3 ms·
> To what extent do Spain's entitlement obligations (health care, retirement, &c) track its economy? Greece apparently provides Scandinavian-grade benefits on A
by bjourne 11y ago
> To what extent do Spain's entitlement obligations (health care, retirement, &c) track its economy? Greece apparently provides Scandinavian-grade benefits on Alabama-grade revenues.
The situation about Greece is mired with propaganda and media tells us that Greeks just want to lay on beach, never work and retire when they are 50. I've heard so many parrot that because they read it in a magazine and it is not true. Greeks work the most hours in the EU and their retirement age is higher: http://www.newstatesman.com/blogs/world-affairs/2012/05/exploding-myth-feckless-lazy-greeks http://www.newstatesman.com/blogs/world-affairs/2012/05/expl...
So there is no reason to believe that "Greece apparently provides Scandinavian-grade benefits on Alabama-grade revenues" is true if it is not backed up by stats proving it to be true.
- tptacek 11y agoYou've refuted a statistic I didn't provide. The full retirement age in the US in 66 (soon to be 67). The average retirement age in Greece is 61. 17.5% of Greece's GDP goes to retirement spending. US public retirement insurance is 5% of GDP. The comparison I made isn't "lazy" versus "industrious". It's "revenue vs. spending", using the USA and Scandinavia as anchors for comparison. Greek revenue is more like USA revenue than Swedish revenue. Greek spending is more like Swedish spending (Swedish retirement age: 65) than like USA spending. I'm trying not to make value judgements. I don't believe that the Greeks are lazy and sitting on beaches. It does, however, appear that their fiscal policy is mismanaged.
- bjourne 11y agoI can't refute your statement "Greece apparently provides Scandinavian-grade benefits on Alabama-grade revenues" because it is very vague. In either case the onus is on the person making the statements to back them up not on other persons to refute them. The reason I made the comparison with retirement age is because you can ask a random person on the street in Sweden or other country whether Greeks retire earlier than the EU average or not and (I'm sure) almost everyone people will say that they retire earlier even though that is false. Bluntly, you made two statements 1) Greece apparently provides Scandinavian-grade benefits and 2) [has] Alabama-grade revenues. Back them up with evidence or else you are just parroting back what someone else told you.
- tptacek 11y agoFirst, we're all just "parroting back what someone else told us", unless one of us is secretly an economist specializing in the public sector of Greece. That said: it's really not that vague. Go to the OECD stats site. Go to "Social Expenditure", isolate "old age" retirement benefits (which in Greece start at 61), go to the column on the table with the most recent full data, sort that column, note where Greece falls on it, note where Sweden falls on it, and note where the US falls on it. Now, in another tab maybe, go to Public Sector/Taxation, to comparative tables for tax revenue, and do "total tax revenue per capita". Make the same comparisons. You will note that the US actually gets quite a bit more money per citizen than Greece does. My intuition was the same, which is why I chose Alabama for the comparison, not the US as a whole; Alabama is one of the least-taxed states in the union. It is true that the intuition to make this comparison came from someone else (in my case: Matt Yglesias, though lord knows where he got the idea to make the comparison). What is also true is that the assertion is verifiable.
- bjourne 11y agoThank you for checking. Do you mean the sheet "Public expenditure on old-age and survivors cash benefits, in % GDP"? What numbers are you comparing exactly? The stats I found end at 2011 and the Greeks pensions have been slashed since then so I wonder how reliable they are for their current pension benefits. Anyway I found stats for Finland (the only Scandinavian country using the Euro) for 2015 here: http://www.etk.fi/en/service/average_pensions/1453/average_pensions http://www.etk.fi/en/service/average_pensions/1453/average_p... and for Greece for 2015 here: http://www.macropolis.gr/?i=portal.en.the-agora.2622 http://www.macropolis.gr/?i=portal.en.the-agora.2622 If the numbers on those pages are true, then the average pensions per month are 1588 and 884 for Finland and Greece respectively.
- condescendence 11y ago>The situation about Greece is mired with propaganda and media tells us that Greeks just want to lay on beach, never work and retire when they are 50. I've heard so many parrot that because they read it in a magazine and it is not true. Greeks work the most hours in the EU and their retirement age is higher: http://www.newstatesman.com/blogs/world-affairs/2012/05/expl.. http://www.newstatesman.com/blogs/world-affairs/2012/05/expl.... This has nothing to do with what the commenter is arguing. What s/he is saying is that Greece was trying to provide top-tier medical advantages while their economy was running down the shitter. I don't really think we need "stats" to back this up. The economy is lackluster right now, how do you provide 'amazing' healthcare when there's no revenue? In 2000 Greece was ranked 14th in overall healthcare systems, above Germany and the United States![1] How do you provide that kind of medical industry without having a decent revenue stream or some way to fund it? Sure their economy might have been growing at that point. But when your economy shrinks and you have less revenue streams your public services need to shrink with it. [1]http://www.who.int/whr/2000/en/whr00_en.pdf http://www.who.int/whr/2000/en/whr00_en.pdf