7 ms·
> We seem to have settled on the WIMP (windows, icons, menus, pointer) model, and there is very little real innovation in interface design anymore. It's an int
by vbezhenar 11y ago
> We seem to have settled on the WIMP (windows, icons, menus, pointer) model, and there is very little real innovation in interface design anymore.
It's an interesting exercise to compare this to the mobile platforms, e.g. iOS. Windows are gone. Icons are here. Menus are changed. Pointer is changed too (your finger is pointer, not an abstract arrow).
Though on OS X desktop I don't see any innovations at all! May be I'm missing something? Windows, icons, menu, pointer, that's all. Probably gestures are an innovation, but it isn't used widely except in operating system windows manager and Safari. Can we think of a tabs as an innovation? I never really liked them, I believe that tabs could be replaced by better window management. It's something that tied to application now, but it should be tied to a window manager and probably in better ways.
Desktop user interface is definitely stagnating, if we're talking about OS X. I don't know much about new Windows releases, but in Windows 7 it was the same story.
- vezzy-fnord 11y agoEven mobile platforms are pretty WIMP-y, especially ones that actually have multiple workspaces. We're still a long way from Oberon, Acme and Bluebottle OS-style interfaces, which are truly "innovative".
- smacktoward 11y ago> Windows are gone Ehhh, yes and no; as mobile OSes have gotten more multitasking-friendly they've moved towards the "card" metaphor, in which each app runs in a card and there's some method for shuffling between them. And a card is really just a window that's maximized 100% of the time. (Which is how most general users use windows on the desktop, so they're not losing much.)
- userbinator 11y agoHopefully the reason for a lack of windows on mobile devices is because their screens are too small to manipulate them effectively with a finger. Which is how most general users use windows on the desktop, so they're not losing much. I've noticed this too, and it's puzzling - I've seen people maximise browsers on large monitors and end up with a narrow column of text surrounded by tons of blank space, or the more difficult-to-read extremely wide lines of text. Why don't they resize their windows to a comfortable width, and also gain the advantage of being able to interact with the other things outside the window? I very rarely maximise any windows, but usually have several of them arranged such that I can see the important bits of each one and switch between them easily. One thing I do a lot is comparing the information in different windows, so perhaps it's entirely natural that I do this. It's definitely better than the alternative of switching repeatedly between full-screen windows and memorising their contents...
- eterm 11y ago> I've seen people maximise browsers on large monitors I am guilty of this, but what's odd is that it is something I only do in a Windows environment. When I'm in gnome or other linux environment I don't tend to ever maximise windows, but when I'm in a Windows environment I almost never not maximise windows. I don't know what it is, whether it is an aesthetic thing or other reason I've not yet worked out why I have such different modes of working.
- xanderstrike 11y agoIt depends a lot on your screen size. Below ~19" I just keep everything maximized and use hotkeys to rapidly switch between windows. I'm usually flipping between a text editor and web browser. On even a rather large laptop, 50% of the screen width is too small for web pages. Unless you're doing data entry I doubt you're memorizing the contents of one window to input it in another, and if you're doing that copy/paste exists.
- azernik 11y agoI think it's a consequence of one of the points TFA brought up - WIMP systems were originally designed to approach modelessness, but users want modal interfaces. They want to go into the context of an application and then switch into a "mode" where they only need to know about the keyboard shortcuts, UI idioms, etc. of that one application. Sometimes you can't accomplish a task like this, but on the frequent occasions when that happens I'm reminded of exactly how annoying it is to, for example, look at a screen that's split between browser and terminal and switch back and forth between the very different interaction paradigms the two require.
- zanny 11y agoI have a triple monitor setup, so almost everything is maximized and I do mobile like card flipping between them with alt-tab. I have a stack of browsers on one, a stack of IDEs on another, etc. If things get out of hand I throw a bunch of windows in a separate activity. Sometimes I turn on the KDE card flip effect to feel silly.
- kartickvad 11y agoI maximise windows to eliminate distraction. I'd rather finish reading the article I'm reading, for example, and then Cmd-Tab to something else, rather than obsessively glancing at a Gmail window a dozen times through the article. More the multitasking, the more stressed I get. One thing at a time is relaxing, and more productive. Feeling frantic doesn't result in any more work, or higher quality work, being done, after all. I maximise windows even on my 30-inch monitor. Recently, I've switched to full-screen. I wish I could tell OS X to launch apps full-screen by default. Windows should, for me, be the exception, not the norm. This is one aspect where mobile OSs are superior, for me.
- leoc 11y agoAnd they're not even always maximised now either (thank God).
- braythwayt 11y ago> as mobile OSes have gotten more multitasking-friendly they've moved towards > the "card" metaphor, in which each app runs in a card and there's some > method for shuffling between them. And a card is really just a window > that's maximized 100% of the time. (Which is how most general users use > windows on the desktop, so they're not losing much.) Meet the new boss, same as the old boss. “Switcher,” written by Andy Hertzfeld, October 1984-1985. http://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?story=Switcher.txt http://www.folklore.org/StoryView.py?story=Switcher.txt Developer’s instructions: http://macgui.com/usenet/?group=8&id=1113 http://macgui.com/usenet/?group=8&id=1113
- jrochkind1 11y ago> And a card is really just a window that's maximized 100% of the time. Ah, but that's not a 'window' at all in fact. That's how things worked _before_ the innovation of the 'window' UI, one 'screen' on the monitor at once, but maybe you can switch between them. The whole point of "windows" as a UI element is that it's not that. > (Which is how most general users use windows on the desktop, so they're not losing much.) It may indeed be that windows have not been a particularly successful UI pattern after all. :) Apple seems to tentatively trying to see if they can move away from them on desktop too, making it more like iOS, with the OSX full-screen mode.
- hrktb 11y ago> Probably gestures are an innovation, but it isn't used widely except in operating system windows manager and Safari I give a lot more credit to the multitouch trackpad. Gestures are a great (and they work basically anywhere there are clear 'back'/'forward' navigation actions), scrolling is actually more efficient and painless than with one or more wheels; we also got rid of physical fixed buttons. I initially switched to a magic trackpad to see if it would alleviate RSI like problems, but for how I use it I found it way more efficient than the mouse in the end. I think the advances in trackpad usability on OS X are the main reason there is less pressure to have a touch screen.
- mrsteveman1 11y agoDid you ultimately find that the magic trackpad helped with RSI issues?
- hrktb 11y agoYes, definitively. In my case the pain was mainly in my index doing all the clicking and repeative scrolling. Scrolling without articulating my fingers helped a lot, and being able to do it with any combination of two fingers was a plus. Same goes with being able to alternatively use the thumb or the index to click Now I'm clearly less fast/precise than with a mouse, so I heavily rely on additional tools and shortcuts to avoid as much as I can to hunt Tiny areas with the pointer. Like using a windows manager like slate or spectacles to stop hunting the corner of the windows when resizing, or relying more on spotlight search to avoid clicking small icons in huge application lists, etc.
- jimmaswell 11y agoIt's not "stagnating", there's simply not much need to "innovate" it anymore. It works well for both new and advanced users. Changing the standard UI would just be a pointless frustration - see Windows 8.
- sanoli 11y agoI always laugh when I hear someone complaining about the WIMP model where their main argument is "it's been the same way for xx years, with no real innovation since its beginning". Right, and the steering wheel sucks so bad as a driving interface because it's so old and hasn't changed any. A couple of years ago there were these 3D interfaces being designed, with the intention of replacing the WIMP dsktop 2D space, and I remember one guy saying how the biggest mistake in computer interfaces was done because somebody decided to attach a typewriter to a TV, meaning we only took what we had and used them as models for what to do (typewriter->keyboard; TV->monitor). Sorry, but no, the stuff worked, and it worked pretty well. It's like this not because it sucks, but because it's actually quite good. I also always think about the simple light switch on every wall. Not to be replaced with sensors so soon, even though it always seems like it's close to being so.
- metasean 11y agoChanging for change sake is bad, but questioning long-held assumptions can lead to highly desirable changes. I largely agree that what we have works, but I also like to see how it may change. One example that's been big in my life is the transition from a mouse to a trackpad. The mouse worked in many cases, but it was a nuisance for laptops. In my case, they also caused excruciating repetitive stress related-tendinitis which, thankfully, a laptop trackpad doesn't. Funny you mention simple light switches not being "replaced with sensors so soon". Years ago, the very first modification I made when I moved into my house was to replace many of the simple light switches with motion, light, and time-based sensors, and a few with dimmer switches.
- jimmaswell 11y agoI always found trackpads to hurt my hand somewhat after a while in contrast with mice. Maybe you just had bad mice?
- x5n1 11y agoGestures are 90s technology. There were shareware programs to facilitate that back then. There was no touch screen though. That's the difference.
- jrochkind1 11y agoI'm pretty sure there are more "mobile" (smartphone and touch-tablet) devices being sold than there are desktop+laptop devices being sold. And this probably isn't going to change. So I expect desktop to keep stagnating. At some point the 'standard' desktop UI will probably merge somehow with the sorts of UI used on mobile instead.
- esolyt 11y agoIsn't that what Microsoft tried to do with Windows 8?
- jrochkind1 11y agoYup.
- snowwrestler 11y agoThe big innovations in OS X are: - Tabs allow you condense like windows into one. Collections of windows now have context with one another. - Window management keys/gestures like Expose or Mission Control allow for many more active windows without getting lost. - High speed local search (called Spotlight on the Mac) reduces the need for nested folders or really much organization at all. Also enables typing to launch apps. - Free high-power apps like iTunes and Photos means that people never even need to see the file system at all for that type of content. Instead they spend all their time in the dedicated free app.
- sparkie 11y agoI'm not very familiar with OSX so not sure if we mean the same thing - but how is the first of those an innovation in OSX?
- snowwrestler 11y agoIt's a UI innovation that is found in OS X, but Apple did not invent it. I meant my list to be more like: here are some big innovations in window-based GUI computing, which can be found in OS X. Not that these are all exclusive to OS X. People say nothing has changed in desktop GUIs but I remember the dark times before tabs and window managers. Constant dragging, resizing, and minimizing windows just to keep track of things. Same with desktop search--constant careful folder curation just to keep files from getting lost and forgotten.
- callil 11y agoI'm a designer on windows 10 and I wanted to comment on your last thought. Take it with a grain of salt but these types of ideas are what we are working on every day consistently attempting to improve or refine. The following are my own thoughts: I agree that the desktop interface is stagnating - but the WIMP methodology is still bar none for discoverability and learnability, and if you're a company making money from the enterprise market, you will always be torn between desiring and pushing innovation and maintaining consistency. However one thing I think we are doing now that is very interesting is attempting to reconcile the world of WIMP (desktop) with the FIM paradigm (finger icon menu - I made this up - ie mobile). Despite their similarities there is a HUGE challenge to meet the user's expectations when you are not fixed in one model. There are a few different points of view I see in the industry - one is that people will get better at the touch language and our interfaces will evolve to support complex touch interactions. And some who think that we have achieved the optimal method for efficient interaction and and the optimal method for mobile quick interaction and that the two worlds should be separate. And still others who believe the best interaction method is still out there (gestures, voice, pen, natural language, ai etc.) The view of windows 10 is that these two interaction paradigms or mental models support two semi formed methods of computing that are continually converging. The attempt is to create a UI that is adaptive to the users goal and should support: WIMP, FIM or a crossover between the two. The closest analogy is definitely responsive web design. There are huge drawbacks to this such as complexity, and current user expectations. But also huge benefits such as computing that is less tied to a device or input method, and lets you choose the best tool for your task at hand. I think it will be very interesting to see how the market reacts to this convergence, and if microsoft is able to communicate real user benefits from this type of experience. So far, it seems like simplicity is key. As a tech geek and designer, I'm excited for the next 5-10 years of interaction design. I think a lot will change with new tech (AR/VR + natural language + ai) and the continual evolution of our existing UIs. I don't expect many major shift within already established interaction paradigms, but shifts that will influence them from outside technology. edit: there are so many facets to this that I couldn't capture them all - but I wanted to comment on the card metaphor. To me it's a symptom of designers and devs looking for a metaphor that is able to cross between devices, screens and surfaces and escape the boundaries of the WIMP methodology. The fact that these types of metaphors are arising naturally in the world of software is a signal that the zerox/parc metaphor approach is still the best for mass market adoption. And seem to be the most well adopted to the environment we have created.