6 ms·
Can someone give the cynical spin on this? I know a lot of these companies purport to care about stopping smoking, but is there also a profit motive? I've hea
by SilasX 11y ago
Can someone give the cynical spin on this? I know a lot of these companies purport to care about stopping smoking, but is there also a profit motive?
I've heard scattered accounts that when a convenience store stops carrying cigarettes they also draw fewer problem customers, but haven't validated it.
- rathboma 11y agoCVS is rolling out walk-in clinics in their stores. So for them it makes a lot of sense and helps them make the case they're a health focused company.
- wcummings 11y agoThey still have whole aisle's dedicated to beer and junk food, so it's about more than just eliminating unhealthful offerings from their stores. Tobacco is on the way out in the US, in 10 or 20 years you'll have to buy tobacco in specialty stores. I think CVS just saw the writing on the wall and seized a convenient opportunity to jettison the business.
- oldmanjay 11y agoI'm not too into the "beer and junk food" line. I see a fairly large difference between offering choices that can be unhealthy if a person overdoes them, and helping to lobby governments to keep markets open for an addictive, harmful drug.
- vonmoltke 11y agoDepends on how you spin it. I know many people who would characterize ethanol as an "addictive, harmful drug". Large food companies spend lots of money trying to make their products more appealing, and by some evidence addicting. The difference is that people can get drunk and blow out their liver or get fat and blow out their pancreas (usually) without direct effects to those around them. Since 90% of tobacco users have to use it in a way that blows every bystander's lungs out while they are blowing their own out, it gets much more vitriol.
- oldmanjay 11y ago>Since 90% of tobacco users have to use it in a way that blows every bystander's lungs out while they are blowing their own out, it gets much more vitriol. What's funny about this is that it's not necessarily true. The whole "secondhand smoke" thing appears to be one of those convenient lies aimed at a greater good. It certainly isn't blowing out anyone's lungs. Still, the falloff in smoking is something I'm totally into, just because it stinks. There is no science at all supporting the notion that the harm from ethanol approaches that of tobacco, so I'm not too worried about the people you know. In particular, the addiction rates are vastly different. Basically, your opening sentence says it all: your point relies on spin to be sharp.
- SilasX 11y agoIt doesn't matter. Objecting on the basis that it smells horrible is just as valid a concern as long-term health effects.
- wcummings 11y agoMany second-hand smoke studies are performed on spouses of smokers, over long periods of time (living w/ a smoker for decades, basically). Second-hand smoke in say, a park (where smoking is frequently banned) is not a factor. It's a convenient lie to discourage smoking.
- hbhakhra 11y agoI think it could be argued that people that drink heavily harm more people around them then people that smoke. I don't have any studies to say which one is worse, but there is no way you can say people that get drunk don't have a direct effect on those around them.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- wcummings 11y agoAddicts drive the alcohol industry, same as tobacco. I don't see the difference.
- jfoster 11y agoWhat makes you think they won't address that in the future? They do need to balance the economics of their business. There's no point in removing every negative aisle at the same time if it will destroy (or make them lose control of) their business.
- tptacek 11y agoCVS is playing catch-up on walk-in clinics with Walgreens, which still stocks cigarettes.
- justonepost 11y agoWell, CVS obviously doesn't want to compete against companies that can profit from selling cigarettes as they will be at a disadvantage. CVS is also looking to burnish their brand by showing they truly look out for public health. That's as cynical as I can get. On the whole, they are doing a pretty good job at burnishing their brand in my eyes...
- ubercore 11y agoThe most likely cynical spin I can think of isn't that cynical; just trying to anticipate cultural trends they can use to their advantage in marketing and public opinion. Investing in sometimes-slightly painful positions earlier than their competitors.
- ben1040 11y agoThey said they would take a $2bn hit to annual revenue [1] when they originally announced this. But I imagine long-term the issue is that having acquired a pharmacy benefits management company, they maybe determined that a plan member who doesn't smoke is a plan member who is more profitable? CVS's PBM subsidiary last year was also proposing charging an additional fee to members who filled their prescriptions at pharmacies that also sold tobacco.[2] Not sure if this ever happened or not; that seems anti-competitive. I don't see why filling my prescription at Walgreens instead of CVS should cost me more, only because you can buy a pack of smokes at Walgreens. [1] http://www.cvshealth.com/newsroom/press-releases/pharmacy-services-corporate-info-events/cvs-caremark-stop-selling-tobacco http://www.cvshealth.com/newsroom/press-releases/pharmacy-se... [2] http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2014/10/20/after-cutting-tobacco-sales-cvs-is-pressuring-other-pharmacies-to-do-the-same/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2014/10/20/a...
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Can someone give the cynical spin on this? Customers dying younger because they are buying an addicting, health-damaging product may produce some money if you are selling them the product, but if you are selling other products -- especially other expensive, long-term regular-purchase products that they will reliably come back to you for -- it can be a net loss. Perhaps CVS has decided that there's more return on customer acquisition dollars if it gets out of the cigarette business (both selling and promoting indirectly via USCC) and stops actively killing off its own reliable customer basis (and, incidentally, other people). I don't know that that's really all that "cynical" of a spin, but its a self-interest profit motive rather than an altruistic one. > I've heard scattered accounts that when a convenience store stops carrying cigarettes they also draw fewer problem customers, but haven't validated it. That's quite possibly a factor, but CVS isn't just a "convenience store"; they are drugstores (that is, a key feature of their stores is the pharmacy) and they also have and are expanding in-store clinics (so they are also health-care providers.)
- qq66 11y agoThe profit motive is that it's rarely smart to fight a battle that you know you're going to lose. When lions fight, they stop as soon as they know who's going to win -- the losing lion would rather walk away with his life than force the winner to kill him. CVS has basically decided that smoking is on its way out the door, and they've decided to forgo the remaining profits in selling a smaller number of cigarettes each year for the next few years. They've decided that they'll be better off getting ahead of this trend, shifting to more health-oriented branding, and opposing smoking publicly and vocally.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoWhat is the cost of maintaining sales of the product?
- krschultz 11y agoWhat is the value of the PR CVS gains by being a leader?
- bsder 11y agoCost vs. profit. Tobacco takes up valuable real-estate in your retail area (right at counter--right at checkout). Tobacco sales continue to fall so your gross sales are falling. Tobacco prices tend to be regulated heavily (minimum price that you can't sell under), so profit is probably fixed. Underage tobacco purchases are heavily penalized--so your cost due some store selling to a minor is minimized. CVS took a bit of hit, but I suspect that they have numbers on the profit they gain by repurposing that space. I'm sure somebody crunched the numbers.
- johnmaguire2013 11y agoThis doesn't explain why they would actively fight to make it illegal.
- pxlpshr 11y agoI'm the cofounder of a health tech startup. This is my opinion. The cynical spin was healthcare pre-2008. Today, our healthcare industry is finally making meaningful changes to its model, moving from fee-for-service toward value-based care and risk sharing. [1] This means payers, providers, and everyone in between is now incentivized to get IN FRONT of problems (like smoking) before it creates an even bigger, high-cost/high-risk patient population (heart disease, cancer, etc). Those who don't will get phased out / merged. The reality is ~75% of the $2.2 trillion we spend on healthcare per year goes toward fighting said chronic conditions. From a distribution perspective, 20% of the population is responsible for ~80% of costs... 5% of population, ~50% of costs. Moving the needle a small amount matters a lot. [1] This is one example of a brand changing due to industry consolidation. Prices are being commoditized across the board for care, for drugs, etc. As others have said, CVS & Walgreens are no longer just pharmacies selling drugs. They are diversifying and growing into providers just like payers.
- SilasX 11y agoI can understand that much, but CVS doesn't (privately) reap the returns from healthier customers. That dynamic would apply to a health insurer or provider, not a glorified convenience store.
- acomjean 11y agoalive customers are the best kind. CVS is a pharmacy so keeping patients alive longer means more money on perscription medication.
- johnmaguire2013 11y agoIn fact, wouldn't they lose profits on tobacco cessation products and medications used by smokers with health problems?
- larrys 11y agoAgree. If people smoke and are unhealthy they in theory would need a larger amount of prescription drugs which CVS sells and profits from.
- cronjobber 11y agoThis may not apply to the US: In my corner of the world, word on the street is that sellers of tobacco products make nearly no profit at all on it. Reason is that between sky-high taxes raising prices and anti-smoking propaganda lowering demand, sellers are squeezed out of a profit. However, there still are a lot of smokers who would be less likely to visit your place of business if you stopped to stock tobacco products. So you continue to deal in it even though it makes you little money. If a large player leaves a market like this, they drop a low-profit use of shelf space, but also lose smokers to competitors. In that position, the most desirable endpoint would be more bans on smoking, because less smokers mean less of an advantage for competitors.
- LordKano 11y agoWhere I live when they passed an indoor smoking ban in the county, certain businesses near the county line were up in arms because smokers will drive an extra 5 minutes to go to a bar/restaurant where they can have a cigarette too. There were bars that were in danger of going out of business because they couldn't get a waiver and enough of their customers were going elsewhere.
- TillE 11y agoIt's much higher in Europe, but in the US the number of smokers is a little below 20%, including those in prime bar-going age. http://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/data_statistics/fact_sheets/adult_data/cig_smoking/ http://www.cdc.gov/tobacco/data_statistics/fact_sheets/adult... I'm not convinced that's enough to make a significant dent in business, especially if you balance it out with those who will be attracted by the idea that their clothes will not smell like smoke.
- LordKano 11y agoYou have not considered another factor. The non-smokers who will stop going to an establishment when their smoking friends go somewhere else. Drinking is often a social activity. Non-smokers who drink already have established places where they go. Those places will have done nothing to alienate them and cause them to change their habits. They'll keep going where they have been going because for them, nothing will have changed. Bars and restaurants don't always operate with huge margins. If 15% of their customers decided to go elsewhere overnight, I have no doubt that it would cause serious problems.
- jfoster 11y agoWhat if they are planning to arrange their business profit motives around what they care about? If they are, you might be able to find something to be cynical about, but actually they might have structured their business in concert with their values.