5 ms·
would be funny if Temple OS ended up being better than everything else
by guttyworks 11y ago
would be funny if Temple OS ended up being better than everything else
- kev009 11y agoThis is kind of what happened to OpenBSD, which started as a pretty hardline thing but is now one of the best PC laptop operating systems out of the box.
- x5n1 11y agothis is a relative understanding, not an absolute one.
- VieElm 11y agoWell it's lack of security makes it probably not an OS you'd want run untrusted code on. Like if you made a browser for it I'm not sure it would be easy to sandbox it to protect your computer from serious harm. Any program can read from and write to any part of memory if I recall correctly.
- x5n1 11y agoon the other hand the chances of coming across a virus made for TempleOS is rather unlikely.
- S4M 11y agoAs long as it has very little users who are all super tech savvy.
- MichaelGG 11y agoPlease explain how that's different from today on other OSes. A JavaScript exploit or other browser corruption is still an issue on current browsers, right? (I only see one Firefox process on my machine, so I'm gonna guess if you break the browser, you have code exec with my user access level.)
- masklinn 11y agoA Javascript browser exploit is still an issue, however it won't usually be able to read and write to kernel memory. TempleOS runs entirely in ring0. That means any exploit whatsoever and the exploiter can not just access some of your data, they own your machine entirely from the kernel up. http://www.templeos.org/TempleOS.html http://www.templeos.org/TempleOS.html is a good explanation of the point and purpose of the project, one which is reasonable and makes perfect sense. It explains why a TempleOS machine should not ever run unchecked third-party programs (let alone be on any kind of network), but could be an excellent OS to use on a remote abandoned island.
- MichaelGG 11y agoCould you elaborate on the difference kernel vs user as far as the end user is concerned? I'm pretty sure that we've seen how damaging CTOs opening Office docs can be. And web browsers seemed to take off before Windows NT was the more popular desktop kernel.
- masklinn 11y ago> Could you elaborate on the difference kernel vs user as far as the end user is concerned? * No possibility of a secure experience via strict privilege separation (e.g. strict usage of multiple account, inconvenient but protects against alteration of personal data) * A ring0 program has unfettered access to the hardware, so the machine itself may be compromised, a breach is not "format & reinstall" let alone "run a bunch of antiviruses" it's possibly "throw the whole machine into the bin and buy a new one". > And web browsers seemed to take off before Windows NT was the more popular desktop kernel. Windows 98 didn't run in ring0. It was crap, but not that crap.
- moreInfo1234 11y agoTo elaborate on the reasoning behind why it may be necessary to throw the machine out, for the people who aren't familiar: Given full access to the hardware, it's possible (though I haven't tested it to be certain) to flash the BIOS. The machine could be bricked by a remote exploit.
- Grazester 11y agoThat would be very unlikely. It has no memory protection as someone else alluded to, has no networking and I dont believe it is open source either.
- barbs 11y agoIt is open-source: http://www.templeos.org/Wb/ http://www.templeos.org/Wb/ So I imagine someone could code networking in there somehow.