3 ms·
The article seems to say: "Feminists annoy me because they are right". This is not why feminists annoy me, though. I don't think they are right at all. So the
by mike_hearn 11y ago
The article seems to say: "Feminists annoy me because they are right".
This is not why feminists annoy me, though. I don't think they are right at all. So the title of the blog post seems to extrapolate her own views out into a universal truth.
This sort of thinking is especially dangerous:
> With the same high school grades a white person has a 78% higher chance of being admitted to a university than a person of color
I do not know where this stat comes from as she provides a cartoon instead of a reference, but assuming it's not a trivially bogus stat (e.g. because of differences in application rates), it sounds a lot like it could be a Simpson's Paradox:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson's_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson's_paradox
The very same argument was made to suggest a gender bias in admissions at an American university (Berkeley): when you selected just people with the same grades, more men were accepted than women. Sexual discrimination!!!
The problem is, when they tried to figure out which department was discriminating, the bias disappeared (actually became slightly in favour of women). It turned out to be a statistical anomaly caused by the fact that women tended to apply for much more competitive courses than men, like English Lit, so they were rejected more often due to overcapacity - not due to their gender. When you select only application rates and gender, this type of data abuse causes misleading conclusions.
I don't know that the race stat is another example of this, but I find it hard to believe that such a dramatic case of racism across so many institutions could persist for so long without severe legal problems, if it was as open and shut as Felienne suggests.
Final issue I have with this blog post:
> You believe God put dinosaur bones in the earth to test your faith, you think vaccines cause autism? Yes, that’s crazy but also funny haha who cares?
The first is harmless belief that doesn't normally impact other people, the second triggers preventable outbreaks of exceptionally serious diseases. So lots of people care and parents opting out of vaccinations is a very controversial issue right now! It seems very strange to use this as an example!
- iopq 11y agoIt could be that white people with the same grades as people of color have higher SAT scores or any other factor that is not being stated. Or it COULD BE that people of color includes East Asians that actually get discriminated against BECAUSE they're so successful in college. I'd like to see the actual sources on the claim because it's too vague for me to comment on.
- octatoan 11y agoGoing against established scientific fact does hurt other people. What if you have kids and turn them into young-earth creationists as well?
- shoo 11y agoWhat you are saying is superficially reasonable! But it is possible to argue the other direction in few ways: * what if you raise kids to have a keen understanding of the scientific method, and other skills/knowledge that asist them in achieving their aims, but also encourage them to be selfish sociopaths? Would this be better than raising highly moral, altruistic young-earth creationists? * What if the net result of our civilisation's scientific and technological development is that we kill off all of the species / generally wreck the planet? Perhaps it would have been better to live in a more "traditional" society that resists the adoption of new ideas/practices. Perhaps life would not be so comfortable as it is now, but it might be far more sustainable! edit: I guess the overall point I am trying to make is that scientific principles is but one of a set of tools that lets you more effectively learn-about/predict/control your environment. Another example of a similarly useful tool could be "negotation skills". But, in itself, having access to these tools does not immediately make you less likely to cause harm. They merely make you more potentially more effective. But is it a positive thing that that you are now more effective? It depends what you're trying to achieve!