3 ms·
TFA is arguing the private creditors got off far too easily. Having made the loans of their own accord, pocketing the interest payments up to that point, you ca
by zaroth 11y ago
TFA is arguing the private creditors got off far too easily. Having made the loans of their own accord, pocketing the interest payments up to that point, you can be sure the private creditors were quite happy to have the debt off their hands in 2012. This is the largest transfer from private credit to public credit in history, right? These are the same loans Greece is now actually completely unable to service.
The paper talks about creditors taking haircuts, but then in the next paragraph that this resulted in very little actual debt relief for Greece? If private credits really had to absorb 50% haircuts on $100 billion of debt, point me to the massive string of bankruptcies? If I understand correctly, the "haircuts" are projections based on net present value using some arbitrary high discount rates (the paper mentions 9% !!!) so you have to appreciate that with a different discount rate you could claim the private debt holders were actually being paid even > 100 cents on the dollar.
Using this 5 per cent discount rate to compare old
and proposed new debt flows, the debt relief
implied by the July 2011 financing offer would
have been approximately zero – indeed, slightly
negative. Using the “risk free” discount rate of
about 3.5 per cent (not shown in the table),
would indicate an *increase* of Greece’s debt burden by
about 11-15 per cent [over] the July 2011.
That's from your quoted article! Doesn't sound like such a great haircut to me... Any time private banks are being bailed out, I'm going to assume that they are being well enriched in the process. Just the way of the world. People will just play with the numbers to suit a given narrative, so it's hard to even find a "truth" in all this. A 9% discount rate for sovereign debt is insane though. Almost any NPV analysis is going to look like shit against a 9% discount.
EDIT: I read further down into the paper, and the actual discount rates used to arrive at the "59 - 64%" haircut range for the 2012 restructuring were 15.3% - 18.7%. Just WOW. So, yes, creditors were NOT paid the full NPV on over a hundred billion of dollars of debt being carried through maturity at rates higher than my credit cards. This should surprise exactly no one.
- derriz 11y agoI don't think you understand NVP and debt. You seem to be suggesting Greek debt be discounted at something close to the risk free rate? These discount rates are correct. The value of a promise of future cash payments from the Greek government is worth far less than one from the US or German governments for example. If you actually believe that Greek debt should be discounted much less, I'll happily swap any amount of (say 10 year) Greek bonds with you if you give me the equivalent face value of 10 year US treasuries or German bunds. Since you think the NVP should be similar, you should be happy to take the deal.
- tomp 11y agoIf you can expect to be bailed outif the debtor defaults, then yes, you should use the risk free rate for discounting.
- derriz 11y agoNope - haircuts are calculated relative to current asset values. For example, when discussing the haircut on a 100m greek bond that's currently trading for 60m, giving the holder 60m for it does not constitute a 40% haircut.