7 ms·
The problem is all in this fragment: "as a vendor of dominant mobile operating system". We all know Apple makes more money than any other mobile manufacturer, a
by toyg 11y ago
The problem is all in this fragment: "as a vendor of dominant mobile operating system". We all know Apple makes more money than any other mobile manufacturer, and we all know they are culturally dominant, but in terms of actual market penetration, they own 20% of the global market. Samsung gets 27%, just to mention one competitor.
This makes it extremely hard to get any sort of antitrust leverage against Apple. We can keep screaming at them until we're blue in the face and nothing will change.
- blinkingled 11y agoThis market share/mind share / profit share rhetoric changes nothing for the sizeable portion of Apple's iOS users. Last I checked there are half a billion of them - they have no choice but to use Safari.
- ryandvm 11y agoWell, for one thing, they can stop buying products from a company that is openly hostile to consumer choice...
- biftek 11y agoIt's as if the people buying Apple products actually like Apple's choice…
- blinkingled 11y agoI guess the same can be said about all the people buying Windows devices in the 90s. Everything is absolute, 1:1 after all - you buy something and you must like everything about it 100%!
- oksawe 11y agoExactly. Occasionally I'll give Chrome, Firefox, among others a try, but I keep coming back to Safari. I hate the way the other browsers look, especially Chrome, and Safari is super quick while being easy on the battery.
- ashark 11y agoIts being the only major browser that respects battery life is pretty much the only reason I use Safari. It hurts to see that "time remaining" indicator drop by 2 hours just because I have Chrome open. I really miss Chrome's multi-profile support, but it's just so much heavier. Last time I used Firefox (admittedly ~3 years ago) it was even worse. System-wide beachballs. Much worse than having Eclipse open. That's what got me to switch to Chrome for a time, after being a FF user since the Phoenix/Firebird days.
- toyg 11y ago> Safari is super quick while being easy on the battery. That's not surprising, considering it's the only product not forced to use the public web view object in iOS. It's like Microsoft Office, which has always used private MS apis that other products running on Windows were not allowed/supposed to.
- realityking 11y agoI believe they're talking about Desktop Safari, there's yet no Firefox for iOS to test.
- t0mas88 11y agoThat's because Apple actively provides Safari with advantages with regards to API access and performance. They royally screw over the other browser vendors.
- panic 11y agoSafari's engine, WebKit, is open source. There are no secret advantages. Other browsers are free to read WebKit's code and copy its techniques.
- TheDong 11y agoNot true. Apple also owns the app store and the default configuration of the OS is moving towards only allowing app store software (has it already finished that transition)? They can and will reject anyone who uses private apis that they themselves use. In addition, because they own the OS they can require that a private API is only accessed by software signed by them. It also could cause firefox to break on OS updates and would require firefox to keep abrest of those changes. Here's a couple references: Apple does use private APIs: http://www.wired.com/2008/02/firefox_developer_uncovers_apple_s_private__undocumented_frameworks/ http://www.wired.com/2008/02/firefox_developer_uncovers_appl... Apple rejected firefox from the app store at some point for using private apis: https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=636841 https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=636841
- dylanjermiah 11y agoI use Chrome on my Mac and my iPhone. An I missing something here?
- wodenokoto 11y agoI completely agree with you. But I would like to add that Apple holds most of the important users - those who are the most willing to spend time and money online.
- toyg 11y agoYeah, you could try to paint them as dominant in a specific market segment (rich people, whatever), but it would be very difficult. We're very far from the numbers Microsoft still has on the desktop, and a world apart from the 90%+ they had back in the Netscape-suit days.
- melling 11y ago9 out of 10 desktop computers still run Windows. 12% of those still run XP. There's still no 3rd option on the desktop; Linux has failed. So, rather than fix a real problem, people start complaining about something a lot smaller: "18% of the world's phones run in a walled garden with a relatively modern browser."
- microcolonel 11y agoWhile Windows XP can run Firefox ESR, iOS of any version only runs whatever it had at last OS push. Also, Linux works fine for plenty of people, sure miniscule in proportion, but it hasn't failed.
- melling 11y agoLinux has always been fine for a minuscule proportion. It has failed to be a viable 3rd option on the desktop for 98% of the population.
- microcolonel 11y agoWho cares?
- skc 11y agoThe "Apple is not dominant" retort is very correct but also very frustrating. Apple is dominant in the sense that they command an outsize portion of developer/consumer mindshare. So issues like this just get drowned out in all the fawning.
- madeofpalk 11y agoUnfortunately Judges wouldn't agree that 'iPhone users' are their own market and agree that Apple has a massive market share which their abusing.
- mseebach 11y agoBecause if they did, "Tide users" and "Ford owners" would be their own markets too which would mean that all brands would be monopolists by default. You don't get to throw anti-trust at Apple because you can't be bothered to switch to a different type of smartphone, just like you can't throw anti-trust at Ford because you don't want to drive a Chevy. The notion is absurd.
- wolfgke 11y ago> Because if they did, "Tide users" and "Ford owners" would be their own markets too which would mean that all brands would be monopolists by default. Which could (in a formal logic, not juristic logic, sense) lead to an argument why anybody should be allowed to install any software they want on their devices - a demand that I, as a hacker, fully support.
- venomsnake 11y agoI can change anything on my ford as long as the resulting vehicle is road legal.
- randomdata 11y agoWhat does Ford do differently with respect to software on their, say, entertainment system or ECU computers that Apple doesn't do with their iOS devices to allow you to draw this distinction?
- mineshaftgap 11y ago>we all know they are culturally dominant And the reason they are is because they put user experience before developers or dogma.
- higherpurpose 11y ago> We can keep screaming at them until we're blue in the face and nothing will change. Well, unless you're Taylor Swift. Then Apple will do what you ask within 24h. I know there's no Taylor Swift of the iOS software ecosystem, but I think that's attitude is defeatist. If more people complained about a lack of real browser choice on iOS, including developers and users, Apple would eventually have to cave. Oh, and I don't think Apple had more than 20% of the U.S. ebook market, yet DoJ still sued them for price fixing - and Apple lost. So if we can find the will (political or otherwise), I think we can get Apple to allow other browsers. In the U.S., where this case would be tried anyway, Apple has over 40% market share.
- 2muchcoffeeman 11y agoI don't think the price fixing had anything to do with market share. The publishers wanted bigger profits and Apple wanted a larger market share of eBooks. If anything they were attempting to break a monopoly.
- toyg 11y agoDoJ sued Apple and a cartel of publishers which dominated the market: "The Publisher Defendants sold over 48% of all e-books in the U.S.". Big difference. Apple was central to the conspiracy to fix prices, but the main charge was really against the publishers.
- bjelkeman-again 11y agoIsn't Apple paying the fines? Did I miss that the publishers have to poney up too?
- toyg 11y agoThey settled.
- Bud 11y ago> If more people complained about a lack of real browser choice on iOS, including developers and users, Apple would eventually have to cave. Nope. Don't you remember just a few years ago, when everyone was screaming at Apple for years to put Flash on its mobile devices? Apple never caved. Apple doubled down, because Apple was smart enough to figure out that Flash was a battery-sucking, security-ruining disaster. Gee, kinda like allowing third parties to control the web browser on a mobile device would be. Fancy that!
- kethinov 11y agoThe fact that there's no legal remedy only highlights the inadequacy of the laws on the books. Simple solution: require all OS vendors to permit opt-in, off-by-default sideloading. Curate your app store all you want, but don't prevent your users from running whatever software they want on their own computers. That would solve this.
- TD-Linux 11y agoThis is basically the anti-tivoization clause of the GPLv3. Look at how much fuss was caused by that.
- AlphaSite 11y agoEven Apple is allowing side loading from iOS9 iirc.
- kethinov 11y agoVia Xcode and only if you have the source code. Doesn't quite work for people trying to distribute apps that aren't allowed in the app store.
- AlphaSite 11y agoI dont imagine it will take someone long to work around that, they already gave you the tools in the form of bitcode.
- kethinov 11y agoThat's all well and good, but Google can't exactly ask all their users to download Xcode and deploy some workaround to get a prebuilt Chrome binary bundled with Blink on their iPhone. Jailbreaking it and installing it via Cydia would be easier.
- ianamartin 11y agoYes. Destroying your platform's security model is exactly what we need governments to do.