chinas-family-planning-goes-awry https://web.archive.org/web/20100216070004/http://www.feer.c...