2 ms·
I alleged a conspiracy between a few people at the CRU to hide data, oust critics from professional societies and have journals shut down. Is that even in dispu
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
I alleged a conspiracy between a few people at the CRU to hide data, oust critics from professional societies and have journals shut down. Is that even in dispute?
Can you delete any emails you may have had with Keith re AR4? Keith will do likewise...Can you also email Gene and get him to do the same?...We will be getting Caspar to do likewise.
How do you interpret this as anything other than a conspiracy (between Jones, Keith, Gene and Caspar, not the entire climate science community, just to be 100% clear) to delete emails?
Rather than arguing against my simple, well supported conspiracy argument, you instead implied that I argued for some vast and implausible conspiracy. Why not just go for broke and act as if I claimed Phil Jones was behind 9/11?
Regarding McIntyre, whether or not he made a major improvement to the existing record or a minor incremental one, the point is that he is correct. A crackpot is a person with wild and incorrect theories completely unsupported by evidence.
Ah, so their internal shop-talk, posturing, boasting, etc. is part of the scientific endeavour, is it?
Ousting dissenters from professional societies certainly is, as is trying to get journals shut down.
Concerning antagonism, "I think you're a fraud" is the best kind to have. I wish it were more common, but it's too time consuming to use on an everyday basis.
- crux_ 17y ago> Rather than arguing against my simple, well supported conspiracy argument, you instead implied that I argued for some vast and implausible conspiracy. Why not just go for broke and act as if I claimed Phil Jones was behind 9/11? If you're claiming or implying, as you have been until now, that 'conspiracies' are the only reason that the current scientific consensus is still standing, then it has to be a vast conspiracy, no? > Regarding McIntyre, whether or not he made a major improvement to the existing record or a minor incremental one, the point is that he is correct. A crackpot is a person with wild and incorrect theories completely unsupported by evidence. Even a stopped clock is right twice a day. We can argue back and forth as to whether he's a crackpot or not but all we'd be doing is arguing about the definition of the word. (And it would remain a matter of opinion and not fact!) It is, however, true that his more substantial allegations practically require a widespread conspiracy, or something similarly dramatic, within the current consensus in order to be correct.