3 ms·
This post is weird. There are a lot of reasons to be annoyed and most of those have nothing to do with the cause, but the means employed. Riddle me this: Let's
by scrollaway 11y ago
This post is weird. There are a lot of reasons to be annoyed and most of those have nothing to do with the cause, but the means employed.
Riddle me this: Let's say some tech company has to match a man/woman quota of at least 40% on a CS position. (This is a pretty common theme in various places)
Going by the numbers in this post, there's a 1.6% ratio in the author's class. Let's be extremely generous and say there's a 9:1 male/female ratio in CS.
With those numbers, there's a 30% skew in favour of female employees. In a sector with a 9:1 male ratio, that means one in three male employee is rejected because of numbers. The real ratio is actually MUCH higher, remember. And on the other side of the equation, female employees would be very aggressively sought after because positions are not actually easy to fill and just because you can find the bodies doesn't mean the employees are good. Is this where we want to end up?
End sidetrack. There's a lot of causes out there. Discrimination, everything. But feminism, I think, annoys more than others because it promotes unhealthy "fixes" such as this one above. You don't want to force people into a new belief system, you want to change their belief system. The former is super awkward for places where discrimination doesn't happen, and imho just perpetuates the issue.
You want more women in CS? Make technology look like less of a boy's club at an early age (and leading into tech education) and wait 15 years for the results. I think the Minecraft kids generation will yield some pretty fantastic surprises on that level.
- rayiner 11y agoRe: forcing people. One of the great victories of our time was the federal government beating people over the head with racial equality. Broadly interpreting the 14th amendment and commerce clause to make not just de jure discrimination illegal, but trampling on peoples' core rights of association to tell them they had to invite blacks into their restaurants and hotels. It was ugly and a gross overstepping of the government's bounds, but necessary because the people needed to be civilized and they weren't going to civilize themselves in any reasonable timescale. If the government hadn't brought down the hammer we might still have a segregated south today. It's ugly and not always the right answer, but sometimes you need to beat civilization into people. I'm not suggesting we need the government to be involved. But sometimes you need top down intervention to fix a problem, and the fix isn't necessarily fair while its in progress. Sometimes top-down intervention is the only way to fix a problem in the long run, because he actors with power have no incentive to self-improve.
- etherael 11y agoThis argument could've been used to justify Belgian involvement in the Congo, as well as criticise ever leaving Africa to it's own devices. Sometimes, y'know, you've just got to beat civilisation into people. I really wish you'd think more on this, and think long and hard. It's really depressing to see someone who I know is intelligent and thoughtful, although I deeply disagree with them, promoting such an abhorrent position. Lastly, also; > he actors with power have no incentive to self-improve. (sic) Bring that to its logical conclusion with regards to the entity imposing the top down violence in order to beat civilisation into people.
- pliny 11y ago>You want more women in CS? Make technology look like less of a boy's club at an early age (and leading into tech education) and wait 15 years for the results. I think the Minecraft kids generation will yield some pretty fantastic surprises on that level. The only way I can make sense of the gender / race quotas for technical positions is that it's a bootstrapping problem: something along the lines of (i) Women don't want to pursue careers in tech because it's a boys club. (ii) It's a boy's club because there aren't enough women in tech (i) (iii) There aren't enough women in tech because women dont want to pursue careers in tech (ii) Which seems to be an intractable problem without outside interference. So if you decided that you were willing to make tough sacrifices (or force other people to make tough sacrifices) then you could solve (ii) by forcing/encouraging tech companies to hire more women even if they're less qualified than male candidates and that would solve (i) by making women want to purse careers in tech now that it isn't a boys club which would solve (iii) by changing women more likely to want to pursue careers in tech and (wait several decades) presto now you don't have to discriminate anymore. That said, I hope you're correct about the Minecraft stuff because that would very conveniently solve the problem without anybody having to do anything they don't already want to (but hoping that problems solve themselves is a bad problem solving strategy).