3 ms·
More to the point, if someone decides to reject that the chair is an object, that’s entirely fine, it’s just a semantic dispute, not a dispute about the underly
by jacobolus 11y ago
More to the point, if someone decides to reject that the chair is an object, that’s entirely fine, it’s just a semantic dispute, not a dispute about the underlying reality.
The individual atoms (or really, electrons and quarks) which make up the chair and the floor and the air around it don’t behave differently based on what object boundaries some person attaches in their mind.
Some of the atoms which the human considers to be “part of” the chair get left behind on the floor, while the bottoms of the chair legs pick some atoms up from the floor. Water molecules are constantly being traded between the chair surface and the air. And so on.
The object boundary is in some sense arbitrary and porous. The way we define it is based on our own practical use and experience, and the aggregated/emergent properties which are relevant to us, since we don’t have the means to simultaneously apprehend every individual particle in our surroundings.
- orasis 11y ago"The object boundary is in some sense arbitrary and porous." Yes. All objects are mind created, so indeed their boundaries are arbitrary.