3 ms·
The sequels don't undermine the original story, they expand on it. A lot of people think Dune is a straightforward hero story, with Paul Atreides the "good" he
by snowwrestler 11y ago
The sequels don't undermine the original story, they expand on it.
A lot of people think Dune is a straightforward hero story, with Paul Atreides the "good" hero, but actually (edit: I should say, according to Herbert and taking into account the later novels) it is the story of the terrible damage a "hero" can cause to a culture and society.
"No more terrible disaster could befall your people than for them to fall into the hands of a Hero." - Frank Herbert
This is similar to Cryptonomicom, which people think is the story of Avi and Randy's success, but is really the story of their misguided quest which is doomed to fail.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoWhat an author intends and what readers take from it are two different things. Definitely an interesting quote, though; I like that.
- spdionis 11y agoAgreed. My interpretation is that Paul actually failed completely as a hero.
- Swannie 11y agoI read the books 15 years ago (IIRC, the first 4 or 5), and need to revisit. But my enduring memory was of a flawed young man becoming overly enamoured with his new messianic role, and making some choices that were questionable.
- spdionis 11y agoIt's not really like that. In the end the choices he made supposedly happened because he saw the future that this was the best way for humanity to survive.