3 ms·
What bothers me about mjd's explanation of "Why doesn't every logic puzzle fall afoul of this problem" is: > > Portia explained to the suitor that of the three
by JadeNB 11y ago
What bothers me about mjd's explanation of "Why doesn't every logic puzzle fall afoul of this problem" is:
> > Portia explained to the suitor that of the three statements, at most one was true.
> Notice that the problem condition gives the suitor a certification about the truth of the labels, on which he may rely.
(the first sentence is quoted, approvingly, from a puzzle by Gardner, and the second explains why it saves that puzzle). Sure, there is a certificate provided in the problem; but why may we trust Portia's certification, any more than we may trust the labels on the boxes? It seems that one needs either
- an annoying intra-textual infinite regress: "Portia said this, and Balthazar said that Portia was telling the truth, and Stephano said that Balthazar was telling the truth, …" (which still doesn't really address the trust problem, just moves it infinitely far); or
- a meta-textual reassurance: "Given that at most one of the three statements is true, which of the caskets should the suitor choose?"
(EDIT: Oops, mdpopescu (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9837257 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9837257) made this point much more succinctly several hours ago.)
- Ended 11y agoI think you are right, and the solution is a meta-textual reassurance, specifically of the form: "if one of the statements is true, then which casket should the suitor choose?"
- JadeNB 11y agoI agree, although note that Gardner actually sneaks in the subtly different statement "at most one of the statements is true." Of course, even here one has to be careful: do we require that the problem say "if at most one of the statements is true, and the previous description of the problem is correct, then …"? If not, what allows us to trust the previous description? One can re-phrase every logic puzzle ever as "Assuming that `P` is true, what can you deduce about `Q`?"; or one may assume that a logic puzzle of the form "`P` is true. What can you deduce about `Q`?" is really shorthand for the former. I don't begrudge mjd for pointing out this shorthand, but I do think that his description of the 'solution' (to the meta-problem, not the actual puzzle he poses) is facile at best, and creates bigger problems at worst.