13 ms·
The Science of Pixar's ‘Inside Out’
- tokenadult 11y agoAnother good set of comments about Inside Out can be found in the Neurologica Blog maintained by Steven Novella, M.D. He likes the movie for some of the same reasons that I like it. "Inside Out – A Neuroscience Metaphor" http://theness.com/neurologicablog/index.php/inside-out-a-neuroscience-metaphor/ http://theness.com/neurologicablog/index.php/inside-out-a-ne...
- amirmc 11y agoUnfortunately, that article perpetuates the same (false) dichotomy between emotion and reason. It also suggests that emotions and higher-order functions are 'competing' for control. The reality is that if the brain regions known to be involved in processing emotion are damaged/destroyed, then there are very negative consequences for your ability to make rational and well-reasoned choices. In other words, emotion (and emotional processing) is critical for logical thought to prevail. In that sense, I really like that the movie had emotions at the 'control panel' (I've yet to see it).
- tfigment 11y agoAs always Fresh Air's Terry Gross on NPR did an outstanding interview with the Director several weeks ago. They go fairly deep into the trade offs of making a movie and getting the science right or at least right enough to be entertaining and still meaningful to the young audience. "It's All In Your Head: Director Pete Docter Gets Emotional In 'Inside Out'" http://www.npr.org/2015/06/10/413273007/its-all-in-your-head-director-pete-docter-gets-emotional-in-inside-out http://www.npr.org/2015/06/10/413273007/its-all-in-your-head...
- forrestthewoods 11y agoThis was great. Thanks for sharing.
- smcnally 11y agoThis is interesting to hear from science's PoV: > "First, emotions organize — rather than disrupt — rational thinking. Traditionally, in the history of Western thought, the prevailing view has been that emotions are enemies of rationality and disruptive of cooperative social relations. > But the truth is that emotions guide our perceptions of the world, our memories of the past and even our moral judgments of right and wrong, most typically in ways that enable effective responses to the current situation." Is it generally accepted that the Logic 'vs' Emotion dichotomy is a false one?
- jczhang 11y agoNo its not, but how do you account for feeling about something that goes against your logic? Ie quitting a job without finding another. How is emotion guiding logic in every case?
- droopyEyelids 11y agoThe emotion doesn't tell you 'quit without finding another job' it says "I don't like this" which prompts you to use your logic to change your environment.
- reagency 11y agoEmotions motivate you to act to improve your situation instead of do nothing. They may be illogical, but they kickstart the thinking process. Logic is useless if you don't wake up and use it. Emotions are the first past filter to bring issues to your attention.
- reagency 11y agoEmotions motivate you to act to improve your situation instead of do nothing. They may be illogical, but they kickstart the thinking process. Logic is useless if you don't wake up and use it. Emotions are the first past filter to bring issues to your attention.
- ZenoArrow 11y agoOne logical statement doesn't have to support another logical statement. We wouldn't be able to get logical paradoxes such as the Paradox of the Court without conflicts in logic... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_the_Court https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_the_Court With regards to quitting a job without finding another, taken rationally you could argue that the individual has decided that in order to have the positive outlook required to land a new job they need to remove themselves from a negative environment they find themselves in. Such an outlook is logical, it recognises that emotional state has a large impact on confidence, and that confidence is a very useful attribute for landing a new job. Of course it could also be much simpler than that, that the individual just wants to improve their emotional state in the short term, not all logic has to apply eternally. That's just a basic example. A more complex example is what we understand by 'truth'. To me, we know when something is true because we feel it, or in other words truth has an emotional response. Is that your experience also?
- IAmNotACellist 11y agoIt's always fascinating to see the Pixar PR machine at work. "Guys, this July 4th weekend remember that there's a great family movie called Pixar's 'Inside Out!' Pixar made it, and it's family friendly, starring an eleven year old girl and these various situations that you can relate to. Scientists think emotions are good, but sometimes when they appear bad they're also good." It was published July 3rd, too.
- rustynails 11y agoThe science behind the movie was very clever. What has disappointed me is that Disney/Pixar keep on pushing the sexism gambit in their movies. This movie wasn't as bad as some of their others, but they are Consistently failing to address gender in a balanced way. Does anyone male in this movie do/say anything good? What about Frozen? The stupid (Wessleton) and nasty (Hans) are only male. Brave? Same thread. The kings/Princes are all obnoxious and/or stupid. Wreck-it-Ralph : Kowalski strikes Ralph across the face as a show of might and it's meant to be funny (ie. The modern assertive woman who bashes men as "humour") Several of the tinkerbell movies where ratchet & clank are the typical stupid males (and in most of them, they are almost the only males). To be fair. They do portray the southern belle as a dimwitted hick too, which is the stupid southerner prejudice emanating from the U.S. civil war. However, they did a great job with Tangled and Princess and the frog - there's a much better gender balance in those movies. It's a shame. You take your kids to see a supposedly family friendly movie and you cringe at the sexism that is pushed by the writers and directors. Do you just shrug it off, wondering if this prejudice won't rub off on your kids - or do you highlight the sexism to your kids and ask how a large studio could be so consistent in their bias, despite their deep attention to the science. I can't help feel there is more sexism and more conscious sexism than there has ever been. It really makes me sad.
- 1stop 11y agoWhat about Toy Story, Incredibles, Cars, Up... Oh wait they completely invalidate your point, I get why you left them out. Or are you saying the sexism bias came in after the acquisition? So it's a Disney thing? Ignoring the fact that they are a company based around a massive Princess franchise, you are wondering why they like to manufacture princesses? Did you forget the two male leads in Frozen? (Kristof and Olaf). Do you point out the sexism in almost every facet of life to your kids? Or does this dilemma just hit you at disney movies? If your children are daughters, do you explain to them they should expect less from the world, because historic statistics show they are going to get less? Or if they are sons, do you explain how they will get more simply by being male?
- qznc 11y ago> One of us suggested that the film include the full array of emotions now studied in science, but Mr. Docter rejected this idea for the simple reason that the story could handle only five or six characters. What is the full array of emotions? Having seen "Lie to Me" I know about the emotions expressed by microexpressions, but I do not know if there are more. "Joy" is not on that list. Either it is no emotion in the scientific world or expressed differently. Any good links?
- soneca 11y agoSorry about the lack of links, but this os how i remember things. Microexpressions representing emotions, as representes in 'lie to me' are a lie. The scientist behind the research that inspired the show admites he faked his research. I am mobile right now, but if you search microexpressions here in HN you will find it Edit: i found it http://m.chronicle.com/article/The-Liars-Tell/149261/ http://m.chronicle.com/article/The-Liars-Tell/149261/ and apparently my memory stretched the truth a little using the strong words 'admited' and 'fake'. But it is a debatable research
- alisey 11y agoEvery basic emotions researcher comes up with a different list. But most of the lists include some version of fear, anger, disgust, and joy (but not sadness). "Emotional Brain" by Joseph LeDoux, chapter 5 has more info on various lists. From the same book: James Averill, a major proponent of social constructivism, describes a behavior pattern, called “being a wild pig”, that is quite unusual by Western standards, but is common and even “normal” among the Gururumba, a horticultural people living in the highlands of New Zealand. The behavior gets its name by analogy. There are no undomesticated pigs in this culture, but occasionally, and for unknown reasons, a domesticated one will go through a temporary condition in which it runs wild. But the pig can, with appropriate measures, be redomesticated and returned to the normal pig life among the villagers. And, in a similar vein, Gururumba people can act this way, becoming violent and aggressive and looting and stealing, but seldom causing harm or taking anything of importance, and eventually returning to routine life. In some instances, after several days of living in the forest, during which time the stolen objects are destroyed, the person returns to the village spontaneously with no memory of the experience and is never reminded of the event by the villagers. Others, though, have to be captured and treated like a wild pig - held over a smoking fire until the old self returns […] Averill uses “being a wild pig” to support his claim that “most standard emotional reactions are socially constructed or institutionalized patterns of response” rather than biologically determined events.
- anticon 11y agoI haven't watched this yet, but the trailer really put me off. Is the movie as sexist and as obnoxious as the trailer? Is this another movie for critics rather than for children? (Up!, Wall-e)
- teh_klev 11y agoSlightly OT, but hearing about this film instantly reminded me of a childhood comic strip called The Numskulls that appeared in various DC Thomson comics: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Numskulls https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Numskulls http://www.fustar.info/2006/12/02/193/ http://www.fustar.info/2006/12/02/193/ https://duckduckgo.com/?q=the+numskulls+comic+strip&ia=images https://duckduckgo.com/?q=the+numskulls+comic+strip&ia=image...
- mhurron 11y agoWow ... I hadn't thought of the Beano for god knows how long.