3 ms·
Maybe this is a stupid question, but I'm not sure I see how that relates to the departure of a Reddit employee facilitating that AMA. He answered the question,
by geofft 11y ago
Maybe this is a stupid question, but I'm not sure I see how that relates to the departure of a Reddit employee facilitating that AMA. He answered the question, right? Whether the answer is terrible maybe impacts what you think of him, but not what you think of the person making the AMA happen (either as a person or as an employee), right?
Or did he not actually answer the question, and did someone else answer in his place? Or is there more going on, like he regretted that answer?
- ForEnglandJames 11y agoLet me explain this in simple terms so everyone here can understand what's going on 1) Pao is still intent on shaking down the silicon valley establishment. She's made that very clear by here refusal to settle with KP, even after the embarrassing loss in the original case. Probably to bail out Ole Buddy, her hubby. 2) Jesse Jackson has decided to go where the real money is and start shaking down silicon valley for donations to his rainbow putsch coalition 3) Pao and Jackson are now aligned in intent--both want the moral high ground in their scheme to extort money from silicon valley using whatever weird false narrative of priviledge they can create 4) Pao invites the Right Reverend to do an AMA, likely coordinated by Victoria in order to start the press game for his campaign 5) Reddit users hurl abuse (rightfully so) at the Right Grifter Jackson over his continued race-baiting and hypocrisy (having an affair while 'counselling' president Clinton over his affair? Jesus Christ!) 6) Jackson gets pissed because he can't control the message. His people likely say something to Chairman Pao's people. 7) Pao realizes she done goofed and potentially lost a valuable ally in her extortion scheme. 8) Pao uses Victoria as a scapegoat to try to save face and fires her on the spot. Now, all of this is rumor, but c'mon, you know it's what happened. It's common sense.
- jammi 11y agoHe probably refretted the answer, because it's like he didn't even read the question before answering with some boilerplate answer, which is probably why the question got rated so high after the answer. I do. But I was jailed in 1960. For trying to use a public library. And that caused more good than harm. I marched to end segregation. The day Dr. King spoke on Washington, in 1963, I was there for that speech. That day, from Texas to Florida, you couldn't use a single public toilet. We could not buy ice cream at Howard Johnson's, or stay in Holiday Inns. We fought to bring those barriers down. And because those walls are down, all the new interstate construction across the South - the new bridges and ports, and seaports - that's progress. You couldn't have teams behind the Cotton Curtain. You couldn't have had Olympics in Atlanta behind the Cotton Curtain. You couldn't have Toyota, and Michelin, behind the Cotton Curtain, so we pulled those walls down. So our work has been beneficial. And it seems to me that people who benefit from that work ascribe it to the wrong reasons. When the laws change to make the South more civil, that brought in more investment. So we've made America better. All these changes have come from our work. Our work has bene good for the South, and good for America. My goal is to expand our consciousness, to create as big a tent as possible, as we fight for justice and world peace. I was able to bring Americans home from jail, from prison, and gaining those freedom of those Americans was the highest and best use of my talents and time.
- geofft 11y agoThat's a different answer from the one the parent comment is mentioning.
- chernevik 11y agoIt is a demonstration that the Reverend doesn't much care about fairness to individuals, and so would not feel qualms about insisting someone be fired because he was embarrassed.
- geofft 11y agoOK, and why would Reddit go along with that? IAmA was one of the most monetizable parts of Reddit, and it needed a full-time staff member to work. The site was already vaguely unhappy with the admins (though maybe those folks were leaving). Jesse Jackson's personal support doesn't mean much to Reddit, I'm pretty sure. Even if it made sense for him to want Victoria fired, which I'm not sure it does, and even if nobody at Reddit felt qualms about firing their coworker, it still makes no business sense why this was the right move for Reddit. Quoting the International Business Times: "The AMA in question, which took place just two days before Taylor's firing was revealed, was widely regarded to be nothing short of a disaster. When the top question on the AMA calls the person answering questions 'an immoral, hate-filled race baiter that has figured out how to manipulate the political system for your own gain', you know you are in trouble. [...] However the suggestion that this was the reason for Taylor's firing does seem tenuous at best, and outright ridiculous in reality." There are some more plausible reasons in that story. http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/reddit-revolt-why-was-popular-director-victoria-taylor-fired-1509234 http://www.ibtimes.co.uk/reddit-revolt-why-was-popular-direc...
- chernevik 11y ago"[T]he suggestion that this was the reason for Taylor's firing does seem tenuous at best, and outright ridiculous in reality." That is an assertion, and one without any argument or evidence. The other two theories mentioned by the article (anti-relocation, anti-commercialization) aren't consistent with such an abrupt and poorly handled firing. Now why would Reddit fire Victoria over the AMA? There are many _possible_ reasons. Here are some speculations. One, no company wants to be the target of Reverend Jackson or his supporters complaining that they treated him in a disrespectful or racist fashion. Look at how some of the various tech diversity controversies have played out, and how quickly. Reddit may well have worried that _not_ firing Victoria could have put them in a "Reddit is racist" cross-hairs that could quickly have spun out of control. Especially given how much of exactly that sort of material is floating around on various subreddits. Given how those controversies can roll, reasoning like this may even have been in some sense correct. Lose the whole company in a Twitter storm? Or fire a popular employee and irritate a bunch of mods? Two, CEO Pao is on record talking about the importance of diversity at Reddit. It may very well be that she felt the AMA was cross-wise her own values, and those she wants to promote at Reddit. Three, CEO Pao may also regard the Reverend and his supporters as important allies for purposes of her own, apart from her role as Reddit's CEO. She's certainly out there as interested in diversity issues, and admired by many for that. It isn't hard to imagine that she would be concerned about that image. Four, others at Reddit may have felt the AMA didn't represent their values. Silicon Valley is notoriously progressive, and when dealing with political questions people often don't think straight. The conflict between "AMAs can be rough" and "Reverend Jackson deserves more respect than that" creates cognitive dissonance. That makes decision-making very hard. Add in some pressure from Jackson or his people -- whom many in Silicon Valley _want_ to perceive as reasonable and intelligent folks, and exposed to a lot of unreasonable criticism -- and good choices start to get difficult. We don't _know_ anything, of course. The basic point is, the Jackson AMA created a _political_ situation for Reddit. Political decision-making is already hard, and the thinking about it easily confused. Reddit may have made a political choice driven by business concerns. Or it may have made political choices based on its employees personal agendas or outlooks. Or, the timing of the firing and the AMA were completely coincidental.
- geofft 11y agoReplying to myself to include a relevant point (reported by Digg, of all people): /u/kickme444, a Reddit employee and founder of RedditGifts, was also let go. RedditGifts was the other weird subreddit that had paid staff at corporate. http://digg.com/2015/redditrevolt-victoria-taylor-ama-reddit-amageddon http://digg.com/2015/redditrevolt-victoria-taylor-ama-reddit... I think it's increasingly hard to believe that this had anything to do with Jesse Jackson's AMA.
- hga 11y agoPer https://twitter.com/kickme444/status/616841444121165825 https://twitter.com/kickme444/status/616841444121165825 it was a few weeks ago.