3 ms·
This has the same flaw that all utilitarian arguments do: imperfect knowledge of future consequences. Specifically, by driving distasteful expression undergrou
by CamperBob2 11y ago
This has the same flaw that all utilitarian arguments do: imperfect knowledge of future consequences.
Specifically, by driving distasteful expression underground, you may find that you've hidden it just well enough to allow it to grow unchallenged.
The antidote to bad speech -- the only antidote -- is more speech.
- astrobe_ 11y agoIn turn, the flaw in your argument is that you let the poison spread. You take the risk that it can spread unchallenged, or insufficiently challenged. Speech - communication - is not that much different from physical force. Some people can speak louder than others, some people speak better than others. Some people own powerful media groups and some people are trained in manipulative speech: sophists yesterday, spin doctors today. Those people are "stronger", but of course not necessarily more "right". Still, they can win. Both philosophies have their pros and cons.
- CamperBob2 11y agoSpeech - communication - is not that much different from physical force Spoken by someone who has clearly never been in a fight.