3 ms·
I'm uncomfortable with being negative about it, but am I right in understanding the only display is led lights? A long time ago I was a kid with an interest in
by andrewstuart 11y ago
I'm uncomfortable with being negative about it, but am I right in understanding the only display is led lights?
A long time ago I was a kid with an interest in computers and I remember what it was like and it's hard to imagine this actually being interesting to kids.
It sort of feels like it's trying so hard not to compete with other technology that it's become kind of pointless. It really should have been able to plug into a display.
I'd love to be enthused because the initiative is an awesome one but a box with lights feel like it might be missing the inspiration factor.
It would have been good if they had some sort of Lego-like ability to connect them to each other or something to encourage kids to hook them up in series and make them communicate. Heck maybe with Legos permission it should have been Lego connector compatible so it could be clipped into Lego structures.
Feels like this little device is a bit of a missed opportunity.
- jbob2000 11y agoYeah, what's wrong with Lego Mindstorm? At least you can actually do stuff with that.
- afandian 11y agoI just heard an interview on BBC news about this with a teenager. He said: "You can interact with the code that you've written as opposed to just seeing it on the screen, just seeing lines of code. You actually know what it does in real life ... as opposed to something like this, just seeing it running on the screen or on TV or something" I can sort of follow that logic. Devices like screens are so normalised now that they're considered part of the fabric of reality. Of course you could do something on a computer but it's a thing only on a computer. I remember making things happen for the first time on a BBC Micro as a child and being incredibly excited about that. Not least because seeing things on a screen was still at least a little bit novel. Ironically, I think that VDUs (that's what they were called at the time!) have come so far that the contemporary manifestation of novel is technologically* regressive. But so much more engaging. EDIT: Also it's small and cheap and everyone can have one without having to contend for / carry around keyboards and screens. EDIT 2: I thought I'd transcribe what was actually said: http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b060zq92 http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b060zq92 from 40:10 Lauren: "You can create animations but you can also set it up with your phone so you can press a button on the microbit it can take a picture or change to the next song and the fact that everybody else is getting it, it's not just one person, everyone's going to be learning at the same time so more people will be interested in it" Ross: "It's got a compass, an accelerometer. You can interact with the code that you've written as opposed to just seeing it on the screen, just seeing lines of code. You actually know what it does in real life you and you can take it round with you and wear it like this. So it's a lot more interesting a lot easier to play around with and you can see the effects of the code pretty quickly with something like this. As opposed to something like this, just seeing it running on the screen or on TV or something" * in terms of IO, not in terms of it having an ARM chip
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- andrewstuart 11y agoI'm sure an idea like this would have blown the budget but if the components were separate and could be clicked together then that would have been very interesting and novel and not competed with Raspberry pi. How cool would it be to pool the bits with your friends and click together each component and make the components talk and do things? Battery module, accelerometer module, led light module, button module, compass module, cpu module, usb module. Want more buttons or led lights, let the kids in the school ground share and swap bits - kids love swapping. The key would have been to come up with an open standard for module connection, seed it with some initial cheap and simple modules and let kids hook em up and third parties design more modules with different functions, all incredibly single purpose but able to talk on a common bus and share a power module. Having just said all that I looked up http://littlebits.cc/shop?filter=Bits http://littlebits.cc/shop?filter=Bits Each school kid could get one random module, not much use on its own but when pooled with other kids they could build together. There's even http://littlebits.cc/accessories/brick-adapter http://littlebits.cc/accessories/brick-adapter
- userbinator 11y agoI agree; SMD LEDs are cheap, but it's not as if a little graphic LCD would've been hugely more expensive while providing a lot more interesting possibilities: http://www.buydisplay.com/default/1-4-inch-graphic-128x64-lcd-module-serial-spi-st7565-black-on-white http://www.buydisplay.com/default/1-4-inch-graphic-128x64-lc... (There are plenty of online stores that sell these at several times that price, only because they've added the word "Arduino" in the description...)
- aaronem 11y agoThe word "Arduino", an interface that doesn't involve hand-soldering to a high-pitch Kapton ribbon, level shifters, neat features like RGB backlights and onboard input devices...
- gdamjan1 11y agoYou already have a mobile phone with a 4K (or ok, a HD) display