3 ms·
The bubble happened because banks were lending money for homes but were not keeping the loans....This would not have been possible with Glass-Steagall in force.
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
The bubble happened because banks were lending money for homes but were not keeping the loans....This would not have been possible with Glass-Steagall in force.
False. This happened all the time with Glass-Steagall in force. Glass Steagall was repealed in 1999, mortgage backed securities were issued and sold long before then. Many commercial banks traded MBS under Glass-Steagall as a way of reducing their risk; in fact regulatory bodies encouraged them to do this.
You are incorrectly conflating many activities, and assuming Glass-Steagall prevents all of them.
As for my second statement, I'm mocking the article's silly idea that investing in "productive assets" is somehow different from "financial speculation." I'm not making any claims about what percentage of their assets they would speculate with (either in the form of equities or bonds).
- hristov 17y ago"False. This happened all the time with Glass-Steagall in force. Glass Steagall was repealed in 1999, mortgage backed securities were issued and sold long before then. Many commercial banks traded MBS under Glass-Steagall as a way of reducing their risk; in fact regulatory bodies encouraged them to do this." We are really getting into details here. This was technically partially true, because Glass Steagall was being progressively watered down long before it was actually repealed. So commercial banks were allowed to underwrite some securities but again there were limits as to how much they could do. I think the limit started at 5% of revenue and then progressively expanded to 25% as GS was being further watered down. But I doubt banks would have been allowed to create the huge amounts of mortgage backed securities they did after the repeal, even in the most watered down version of GS. Also, when the original article argued for the reinstation of Glass Steagall they probably argued for it in its original non-watered down version. As to your second statement, you said "Instead of speculating in "finance", lending went to speculate in "productive assets" like equities and bonds." To me this means that you misunderstood what the original article was trying to say. By productive assets the original article meant direct loans to businesses and individuals instead of financial instruments.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoGlass-Steagall prevented banks from running a trading desk, not from securitizing and selling their loans. You are simply mistaken as to what the law actually means. By productive assets the original article meant direct loans to businesses and individuals instead of financial instruments. A direct loan to a business is, by definition, speculating on a corporate bond.