7 ms·
The most interesting part of the story about him is that the laws were changed inspired by his former acquittal: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sergey_Aleynikov
by acqq 11y ago
The most interesting part of the story about him is that the laws were changed inspired by his former acquittal:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sergey_Aleynikov https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sergey_Aleynikov
"On April 11, 2012, Dennis Jacobs, Chief Judge of the United States Court of Appeals, published a unanimous decision in a written opinion[11] stating:
On appeal, Aleynikov argues, inter alia, that his conduct did not constitute an offense under either statute. He argues that: [1] the source code was not a "stolen" "good" within the meaning of the NSPA, and [2] the source code was not “related to or included in a product that is produced for or placed in interstate or foreign commerce” within the meaning of the EEA. We agree, and reverse the judgment of the district court.[10]
In the course of these events, Aleynikov has spent 11 months in prison. Aleynikov has divorced, lost his savings,[12] and, according to his lawyer, "[his] life has been all but ruined".[13]
The government did not seek reconsideration of the Second Circuit's ruling, thus ending federal action against Aleynikov.[14]
Later, on December 18, 2012, the law was changed by Congress, in order to punish acts like the ones Aleynikov committed in future rulings, in a law referred to as the "Theft of trade secrets clarification act of 2012".[15]"
- tpatke 11y agoNo. The most interesting part is that this is an example of a vindictive employer ruining someone's life. I used to work at Goldman's and can tell you that they are paranoid about this kind of thing. They are trying to make an example out of Sergey. We used to get daily updates (on the corporate intranet) about the progress of the case. There is no telling how much money Goldman's has spent going after this guy. Both directly and indirectly through lobbying. You have to ask why, after a year in jail with no conviction, the government still trying to prosecute him? Could it be because Goldman has a very powerful lobbying arm which is particularly strong in New York? If you are leaving your employer, don't upload any code. Sure. ...but that was over 6 years ago and the guy has already done time. Try getting a job with a prison record. I can tell you that in the banking industry it will not happen. I wouldn't be the least bit surprised if they keep coming after him. Poor guy. One last point. There is no market for stolen code. If I stole Google's search algorithm, who would I sell it to? Microsoft wouldn't be interested and it is not like you can take out an ad on ebay. Who would have the brains to figure it out? If you had those brains, wouldn't it be easier to just write it yourself? What is true for Google's code is also true for any complex system such as trading software.
- frozenport 11y ago>>If you had those brains, wouldn't it be easier to just write it yourself? Except it takes months to recreate code. Much easier for you to walk up to your boss and show them a working prototype after a week of refactoring.
- monsterix 11y ago> Except it takes months to recreate code. No. For a neanderthal leadership it doesn't take months to recreate code. It usually takes forever. Goldman Sachs and many such large corporation, including the US Government, are led by a bunch of dinosaurs. People who do not understand what code is. What they understand instead is bullying, setting an example like some sort of public execution, owning people to the point of slavery etc. They know what it means to prosecute and destroy lives of individuals. And enjoy parties and drinks on the side in the evenings. And this is just one example of that tyrannical trait.
- frozenport 11y agoMaybe we are both right? GS are terrible people, but the code he stole could help him future work?
- monsterix 11y agoYep!
- knodi123 11y ago> What is true for Google's code is also true for any complex system such as trading software. I'm not sure that follows. Many trading companies operate as black boxes, and there are a hell of a lot more of them, and they have much fewer employees, and seem to exemplify a "get rich quick" attitude.
- andrewflnr 11y agoYou would sell it to someone interested in gaming it.