4 ms·
Unfortunately that's clearly sophistry. The money is being spent involuntarily, for benefits the recipients has no control over, with little or no market levera
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
Unfortunately that's clearly sophistry. The money is being spent involuntarily, for benefits the recipients has no control over, with little or no market leverage, priced in ways that aren't genuinely open to competition.
It shouldn't take much thought to realise that's exactly how taxation works.
So effectively that argument simply treats benefits that would be funded from taxation in more rationally managed countries as somehow magically equivalent to private income.
Clearly, that's not even good sophistry - although it's about par for the course for a modern orthodox economic argument, so I suppose no one is going to be surprised by the low quality.
- refurb 11y agoThose benefits aren't funded from taxation, they are funded by your employer. And they most certainly count as compensation. If your employer promised you a full pension, wouldn't you consider that a part of compensation?
- nmrm2 11y agoParent's argument was that it's disingenuous to count e.g. health insurance as part of compensation when it's required by the State. That's not private compensation, it's a tax on corporations. Post-ACA, a company calling health insurance part of your compensation package is like them calling payroll tax part of your compensation. Which almost no one does historically, because that's stupid. It's not reasonable to argue that "real compensation" has increased between year X and year Y by counting tax burdens in year Y but not in year X. The reason that such a comparison is stupid and wrong should be obvious. It's slightly more reasonable to argue that additional taxes have eaten up projected wage increases. (But that argument is wrong.) > If your employer promised you a full pension, wouldn't you consider that a part of compensation? The difference here is that the Government more or less never requires a private company to provide a full pension.
- JesperRavn 11y agoSo if the government taxed each corporation $1000 per employee, then gave you that $1000 back at the end of the year, that would mean your wages were less by $1000 a year? it's not reasonable to argue that "real compensation" has increased between year X and year Y by counting tax burdens in year Y but not in year X. It is when the government introduces new "taxes" in year Y, which would have been equivalent to salary in year X.
- nmrm2 11y ago> It is when the government introduces new "taxes" in year Y, which would have been equivalent to salary in year X. This is a different argument and I've already addressed it in my post above: It's slightly more reasonable to argue that additional taxes have eaten up projected wage increases. (But that argument is wrong.) Again, the argument you are making is that taxes offset increases in income that would have increased otherwise, NOT that income has actually increased. But, as I stated above, this argument is clearly and obviously wrong -- a conclusion that is unambiguously supported by the data. Tax increases cannot explain a multi-decade stagnation in income, ESPECIALLY because NET corporate taxes have net decreased in that period of time [1]. (As a complete aside, when every corporate tax break is passed on to either the customer or the employee, I'll be ready to entertain even the criteria I established above. But while companies pocket the difference and perform stock buy backs [2], economists who argue tax increases count as increases in income are being disingenuous (edit: changed wording). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_tax_in_the_United_States#/media/File:US_Effective_Corporate_Tax_Rate_1947-2011_v2.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_tax_in_the_United_St... [2] Clinton mentioned that H.W. Bush warned him not to provide a no-strings-attached tax holiday for this exact reason; see his latest interview on the Daily Show.
- JesperRavn 11y agoPlease be civil, I'm not going to "fuck off" just because you argue in an aggressive manner. All your verbal arguments are obfuscation. This is simple arithmetic. What we would like to measure is the total post-tax and post-govt spending utility of a person: total utility = post-tax compensation + govt spending per person. That is what should be going up. But it's hard to measure all these things, so instead we can try to measure total compensation. When you redefine health care to be a tax, you are moving health care from the "post-tax compensation" category, to the "govt spending per person" category. Then you are arguing that post-tax compensation is going down, but that is just because of your accounting choice. Your logic would only apply if the government was initially providing free healthcare, and then moved to a regime where healthcare was provided by employers, which is not what happened. The problem with your reasoning is that it deals with everything except economic fundamentals, i.e. total consumption per person.
- refurb 11y agoThat still makes no sense. The ACA only requires certain sized employers to either pay for your insurance or give you the cash to buy your own. If your employer is paying $6K per year, that is additional compensation beyond the $2K per year minimal plan the have to pay for.
- SilasX 11y ago>, with little or no market leverage, priced in ways that aren't genuinely open to competition. Exactly. It's not very reassuring to tell me my total compensation includes $8000 "worth" of insurance that turns out to cover very little in the event of a catastrophe.