2 ms·
"X and Y are both instances of Z, so let's use Y and Z as a source of ideas about X." This pattern is basically repeated in every single paragraph, e.g. * The
by Alex3917 17y ago
"X and Y are both instances of Z, so let's use Y and Z as a source of ideas about X."
This pattern is basically repeated in every single paragraph, e.g.
* The reputations of hackers probably have a large random component introduced by fashion, as happens with artists.
* In hacking as with painting, it’s best to start by sketching
* Both software and paintings are intended for a human audience, so both hackers must have empathy to do good work.
The essay was written for the benefit of hackers, so if you want to attack the ideas in the essay, a 'good' argument might be that hacking does not require empathy. As opposed to saying that the idea that the best paintings were done between 1430 and 1500 is just some guy's opinion, which adds nothing.
Now if you wanted to challenge the ideas about art as a way of challenging the ideas about hacking then that would at least be interesting, but just nitpicking about art history is lame.
- pvg 17y agoI'd like to challenge it in the way the essay challenged it, that is that the comparison is fatuous wanking. A 'good' argument to the contrary might involve, well, a good argument to the contrary. Rather than fatuous wanking.