3 ms·
I think domesticated is a big term for naming an interaction between two predators. Domestication implies a transformation in the morphology of the domesticated
by pvaldes 11y ago
I think domesticated is a big term for naming an interaction between two predators. Domestication implies a transformation in the morphology of the domesticated species, this is just mutual tolerance at best.
- woadwarrior01 11y agoI agree that domestication is a big term. It's more like a symbiotic relationship between the monkeys and the wolves. The article states that the monkeys are herbivores and thus not predators.
- pvaldes 11y agoYou are right, I'm mistaking it with the Hamadryas. Geladas are the interesting mountain monkeys that eat dry grasses. It seems that solitary wolves enjoy protection from feral dogs within the group of monkeys surveying and thus can concentrate in the chase of rodents (and maybe use also placents and any dead monkey corpse?). Wolves probably understand that monkey bite will do a lot of damage and avoid to put himselves in troubles. Geladas eat a very poor diet, live in a cold place and (as pandas) probably need to preserve the energy so spend it chasing a much faster wolf is a bad movement. Common enemies. Not conflict of interests with diet, long lives and social animals that can remember you; thus: Not need to be unpolite. To start a fight is a lose:lose movement for both.
- has2k1 11y agoThe tendencies at the start of the domestication process can be varied, yet we can expect that any capacity for tolerance is more likely aid the process rather than hinder it. This is a process that can and does take thousands of years, and if it is happening you are probably not going to expect to see a transformation in morphology (Speciation) during a human lifetime. Once you see tolerance between an ape/monkey and a canine, you certainly wonder whether something is happening. Also note that something may indeed be happening only to get disrupted due to the many factors at play in an evolutionary process. Domestication is an evolutionary process. Domestication is a term that evokes calculation and intention [1], but given the time scales involved the participants have not a clue what the end product will be let alone be cognisant of the process. [1] This is may be due to the "domestication" term being applied to plants as well were the process is simpler.
- pvaldes 11y agoOf course, but apart of tolerance you need also controlled reproduction, selection of specimens with desirable characters (reduce the genetic pool) and changes in morphology. As seen in red fox the later can take only 30 years if the former occur. Those wolves are non reproductive specimens, not are different than other wolves of its species, thus could be seen as 'domestic' for geladas (like sparrows, spiders or house flies for us), but not domesticated (like canaries or fruit flies). This is not much different than to say that crocodiles are being domesticated by hippopotamuses.
- ende 11y agoMaybe a term like proto-domestication would better serve.