5 ms·
The $80 million in fiber only lasts 1 year? Laying water pipes is expensive.. but water pipes are good for what, 80 years? The cost spread out through bonds o
by brianwawok 11y ago
The $80 million in fiber only lasts 1 year?
Laying water pipes is expensive.. but water pipes are good for what, 80 years? The cost spread out through bonds over a long period is not that bad.
The trick is how long is gigabit "good" internet for? In 2001, they could have built a 1mbit connection to every house and been seen as pretty awesome, but now, 15 years later, it would be pretty worthless.
Though I am not a fiber expert, I think there may be ways to future proof it so current 1gbit fiber could be 10gbit or 100gbit down the road with better back office equipment..
- bluedino 11y agoThe fiber would hold up, it's the equipment that would need upgraded. Since 2001 the cable lines coming into my house have went from 3mb to 100mb on the same lines
- ObviousScience 11y ago$80 million for 20,000 households is about $4,000 per household. Let's call it $10,000 per household like the other guy, assuming most people won't be interested. Let's estimate that about $60 million of the cost is the actual build out of fiber, and $20 million is other expenses. If we're going to upgrade our backend equipment every 3 years over a 20 year life span on the fiber, we're talking about another $100 million on top of our $80 million investment. So we could have constantly upgrading backroom fiber laid down on a 20 year infrastructure cycle for $180 million, or about $22,500 per household (over 20 years). So the cost per household to lay down fiber, even if only 40% of the households are paying, is about $100/mo per household for 20 years. Given that we need to pay bond interest rates and cut some money in for the company managing your ISP account on the fiber, we're talking more like $130/mo, maybe $150/mo. So in short, if $130/mo-$150/mo for 1gig internet with open ISP competition instead of getting dicked by Comcast all the time sounds good, talk to your local government.
- rayiner 11y ago40% is an incredibly high uptake ratio. Google is not hitting that in Kansas City with gigabit at $70. And the higher the price, the lower the uptake. At $130 to $150 per month, uptake will be a lot less than 40%.
- ObviousScience 11y agoThe water and electric grids in my city have near 100% uptake, especially in the denser parts of the city. While in most cases I would agree with the uptake analysis (eg, if we were talking about coffee shops), I'm not sure that it applies to the particular case of talking about rolling out a government monopoly in place of a natural monopoly using city bonds to cover the upfront cost (and time to smother people not using the city network). Further, I was actually just interested in plausibility: I didn't account for growth rates, the attractiveness of a city wide network, competition between ISPs, etc. That the answer was ~100 and not ~10 or ~1,000 is interesting to me, because it means that even if the technology isn't there, that the details work out a lot closer than I was expecting -- expensive, but not impossible. tl;dr: Deciding if we should roll out government infrastructure isn't quite the same analysis as seeing if a business works, and I only did the latter as a proxy for plausibility.
- ensignavenger 11y agoDo you have any data on this? Does that include their $300 installation for 10 years of service?
- fiberrun 11y agoReplacing all equipment every three years is way too aggressive. No network operator spends $1000 per subscriber for new equipment every three years. A more realistic and conservative replacement schedule would be seven years.
- sre_ops 11y agoOh, so transit is free?
- Retric 11y agoIn 2001 top fiber networks where generally 100+MB which is still considered good after 15years.
- chockablock 11y agoEven 1mb symmetric would still be considered good in many rural areas. As the article notes, many of these folks are still on dialup.
- CyberDildonics 11y agoYou are right about the bonds, in fact it should end up being very profitable. If fiber is run through people's neighborhoods, 1gb is not any sort of hard limit, it is just a nice round number that coincides with 1gb ethernet being a limit of most people's equipment. Even now DOCSIS 3.0 can give people 300mb connections over cable, so cable has advanced an enormous amount. Just like an ethernet cable has scaled up from 10mb to 1000mb fiber can carry more. You could wire your home up with a 40gb network right now if you wanted to pay for the $400 network cards and more expensive routers.
- solotronics 11y agoTime Warner Cable residential is in the process of upgrading to 300mb and DOCSIS 3.1 is capable of 1gig/s download. Fiber has huge advantages over any kind of copper because there is no RF interference involved. Initially Verizon had higher costs per service call vs cable, but I heard that they are on parity or lower now.
- mdaniel 11y agoIn my mental model, it's laying the conduit that is expensive (but the collective clearly has an edge over a traditional vendor because they presumably don't have to get permits from the towns), followed by the cost of the actual fiber and/or equipment. But hopefully once that conduit is in place, if Super Awesome Fiber 2.0 comes along, they are one small remote controlled fiber-pulling device away from stringing the updated medium through said conduit. I am purposefully not even addressing the multiplicative power of multi-modal fiber connections, or any such in-medium improvements.
- amalag 11y agoWhen ISPs get federal money to lay fiber they will never lay conduit because then they would not get money again when "Super Awesome Fiber 2.0" comes around.
- fiberrun 11y agoInstalling conduit and pulling the fiber is about three times more expensive than just doing direct burial fiber. In rural areas it can be more cost effective to just do direct burial fiber. Fiber strands are also quite cheap. It is often faster, cheaper and easier to direct bury a fiber cable with "enough" fiber strands to cater for current and any forseeable demand than to install a condiit system in rural areas. Furthermore it is quite rare to replace the fiber in a last mile network. I can't recall a single instance since single mode fiber was introduced. It just isn't cost effective. It's much easier, cheaper and faster to just change the electronics/optics. Even adding more fiber strands by means of a new cable is rare. Again it just isn't cost effective. It's much easier, cheaper and faster to just change the electronics/optics. Even so, in rural areas it is just cheaper to plow down another cable than to build a conduit network. In summary, a conduit system is more expensive to install, repair and maintain than a direct burial network. Aerial systems are generally even cheaper, but have their own downsides. A direct burial network might not be as flexible and easily upgradeable as a conduit system, but sometimes this does not matter, especially if you are on a fixed budget.
- DannyBee 11y ago
- rayiner 11y agoI cited market cap, not yearly revenue. Market cap per customer is a good estimate of the value of each customers subscription projected indefinitely forward into the future.