5 ms·
False statements you have made about art: "The paintings made between 1430 and 1500 are still unsurpassed." (easy refutation - go to sistine chapel, look up).
by idlewords 17y ago
False statements you have made about art:
"The paintings made between 1430 and 1500 are still unsurpassed." (easy refutation - go to sistine chapel, look up).
"What made oil paint so exciting, when it first became popular in the fifteenth century, was that you could actually make the finished work from the prototype."
This is not how people painted with oil until the 19th century. It was a very expensive medium requiring careful preparatory work, sketches, and so on.
"Most painters start with a blurry sketch and gradually refine it." - completely unsupported.
"Line drawings are in fact the most difficult visual medium" - yes, carving marble is much easier.
"When oil paint replaced tempera in the fifteenth century, it helped painters to deal with difficult subjects like the human figure because, unlike tempera, oil can be blended and overpainted." - again, this is how oil paint was used much later. At the time it was painted in thin, transparent layers that did not allow the kind of reworking you learned four hundred years later in art class.
And now we have 'Cézanne can't draw" to add to the list.
Many of your other statements about art fall more in the 'not even wrong' category - fatuous generalizations based on your own tastes, but presented as deep insights about the world.
So it is a little disingenuous of you to keep asking for people to point to specific places where you are wrong. The wrong is diffusely and uniformly distributed.
- unalone 17y ago"The paintings made between 1430 and 1500 are still unsurpassed." Art has progressed so much in the last 500 years that this comparison is utterly absurd. Francis Bacon comes to mind as a painter whose works simply cannot be compared to earlier pieces.
- Retric 17y agoI am always amazed when people fall in love with an artist I consider a talentless hack. PS: In the tradition of things you can't say. Science killed philosophy as a meaningful activity. And the camera killed painting as meaningful activity. They have become the refuge of talented youths and over-educated idiots.
- zimbabwe 17y agoFirst point: Just to clarify, you're calling Bacon a talentless hack? Bacon, the master of nightmarish imagery? Second point: Define meaningful. Philosophy, science, photography, painting, all are essentially ways of passing time before death, if we want to use the cosmic scale; on the personal level each activity has different meanings to different people. I'm not a big philosopher, but I enjoy that much more than science. Science bores me. Where is it written that philosophy can't evolve based on scientific findings? And what makes you think painting's not useful? Perhaps portraits aren't as meaningful, but even there, designing a web site for a musician I commissioned a painting of him rather than a photo. With paintings you can specify colors ahead of time and make something that fits for the design. So there's an example of an archaic medium being used for modern purposes. I don't like very much your us-versus-them mentality here. I don't like your suggestion that there's such a thing as too much education. My policy is, to each their own. I'll continue to be fascinated by those over-educated idiots I call my friends, and you can continue to do whatever you choose with your own time.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- Retric 17y agoFirst point: Yes. I expect some refinement of an artist's craft over time. Just look at his faces. As a point of comparison my sister is a long way from mastery but he presents a reasonable progression for a HS student. 14 years old: http://geomexia.deviantart.com/art/Wired-Mother-Earth-27347495 http://geomexia.deviantart.com/art/Wired-Mother-Earth-273474... 15 years old: http://geomexia.deviantart.com/art/Deep-Sea-Gold-34634785 http://geomexia.deviantart.com/art/Deep-Sea-Gold-34634785 17 years old: http://geomexia.deviantart.com/art/Looking-Up-37173397 http://geomexia.deviantart.com/art/Looking-Up-37173397 18 years old: http://geomexia.deviantart.com/art/Turn-Around-Turn-Around-137801049 http://geomexia.deviantart.com/art/Turn-Around-Turn-Around-1... Bacon had some interesting ideas, but he lacked the skills to really explore them. IMO, that is forgivable for a dabbler or young person, but it's just not acceptable for a serious artist. Second when looking for truth, philosophy is a dead end. You can still use a horse and buggy to get around New York but there is a reason it's become far less popular over time. Painting as a means to convey meaning from an artist to his audience has been similarly demoted because there are better ways to capture what you have seen. Leaving panting with abstract ideas better conveyed though words and meaningless garbage.
- EliAndrewC 17y agoSome of this speaks to PG's "Writing to Discover" (http://paulgraham.com/discover.html http://paulgraham.com/discover.html) observations. When he says, "The paintings made between 1430 and 1500 are still unsurpassed" then my impression is that he's just stating his opinion. But because he doesn't bother to preface it with, "Well this is just my opinion, but..." then it sounds like everything that he says is, as you say, "generalizations based on [his] own tastes, but presented as deep insights about the world". So because all of his statements aren't prefaced with "sometimes it seems to me" or "I wonder if" or "Maybe it's the case that", then it comes across like he's speaking as if everything he says is absolute truth, whereas a lot of it is simply his musings about the world. I totally understand why this rubs a lot of people the wrong way. Personally I prefer his current writing style, where he doesn't qualify everything he says with, "in my experience" or "among the artists I've known personally" or whatever. With that being said, I can't comment on your factual corrections about the history of oil painting.
- gatormax 17y agoI would expect that you're correct, given your stint as a professional painter, something Mr. Graham cannot lay claim to. And it doesn't really matter. The "Hackers and Painters" essay is not about painting, nor the strict similarities between "hacking" and painting. It is about the fact that "hackers" do both design and development. This is different from the conventional notion of product development existing separate from engineering. The painting analogy is merely a (successful) vehicle for communicating this distinction. I think this is obvious, and I assume you know it. The bitterness in your riposte, especially the invocation of sexual neener-neenerism, perplexes a bit. Perhaps as a painter you take offense to the imperfect use of painting as an analogy. This seems excessive. "Tomate un geniol." (I am neither a "hacker" nor a painter.)
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- akkartik 17y agoTurns out 'weenis' isn't sexual at all. But yes, the name calling is a huge distraction.
- pg 17y agoActually you're mistaken in all 6 cases: 1. easy refutation - go to sistine chapel, look up You're claiming that the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel is better (not just as good, but better) than everything Leonardo and Bellini ever painted. The number of art historians who'd agree with that statement is zero. 2. This is not how people painted with oil until the 19th century. http://static.squidoo.com/resize/squidoo_images/-1/draft_lens2016901module10642403photo_1217059430hals-malle-babbe-detail_.jpg http://static.squidoo.com/resize/squidoo_images/-1/draft_len... 3. completely unsupported. Your counterclaim is likewise completely unsupported. But anyone who wants to settle the matter can choose any "how to paint" type book published in the 20th century, and they'll see that was considered the default technique. 4. carving marble is much easier Carving marble requires more specialized training, but the kind of difficulty I was talking about was how critically viewers judge the result. They are tough on sculpture too, but I think they are as tough on line drawing. The less there is, the more closely it's examined. 5. At the time it was painted in thin, transparent layers that did not allow the kind of reworking http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pentimento http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pentimento http://www.escholarship.org/editions/data/13030/d9/ft1d5nb0d9/figures/ft1d5nb0d9_00061.jpg http://www.escholarship.org/editions/data/13030/d9/ft1d5nb0d... 6. If you want to offer any actual counterargument about Cezanne's drawing, feel free.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- idlewords 17y agoWow, you really want to do this? 2 - I like Frans Hals too! 3 - Yes, that's how painting is taught now, to the kind of people who read 'how to paint' books. 4 - Nice weaseling. 5 - Notice how those carefully fixed errors show fully-drawn hands, feet, etc., rather than a cloud of "rough drafts" like you would see in a painting done in the modern style? Another nice demonstration of the point that oil painting was not a fluid, iterative medium in its first few hundred years. 6. Try one of the numerous image links in the thread. As for 1, Aaron Swartz sent us both this quote the first time you and I had this argument, and I'm surprised you've forgotten it. It's from Graham Larkin, curator of the National Gallery of Canada, whom he asked to adjudicate your claim: ""By even the most conservative standards (which your buddy seem to be applying), you'd need to go at least a few decades further, into the High Renaissance. Julius II's didn't even start commissioning Michelangelo's Sistine Ceiling and Raphael's Vatican Stanze (School of Athens &c) didn't start until 1508. These works don't exactly represent a decline, except by Preraphealite standards which would judge them as over-sophisitcated and lacking in primitive simplicity. (That's IT: your friend's a Preraphaelite! Well history is not on his or her side; such Victorian predilections are a mere blip in the history of Western aesthetics.) The generation after the giant Raphael (and the giant Durer in the North) is a much better candidate for cultural and artistic decline--a story complicated by Michaelangelo's inconvenient longevity. Historians have often pointed to the 1527 Sack of Rome as a downturn in artistic ferment, or at least in the unparalleled ascendancy of Italy. I would add that Western painting of around 1500 can scarcely be separated from the other visual arts, including the still-young (to the West) technology of print, brought to incredible levels of sophistication by Durer and others in precisely the post-1500 decades. One wonders whether your friend meant "1500" or "like, 1500."" Of course, Dr. Larkin gets one thing wrong. You're not a pre-Raphaelite, you're just a big ole weenis.