5 ms·
The physics of floating screwdrivers [video]
- icegreentea 11y agoWhats super interesting to me is how this system becomes dynamically stable. In the pure thick shaft version, it looks like the jet is centered on about 1/4 of the way down the shaft - so it should be imparting torque on the whole thing, but the fluid dynamics are enough to keep it at what appears to be a pretty constant angle. Also, as a note about the golf ball comment (this seems to happen quite a lot), nothing he said was wrong, but there's slightly a bit more nuance going on. For a sphere (since we're talking golf balls) in a given flow, there will be a point along the ball will the flow will detach and form eddies and the mentioned low pressure zone behind the ball causing additional drag. By adding dimples, you introduce turbulence into the boundary flow that basically gives it enough momentum to keep up with the ball for longer, letting it stick the ball and therefore separate later - therefore lesser losses through that pressure drag. The reason why we don't dimple everything flying through the air is that adding turbulence to the boundary flow also increases the amount of drag on the object (so called skin friction drag). The act of adding dimples may either increase or decrease total net drag depending on the exact parameters of the object and the flow. It just happens that for golf balls flying through atmosphere, typical drive velocities are right in the range where adding dimples causes noticeable net reduction in drag.
- lisper 11y agoIt works for cars too: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eR5SlwNf4K0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eR5SlwNf4K0
- nerd_stuff 11y agoDiffusers do a similar (but different) thing while looking slightly cooler than dimples :) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diffuser_%28automotive%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diffuser_%28automotive%29
- iamcreasy 11y agoThen why the fuselage of an airplane is smooth?
- platz 11y agohttp://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/109395/why-arent-airplanes-like-golf-balls http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/109395/why-arent-...
- userbinator 11y agoIn the pure thick shaft version, it looks like the jet is centered on about 1/4 of the way down the shaft - so it should be imparting torque on the whole thing, but the fluid dynamics are enough to keep it at what appears to be a pretty constant angle. The angle is caused by the dynamic pressure of the jet; if you had a circumferential jet (like a Dyson fan), you could get it to float vertically.
- nsajko 11y agoImages in this article are very nice for visualizing types of drag: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drag_(physics) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drag_(physics)
- mjcohen 11y agoA question and a comment: 1. How much of the lift is caused just by the air pushing up? 2. The turbulence caused by a square back is (I think) why rear windows should be closed in a pickup - prevents the exhaust from coming in.
- Geee 11y agoThe largest forces here are gravity and the air directly hitting at the screwdriver. Other forces (Coanda effect) stabilize the screwdriver. Different air hose angles would send the screwdriver flying or let it drop.
- ams6110 11y agoTechnically, all of it? Lift is cause by higher pressure air pushing into a lower pressure area.
- raldi 11y agoTo rephrase the question, how much of the lift is generated by high-pressure air below the screwdriver, and how much is generated by low-pressure air above?
- userbinator 11y agoPressure is relative, and it is this pressure difference that causes the lifting force. So what is "high pressure" relative to the top of the screwdriver is "low pressure" relative to the bottom of it (and the atmosphere.)
- raldi 11y agoRelative to 1 atm.
- userbinator 11y agoThen there is no high pressure at the bottom, only low pressure at the top.
- joering2 11y agoVery interesting, consider how heavy that screwdriver is. What would be a ratio of a cost of electricty (to blow an air) to the weight of an object it can raise? Could this be used as initial propeler to raise a rocket high enough to use this technique as a "first stage engine" in flying object out into space?
- josai 11y ago> Could this be used as initial propeler to raise a rocket high enough to use this technique as a "first stage engine" in flying object out into space? I don't really see how. You'd need some kind of gigantic and fairly stable platform to shoot the jet from - if you have that, it would be easier to just launch the rocket from that. And you're forgetting the fact that we seldom just launch stuff "into space" - we want it in orbit. Only about 20% of the delta-v budget of a typical launch to orbit is the "vertical" component, the large majority is spent on attaining angular ("sideways") velocity. So you'd be doing an awful lot of work just to cut down that 20% by, say, a quarter - it's simply not worth it.