3 ms·
That may explain why Broadwell isn't significantly faster than Sandy Bridge, but I don't understand how it has anything to do with this announcement. How does
by bryanlarsen 11y ago
That may explain why Broadwell isn't significantly faster than Sandy Bridge, but I don't understand how it has anything to do with this announcement. How does 10nm being delayed 1 year have anything to do with integrating graphics?
- agumonkey 11y agoThe GPU takes resources and put pressure on the design, at the expense of CPU logic. I think what he meant to say is that an intel CPU-only could devote more transistor to logic without having to deal with so much heat which might still be a problem at 10nm.
- bryanlarsen 11y agoI'd argue the converse: when you are benchmarking a CPU intensive application, the GPU is mostly idle and not generating much heat, giving you margin to push the CPU transistors harder. GPU designs are also much more regular than CPU designs, so heat is spread much more regularly rather than in a few hot spots. The regularity also makes it easier to transition to a new node.
- trynumber9 11y agoIntel doesn't have a problem dissipating heat from their all-CPU Xeon giants. It stands to reason that without the GPU they could either make wider or more cores while staying in the 80-90W TDP. Most of the die space would end up going to larger caches, which are also very regular.
- cma 11y agogiving you margin to push the CPU transistors harder If you dedicated the GPU space on the core to more CPUs, you could cycle your workload amongst more cores, even if you made it so that only the same number were active at any given instant.
- duaneb 11y agoI was under the impression that heat per transistor is inversely proportional to the size of the die. So it makes sense that reducing the size would be, primarily, a heat problem. The GPU adds much, much, much more logic to the CPU, making heat constraints more difficult to deal with.
- agumonkey 11y agoGood point, higher density but also lower voltage, I don't know how these balance each other. http://imgur.com/PD14VtN http://imgur.com/PD14VtN shows how large GPUs can be. As other said, GPU might spend a lot of time in low workload I don't know. And I don't know if have 30% more transistor budget could help heat generation and dissipation...
- duaneb 11y agoI think there are two constraints the GPU would impose on the CPU: 1. Static resource contention—i.e. how many transistors are allocated to a task. 2. Power/Heat contention: assumably the CPU can run at full force without the GPU. When the GPU is also cranking, it's unclear how the processor divvies up the power. Optimally, it would not affect the other, but with so much money going into power management and conservation research vis-a-vis phones, it wouldn't shock me to find that it cut into the CPU significantly: I would suspect the GPU is a much more recognizable piece of quality hardware to most consumers. My Moto E is an impressive, cheap piece of hardware, but still chokes hard on lollipop animations.