3 ms·
> "The world is full of unworthy and unscrupulous entities willing to take your money and call the transaction a “loan”. It always will be. That is why responsi
by dnautics 11y ago
> "The world is full of unworthy and unscrupulous entities willing to take your money and call the transaction a “loan”. It always will be. That is why responsibility for, and the consequences of, extending credit badly must fall upon creditors, not debtors. There is one morality tale that says the debtor must repay, or she has sinned and must be punished. There is another morality tale that says the creditor must invest wisely, or she has stewarded resources poorly and must be punished. We get to choose which morality tale we most use to make sense of the world. We do, and surely should, use both to some degree. But if we emphasize the first story, we end up in a world full of bad loans, wasted resources, and people trapped in debtors’ prison, metaphorical or literal. If we emphasize the second story, we end up in a world where dumb expenditures are never financed in the first place."
This is great. What, then, about a middle road? Absolve greece of its debts. Write off its liability as a sunk cost, let bygones be bygones. Then cut it off from the ECB. Let the government figure out how to run a sustainable economy, and when they're ready, bring them back in.
- reagency 11y agoThat quote is silly, it completely justifies fraud. There has to be a balance.
- icebraining 11y agoThe quote says "emphasize", not "ignore the other view". The balance is implicit.
- crdoconnor 11y agoThe balance can involve slamming the individuals in jail who enabled Greece to misrepresent its finances before it joined. Unfortunately, actually prosecuting fraud seems to be a minority view, whereas punishing entire countries (primarily those on a low income, too) for the sins of a few is the norm in Europe.
- Xylakant 11y agoSome of these individuals were greek and are under greek jurisdiction. None were prosecuted. It would give the moral position of the greek government a huge boost if they started doing that, just like Iceland did in its default.
- kylebrown 11y agoQuoting from a comment on the linked article: > I’d only add that the corrupt elites were not only overspending, but they were involved in vendor finance scams. Hundreds of millions in bribes on some single deals. The credit came through to sign the contracts, and the bribes were rolled into the contracts. On one deal alone, Siemens, you had the Greek defense minister take hundreds of millions to approve a tens of billions deal. He is in jail, so are members of his family, but then there are 64 others being prosecuted as well for this one deal. Think about it, hundreds of millions spread to 64 people (who probably doled out more themselves).