5 ms·
Cigarettes kill people. I don't care. As long as the public is well informed, I'm strongly in favor of allowing individuals to make their own choices. The cul
by colechristensen 11y ago
Cigarettes kill people. I don't care.
As long as the public is well informed, I'm strongly in favor of allowing individuals to make their own choices. The cult of anti-smoking needs to come to an end. The second-hand smoke nuisance has been eliminated in public places, and nobody reasonable has any question about the overall health effects of cigarettes. It's time to let people make their own choices.
- baudehlo 11y agoThere's also some evidence that smokers die earlier and are less of a burden on the health services than non smokers. I mean it's a terrible reason to support smoking, but I kind of support your viewpoint. I don't think there are any smokers out there anymore who don't know it's bad for you. Though I would never ask to go backwards in terms of where we arrived at now - packs with warnings and no indoor smoking is a great thing.
- Nagyman 11y ago> I don't think there are any smokers out there anymore who don't know it's bad for you I suspect this is not necessarily the case in countries with less public health education, especially developing or poor countries which is where Tobacco has shifted its efforts to grow or maintain revenue.
- baudehlo 11y agoFor sure. But this article isn't about that.
- s73v3r 11y agoIsn't it? The US Chamber of Commerce apparently supports those actions.
- URSpider94 11y agoThat is exactly what this article is about. It talks specifically about fighting smoking regulations in Moldova, for example.
- mr_spothawk 11y agonah... as a smoker, i can tell you it's damned clear that it's bad for you when you wake up in the morning. there's no internal dialogue telling you "maybe this isn't bad for me". there's an external dialogue though, for sure... "it's more/less bad than you think"
- afshin 11y ago"The second-hand smoke nuisance has been eliminated in public places" only because of "the cult of anti-smoking". The antismoking laws that the Chamber of Commerce is lobbying against are those very same ones that ended smoking in public places in much of the developed world.
- themgt 11y agoI guess you didn't RTFA, where it says the United States Chamber of Commerce is helping sue other countries for public health measures such as eliminating second hand smoke and ensuring people are well-informed of the risks they're taking?
- goler 11y ago>The second-hand smoke nuisance has been eliminated in public places Reduced, but not eliminated. People still smoke in far too many public spaces in the US. Try standing at the curb outside baggage claim at SFO or SJC. Or, outside many large office buildings. The only place smoking should be legal is in the privacy of your own single-family detached home. Even then, only if you don't have any minors living there.
- sneak 11y agoAs long as smokers can smoke freely in their own homes and cars while their children are there and unable to escape it, the second-hand smoke nuisance has not been eliminated.
- icanhackit 11y agoLet's play a game: As long as X can X freely in their own X while their children are there and unable to escape it, the X has not been eliminated. ... As long as parents can endlessly stock junk food freely in their own homes and cars while their children are there and unable to escape it, the influence of junk food has not been eliminated. The problem, fundamentally, is that people can be inconsiderate of others. I would classify someone who smokes in their car with non-smokers in their presence, children and adults alike, as jerks. It's a dick move. But don't try to legislate against every dick move - teach people to be more thoughtful of others.
- Retric 11y ago"It's a dick move", no we have a word for that it's evil. PS: Risking others lives for fun or profit seems to exist in a weird mental place. Drink and drive? Speed? Drive while really sleepy? Second hand smoke? Pollution? CO2? Fire a gun randomly in the air?
- icanhackit 11y agoit's evil As outlined in a separate comment in this thread, your solution is unenforceable unless you want to erode some pretty fundamental freedoms. THAT'S evil. No, wait...it's not evil. "Evil" is a gross oversimplification of things. It's anti-intellectual and avoids any sort of meaningful discussion of why people do the things they do. You feel compelled to help prevent potential respiratory issues and cancer in children exposed to second hand smoke by policing what people do in their own homes. But in the process of policing this issue you potentially do more harm than good - how do you solve the issue? Fines? Makes the family poor. Criminal record? Makes the family poor. Take away the children? Your intentions are good but I can only see the medicine being worse than the malady.
- ceejayoz 11y ago> The cult of anti-smoking needs to come to an end. The second-hand smoke nuisance has been eliminated in public places. That's a bit like saying "the cult of modern medicine needs to end now that I'm healthy", isn't it?
- colechristensen 11y agoNo, because they aren't stopping. To use your analogy, you must stop taking your antibiotics once the course is done and the infection clear. Having won all the battles they should have won, the cult is reaching to win battles they shouldn't. Keeping people well informed about the choices they make is good. Keeping public places reasonably free of smoke is good. But once you inform smokers about the consequences of their choices and prevent them from affecting those who don't want to make those choices ... it's time to step back and allow people to make their own decisions. If somebody wants to make an unhealthy choice for themselves, I don't have a problem with it. Maybe they'll need to pay a different health insurance premium to make up for it, and that's okay, but otherwise it is not the prerogative of my self or any government to intrude on personal choices which have effects limited to the individual.
- cageface 11y agoThe second-hand smoke nuisance has been eliminated in public places Only in the West. Here in SE Asia you're hard pressed to find a cafe or restaurant that isn't completely engulfed in cigarette smoke during business hours. Public smoking bans seem a long way off here.
- DanBC 11y ago> nobody reasonable has any question about the overall health effects of cigarettes. This is probably not true. Sure, smokers know that cigarettes are harmful and that their live is probably going to be shortened by smoking, but they do not know the rates or severity of the various health problems. For example Most men do not know that smoking is a leading cause of male impotence. People don't understand why their surgeon wants them to stop smoking (reduced risks during surgery; better healing after).
- 300bps 11y agoAs long as the public is well informed, I'm strongly in favor of allowing individuals to make their own choices. It's not much of a choice when you're psychologically manipulated through marketing to start smoking and then physically dependent and mentally addicted thereafter. The second-hand smoke nuisance has been eliminated in public places This is nonsense. I can't walk into my office without going through a giant cloud of smoke. Smokers are literally smoking right next to the signs that say, "No smoking within 30 feet of door" that are less than a foot from the door.
- colechristensen 11y ago>It's not much of a choice when you're psychologically manipulated through marketing to start smoking and then physically dependent and mentally addicted thereafter. I have no respect for this abdication of personal responsibility. >This is nonsense. I can't walk into my office without going through a giant cloud of smoke. Smokers are literally smoking right next to the signs that say, "No smoking within 30 feet of door" that are less than a foot from the door. I likewise have no sympathy. There's a difference between an actual public health concern (my intention using 'nuisance') and the nonexistent right to not be offended. Sharing public space means being inconvenienced sometimes. There's a big difference between working in a smoky bar for 10 hour shifts, and smelling cigarettes for 30 seconds as you walk in a building.