2 ms·
I don't think making it a specific crime is the way forward long term. As the article states, in most countries everything is already covered by existing legisl
by dspillett 11y ago
I don't think making it a specific crime is the way forward long term. As the article states, in most countries everything is already covered by existing legislation (and society's general view of common decency but that doesn't necessarily help in a court).
The problem is one of implementation. How do you gather proof/evidence, how do you prove intent beyond reasonable doubt, and how do you support the victims during and after. A fair amount of the existing problem is similar to bullying in other area: the victims being scared to speak out either just through fear of the perpetrators or through the thought that nothing can and/or will be done. And other key problem is people in law enforcement (from the cops on the street all the way up to the judges and legislators) and people in society's support structures (parents, teachers, councillors, and so forth) not understanding: being out of touch with the technology, or facets of modern culture (cyber-bullying is a lot more common in the young and many who where young 20 or more years ago, and I'm including myself there, don't quite understand those people), or often both.
Sometimes the more specific a crime the easier it is for a good legal team (or just a clever arsehole) to find loopholes that allow them to get away with things that are effectively the same thing but are not covered by the exact wording, so great care needs to be taken in drafting the law.
Having said that: making it a specific crime might be a very useful stop-gap measure though. It at least tells both the victims and those on the other side that the situation is being taken seriously, brings the matter to sharper focus for the implementers/enforcers of the law so they'll see the need to fill the knowledge/experience gap, and to an extent brings the issue to increased public attention (hopefully with similar effect where needed).
- AdeptusAquinas 11y agoWhile existing legislation covers the same issues, I think a problem is the courts and general public treat the same crime in a different context (i.e. over the phone or out in the street) as more serious / real, which leaves the cyber-variant harder to deal with effectively or consistently. By explicitly singling it out with its own definition and punishments, this will no doubt it makes things easier for the police, courts and victims I think. Assuming it doesn't get abused by our idiot politicians anyway (I'm from NZ - looking at you Colin Craig).