6 ms·
Cities in NC did this[1]. TWC didn't like it, so they bought the state legislature and had it made illegal[2]. The FCC is trying to pull rank on NC, but NC is f
by js2 11y ago
Cities in NC did this[1]. TWC didn't like it, so they bought the state legislature and had it made illegal[2]. The FCC is trying to pull rank on NC, but NC is fighting back[3].
1. http://www.greenlightnc.com/ http://www.greenlightnc.com/
2. http://www.wired.com/2011/05/nc-gov-anti-muni-broadband/ http://www.wired.com/2011/05/nc-gov-anti-muni-broadband/
3. http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/05/north-carolina-sues-fcc-for-right-to-block-municipal-broadband/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/05/north-carolina-su...
- ams6110 11y agoWell TWC had their original monopoly granted by the government, so pretty natural they would look there to defend it. I don't defend big ISP monopolies. But my concern with municipal broadband is that municipalities generally do a bad job running what should be private sector services. They end up being used for patronage jobs and other political shenanigans among other things. Plus your average elected city councilman doesn't know the first thing about the technical or financial realities of running an ISP. It's more like "hey we can pass a tax levy and take some money from each citizen to build a Cadillac internet service with no concern for profit or cost." It's thinking like this that had my town buying acres of land for a "tech park" that has sat undeveloped for years, and working plans for a waste materials separation facility that no private waste hauler will build because it's a guaranteed money-loser. I wish I had more choice in ISPs. But I don't think my neighbor should be forced to pay for my internet service.
- HarryHirsch 11y agoOn the other hand, municipalities generally run water and sewage services without complaints; incompetence and corruption in that department are so rare that they are news. You can privatize bus or trash service and hand the concession to someone else should the incumbent be too awful at their job, but things like water, sewage and data are natural monopolies, and for these different rules apply. The sad thing is that we know how regulated utilities ought to be run, but we choose not to. Hence Comcast and the Enron-sponsored electricity shenanigans in CA.
- bennylope 11y ago> municipalities generally run water and sewage services without complaints I'd largely agree with this from my own experience. The caveat here in comparing water & sewage to internet service is that water and sewage service - at least what we experience as end users - hasn't changed much over the years. Municipal governments are good at managing that type of service. I'm happy with the same water and sewage service that I had 15 years ago. Not sure I'd like the same Internet service. And I'm not so sure I'd trust my city to keep such a service up to date.
- michaelt 11y agoI'm not so sure I'd trust my city to keep such a service up to date. If the private sector is doing a great job at keeping your internet connection up to date, I'm glad for you! Unfortunately some Americans don't seem very happy with the level of service the market is providing [1] - IMHO if people are attending meetings and voting in favour of municipal broadband, it indicates the private sector isn't doing a very good job of keeping services up to date either! [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/2ei1qj/after_an_internship_at_comcast/ https://www.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/2ei1qj/after_an_inter...
- baddox 11y agoIndeed, imagine if municipalities had needed to increase their sewage "bandwidth" per customer tenfold over the last decade.
- HarryHirsch 11y agoThere was a fairly heady construction boom in the last decade, let me remind you of that. That said, everyone seems to have a beef with Comcast, while the complaints about the Vermont muni ISPs and the only muni ISP in North Carolina (http://www.greenlightnc.com/ http://www.greenlightnc.com/) are muted.
- kalleboo 11y agoMunicipalities everywhere have had to deal with increased water usage and yes, sewage. I was just reading a news article from my former hometown about the original choices and changes of water sources and the build-up and upgrading of water towers as the town grew. Back in the early 1900's, water infrastructure WAS high-tech.
- asmithmd1 11y agoMassachusetts has a long history of municipal power companies; along with schools, fire, police, water and sewer 41 towns also own and run the electric grid. Their association claims 24% lower distribution costs then investor owned utilities. Here is a map of who supplies power in each Massachusetts town: http://images.masscec.com/uploads/attachments/ElectricUtilityMap.pdf http://images.masscec.com/uploads/attachments/ElectricUtilit... Massachusetts has a real problem with patronage jobs, but it is at the state level, not local.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- GFK_of_xmaspast 11y agoI'm ok with my neighbor paying for my internet service, as long as I pay for the neighbor on the other side, and so on.
- lotharbot 11y agoSeveral cities in northern Utah did it as well [0]. I'm not aware of any legal issues they've had; the main issues they've had have been financial issues and rollout delays. With each new community that succeeds, that's one more example we can point to in our own communities. [0] http://www.utopianet.org/faq/ http://www.utopianet.org/faq/
- nitrogen 11y agoAt one point the local DSL and cable monopolies used lawsuits to prevent federal funding from being distributed to UTOPIA, which contributed to the financial issues, IIRC.
- taway292621672 11y agoArsTechnica: > broadband service in Wilson County, but is unable to expand its broadband network due to the state law This gives the impression Greenlight covers most of the city. It's never been true: Time-Warner of Wilson doesn't even suffer real competition. Here's a map: https://www.google.com/maps/place/Wilson,+NC/@35.7378769,-77.9345956,13z/data=!4m2!3m1!1s0x89ac26f39c8c910d:0x43df22c9c9c44d21 https://www.google.com/maps/place/Wilson,+NC/@35.7378769,-77... I'm not aware of any place at all on Nash, Ward, 264, Airport, or Forest Hills with Greenlight. If you know someone who has it, I'd love to know where. "Wilson's muni broadband success story" is a fairy tale kept alive by credulous reporting.