5 ms·
How so? If you're white, perhaps you see no problem with making everyone's skin white. But the billions of people who aren't white might have a problem with it
by TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago
How so? If you're white, perhaps you see no problem with making everyone's skin white.
But the billions of people who aren't white might have a problem with it.
- sp332 11y agoThe color was not specified before, so it was up to the font creator. I think yellow was the most common choice. The test page shows all the icons as blue in my browser. I'm not against the new changes, but I think the old version was more popular in Asian countries than anywhere else, and wasn't really pro-white.
- kuschku 11y agoWell, Apple made them mostly white. White people holding hands, white people praying, a white family. Google and Microsoft’s neutral yellow was a lot more neutral there, yes.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago> The color was not specified before, so it was up to the font creator. I think yellow was the most common choice. Nope. Usually white (Apple, Japanese phones).
- sp332 11y agoThanks for the info. Still, it's hard to believe that Japanese phones would put Caucasian people all over their emoji. Related: "Why Do the Japanese Draw Themselves as White?" https://abagond.wordpress.com/2010/06/16/why-do-the-japanese-draw-themselves-as-white/ https://abagond.wordpress.com/2010/06/16/why-do-the-japanese...
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoThey're not white in the sense of "European". They just have a light skin colour. Japanese skin isn't bright yellow. A Japanese person draws a simple human face, an American draws a simple human face, both will draw "white" skin.
- sp332 11y agoWay back up in this comment: How so? If you're white, perhaps you see no problem with making everyone's skin white. But the billions of people who aren't white might have a problem with it. I really thought you meant Caucasian. Did you just mean light-skinned?
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago> I really thought you meant Caucasian. Did you just mean light-skinned? It would have been better if I said "light-skinned", yes. While East Asians are not "white" in the "racial" sense (ew), their skin is light much like Europeans', and thus when the Japanese created the emoji, they made them have light skin. Sorry for the confusion.
- realusername 11y agoEmojis are used for communicating emotion, not skin color. If the user want them to be displayed black (or even replace them with cat and dog faces) it should be up to them, it's just a user preference.
- chimeracoder 11y ago> How so? If you're white, perhaps you see no problem with making everyone's skin white. > But the billions of people who aren't white might have a problem with it. I'm not white, and I have a problem with "skin tone" emoji. Previously, skin tones for emoji were left up to the font creator. In practice, this meant that they were usually lime green, neon blue, or Simpsons yellow, all of which are cartoonish enough not to be evocative of any particular real-life skintone. I can't really imagine a situation in which drawing attention to the race of an emoji character is desirable or even acceptable. I'm sure some exist, but they're nowhere near important enough to be included in the actual standard itself. Beyond that, the skin tones used are incredibly reductive. Human skin tones are not as simple as 6 different shades of brown. (I, for one, cannot match my skin tone to any of the examples on the Unicode website). And if we want to get philosophical, there are a number of ways in which race and culture are encoded (literally) into emoji that are far more subtle, yet more significant, than the color used to render the skin of the faces. In a way, it reminds me of the picture-interpretation tests that they used to administer at Ellis Island to "prove" that certain immigrants were not "fit" for life in the US, though that's perhaps a topic for another day.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Previously, skin tones for emoji were left up to the font creator. In practice, this meant that they were usually lime green, neon blue, or Simpsons yellow, all of which are cartoonish enough not to be evocative of any particular real-life skintone. That's not true, IME -- in several of the popular emoji fonts I've seen that don't incorporate specific "skin tone emoji", most emoji for people that aren't expressly silhouettes are white, except a very small number which are black (in both cases, within the range of flesh tones usually associated with those as races, not cartoonish colors.) EDIT: This is not true of "smiley face" emoji, but of other emoji representing humans or human body parts.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago> Beyond that, the skin tones used are incredibly reductive. Human skin tones are not as simple as 6 different shades of brown. Yes, they are a bit more complicated. But 6 choices that correspond to a widely-used system (Fitzpatrick) is far better than none.
- Grue3 11y agoBillions of people who aren't white were using and invented emoji before white people even got to them.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago> Billions of people who aren't white were using and invented emoji before white people even got to them. There are not billions of Japanese people and their skin tone is light (though they're not European).
- wongarsu 11y agoI have never thought of emoji as having any particular skin colour, until this recent trend to make skin colour selectable. Emoticons and emoji have traditionally been displayed as yellow cirlces with large faces. White emojis have been the exception, not the rule. I have never had a problem with being represented by a character with Jaundice (a medical condition turning your skin yellow).
- codygman 11y ago> I have never thought of emoji as having any particular skin colour, until this recent trend to make skin colour selectable. If your skin color is already represented you have the privilege of not having to worry about inclusivity of others being represented. However, I'm not sure this applies to you since I'm not sure what race you are.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago> White emojis have been the exception, not the rule. Not at all true. Most emoji implementations (Japanese mobile providers, Apple) used white faces.