2 ms·
Did you read my response to maaku above? You're arguing against a bunch of strawmen points. I'm not saying that there is no difference between the two things;
by derefr 11y ago
Did you read my response to maaku above? You're arguing against a bunch of strawmen points.
I'm not saying that there is no difference between the two things; I'm saying that an "activity" is a concept that belongs primarily to the cluster in conceptspace representing that activity's goals and affordances, and you should evaluate an instantiation of an activity relative to other instantiations of that activity, rather than relative to other activities available in the same medium.
Or, to put that more simply, I'm saying that you should treat e.g. Minecraft as an instance of the kind of thing that Lego is, compare the two based on their merits (with e.g. Lego on the motor coordination side, as you said), and only then decide what you want or don't want your kids playing with.
The point I was trying to make is that, for example, telling a child to "turn off their computer and read a book" is nonsense if they were reading a book on the computer. Both things are books. In this case, there is no additional merit on either side of the ledger; in either case, the affordance is "text" and the interaction is "moving your eyes to absorb it."
Likewise, it is nonsense to tell your child to "get off the computer and go play with your friends" when all their friends are stuck at home due to their own overprotective parents, and so the only place they can freely see their friends is on the computer. You're making an assumption based on the medium (that the computer is solitary and real life is social), whereas in the specific case-by-case evaluation at that moment, the opposite is true.
Again note how I'm not suggesting the experiences are one-for-one replacements for one-another. Of course they're not. But the degree to which they're not is exactly the same degree that any other instantiation of the same {goals, affordances} tuple—any other instance of the same activity—is not.
And one more alternate phrasing, for redundancy's sake: in the set {computer game, board game, card game}, the adjective "computer" doesn't magically make the first element more N-dimensionally distant from the other two than they are to one-another. You should do the same evaluation when comparing the merits of the computer game to the card game, that you would when comparing the merits of the card game to the board game. Don't bias yourself by assuming that anything on a computer is going to have the same merits and the same drawbacks. The medium is not the central cluster to which the activity belongs. It's just a property in the equation.