8 ms·
Peter Thiel Wants You to Get Angry About Death
- coldtea 11y agoIf all those Californians (the ideology) are so "angry about death" how come they don't give some of their money to help save hubndreds of millions NOW, in Africa and elsewhere? "Angry about death" here is short for "angry about my particular personal death", which is not as noble as angry about death in general. It can even mean: "if I could step all over others to live forever, I would".
- t0mbstone 11y agoI think you might be missing the point. If MORE people cared about not dying, we might actually be able to find a solution that lets us live longer (if not indefinitely). Instead, people resign themselves to the "inevitable", and nobody even really tries. Imagine if you could have your 30 year old level of health and brainpower for 1,000 years. Imagine what someone like that could accomplish. Imagine how much differently we would approach reality, if that was possible? Instead, people hit middle-age, and it's all down-hill from there. Their brains become brittle, and over time, they forget the vast majority of what they have learned, until they become borderline useless and die in misery. Why AREN'T you more angry about that fact? Why AREN'T you doing everything in your power to change it??? Immortality is the ONLY thing that should matter, or else everything you do in life is theoretically pointless.
- joshkpeterson 11y agoBecause I'm not selfish. Because life on earth is more than just me. Because, thus far, death has been an important part of life, and I have the intellectual humility to admit I'm not sure extending life would be for the best.
- coldtea 11y ago>I think you might be missing the point. If MORE people cared about not dying, we might actually be able to find a solution that lets us live longer (if not indefinitely). Actually our whole civilization has a huge obsession with death and with not dying -- evident in healthcare costs for older patients, cosmetic surgeries, and tons of other things besides. If we die it's not for lack of trying (not to) or lack of medical research that ACTUALLY prolongs life (and we have done great in this regard in the 20th century). Those "anti-death" ideologists are just kooks trying whatever fringe BS they find (including "cryogenics"), and they do more harm than good regading helping good science... >Instead, people hit middle-age, and it's all down-hill from there. Their brains become brittle, and over time, they forget the vast majority of what they have learned, until they become borderline useless and die in misery. Yeah, it's how DNA/animal bodies work. Biology, medicine works on it, but, like AI, space exploration and lots of other hard problems, it's quite a venture. Not some BS thing that will be solved in Kurzweills lifetime if only we want it really passionately. Reading your comment one would think it's caused because we're not willing enough that it doesn't happen...
- jackvalentine 11y ago> Why AREN'T you more angry about that fact? Why AREN'T you doing everything in your power to change it??? Immortality is the ONLY thing that should matter, or else everything you do in life is theoretically pointless. Because I'm not so narcissistic to think that my particular life matters that much. I live well, I try to care for others and when I am gone I am gone. There is no shame in mortality.
- seren 11y agoI am convinced death also help human society as a whole by bringing new people with a fresh view on things. Even in a democratic society, would like to have the same senators or mayor for 500 hundreds years ? Even if we had the mean to, abolishing death would also have dire consequences.
- vixen99 11y agoFeeling irritable this morning, are you?
- coldtea 11y agoFeeling ad hominen?
- JoshuaDavid 11y ago> how come they don't give some of their money to help save hubndreds of millions NOW, in Africa and elsewhere? A couple of things. First, the overlap between the anti-aging and anti-death community and the effective altruism community is pretty large. Because the base rate of people who take effective altruism seriously is still so low, it's a reasonable assumption to make, but in this case it's incorrect. Have a look at how much interaction there is between, for example, GiveWell and Good Ventures (as background, GiveWell places a very strong emphasis on being very sure that what they're doing is helping and how much, and Good Ventures focuses more strongly on projects that might do massive amounts of good) [1]. Second, it's great that you're thinking in terms of how money can best be spent to provide the maximal benefit to humanity. You're entirely correct that medical interventions in Africa are orders of magnitude more effective per dollar at than, for example, the Make a Wish foundation -- the estimate I'm familiar with is about $3,000 per life saved, which is pretty impressive [2]. However, continuing that line of thought, tropical diseases and malnutrition have a combined cost of about 200 million DALY's annually. The problems we generally consider "just a normal part of aging" (cardiovascular disease, neurological diseases, cancer, arthritis, etc.) have a combined cost of about 1 billion DALY's annually [3]. My personal opinion is that addressing medical problems in the developing world is probably still more cost-effective than medical research in the developed world, but it's not all that clear-cut. When you're a billionaire like Thiel, you can afford to put some resources into both ways of improving the world, and either way is still better than buying a fourth yacht. "Angry about death" could mean "if I could step all over others to live forever, I would", but in this case I don't think it does. [1] http://www.givewell.org/about/official-records/board-meeting-19/givewell-and-good-ventures http://www.givewell.org/about/official-records/board-meeting... [2] http://www.givewell.org/international/technical/programs/insecticide-treated-nets#HowcosteffectiveisLLINdistribution http://www.givewell.org/international/technical/programs/ins... [3] http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(12)61689-4/fulltext http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-67... (you can register and view the full text, charts, etc. for free).
- serve_yay 11y agoI want Peter Thiel to get angry about poverty.
- boh 11y agoMy friends and I started using a new verb: "thieling". As in "you're totally thieling right now". Definition: 1) expressing overarching assertions in the parlance of populist tech speak. 2)Expressing obvious assertions as if they were counter-intuitive. Get angry about dyeing? What has been the larger point of healthcare? People aren’t dying because of “pessimism”.