4 ms·
Judging by the few early comments and what I know about the HN community, I am guessing this will be a wildly unpopular tax here. Before just shooting this dow
by slg 11y ago
Judging by the few early comments and what I know about the HN community, I am guessing this will be a wildly unpopular tax here. Before just shooting this down, I would be curious what our suggested alternatives would be. As mentioned in the article this tax is an attempt to solve the problem of lost tax revenue due to local tax paying business being replaced by internet business that have no obligation to the local economy. What is a realistic option for Chicago outside of taxes like this?
- eli 11y agoIncome tax.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoSpend less, and then you need less taxes to cover those expenses. Create an environment where businesses will want to start and to grow, rather than creating taxes that will specifically make new businesses go out of their way to avoid the the area. This kind of tax makes Chicago drastically less appealing to start a business in, and it's sufficiently bad to make it worth considering a move for any company that isn't inherently local. And "companies that aren't inherently local" are exactly what this tax targets. (Note in particular that for any business without a local nexus in the state, this exceeds the taxing authority of a city or state, as it would be regulating inter-state commerce.)
- eli 11y ago> for any business without a local nexus in the state, this exceeds the taxing authority of a city or state, as it would be regulating inter-state commerce. IANAL, but I don't think that's true. The locality can tax its citizens pretty much however it wants. Without a local nexus Chicago may have a hard time forcing Netflix to collect the tax on their behalf. But that's an implementation detail. Chicago citizens would still technically be on the hook.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoIt'd be interesting to see that tested in court. I know there have been cases that struck down regulations on inter-state commerce, in particular when there's no nexus in the state. It doesn't suffice to claim you're taxing citizens rather than transactions; courts do look at intent and net effect when evaluating a law. A tax on the internet connection itself would sadly be within the taxing authority of a state; however, a tax on an Internet service provided outside the state would be in effect a tax on "imports" across state lines (or country lines in the case of international services), and only the federal government can levy those.
- eli 11y agoI'm not so sure about that. When Amazon challenged New York State over sales tax it wasn't over whether NYS could charge a "use" tax for goods purchased online, it was over whether customers had to submit the tax themselves or whether Amazon was obligated to withhold it.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoI haven't seen a court case against any individual or business over "use tax", but I'm skeptical that rebranding an inter-state sales tax as a use tax suddenly makes it Constitutionally acceptable, given that it taxes the same thing. Nonetheless, neither of us are lawyers, and that question probably won't be settled unless someone actually takes it to a sufficiently high court.
- phil21 11y agoIt's quite well established that if you don't pay sales tax at the time of sale (e.g. via mail order/on-line) you are required to submit a use tax voluntarily by self-reporting. Of course pretty much no one does this. There are exceptions such as some states aggressively going after taxes on the sales of cars you buy across the state line/etc - but in general it's wink wink nudge nudge. If you're in a state with sales tax, and have ordered from an out of state retailer you are breaking the law if you don't pay use tax on that item. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Use_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Use_tax
- dub 11y agoRaising property and income taxes seems like a more traditional approach having a government share in the wealth of its citizens. If they want disproportionately higher taxes for internet users, maybe try taxing ISPs more?
- snsr 11y agoThis is a ferociously regressive tax. How about something a bit more progressive?