12 ms·
Dutch universities start their Elsevier boycott plan
- azdle 11y ago> If this way of putting pressure on the publishers does not work, the next step would be to ask reviewers to stop working for Elsevier. After that, scientists could be asked to stop publishing in Elsevier journals. Why is stopping publishing in the journal the last resort? This may be my lack of understanding showing, but why wouldn't that be the first step? I would think that all the other pieces would be much more replaceable than the actual papers themselves.
- candu 11y agoBecause removing a single editor-in-chief is much more damaging to the publisher than removing a single author?
- Someone 11y agoThe goal seems to be to reach an agreement, not to get embroiled forever. First, show your teeth. Biting can come later. Also, that biting would be costly, especially for less established scientists. Not publishing in high-ranking journals can be bad for a career.
- detaro 11y agoBecause it also has the highest impact on your scientists. Asking somebody to stop publishing in the major journals of his field is not going to get as much understanding as the weaker measures. You don't want all your potential PhD students running for the hills because they fear they won't get good publications...
- badlogic 11y agoIt's sad that this process hasn't started earlier. It's a farce that publishers got to erect a walled garden around tax funded research without adding anything of value. That being said, EU CS academia is a cess pool where more often than not it matters more who you know than what your actual research is. I partially blame the funding agencies for attaching unrealistic publication metrics to grants (publish or perish). On the other hand i had high ranking university staff tell me "they love how they can just burn €6M in 2 year EU project with zero outcome without consequences". Reviewers of such projects only need to have the right political color and zero domain knowledge. It's sad really and i'm happy i don't have to work in such an environment amnymore.
- _dark_matter_ 11y agoOuch, that's a scathing comment on EU CS research. Being in the US I know very little about it, though I do see a lot of quality work in my field come out of ETH-Zurich. I want to say we don't have the problems you're talking about, but I could just be an oblivious grad student :)
- Someone 11y agoZürich, Switzerland, isn't in the EU :-)
- protothomas 11y agoFor the purposes of European research funding it effectively is.
- folli 11y agoI would hope not. The single biggest research foundation in Switzerland is SNF (http://www.snf.ch/ http://www.snf.ch/), especially since the swiss participation in Horizon 2020 is unresolved due to political reasons.
- anigbrowl 11y agoWell, the administrators have outsourced the domain knowledge to the journal reviewers and pay for this service indirectly through journal fees, so from an accounting point of view it makes total sense. If not publication, what metric should funding agencies use to decide who gets grants? Of course they could hire senior scientists in the field to evaluate grant roposals, but that would mean hiring lots and lots of scientists across all the fields in which they disburse grants; those jobs would be sinecures and from the point of view of the grant applicant it would still be about 'who you know,' just a referee at a grant-issuing agency instead of an editor/reviewer at a journal. I don't disagree with you about the problem, but I'm not clear on how you would address it. Making the journals less profitable by refusing to pay silly subscription prices to read publicly-funded research would be a good thing for universities, and maybe for scientific publishing, but it's not going to fix the disconnect between people who control the public purse strings and which scientists will get the grants they want.
- SiVal 11y agoI would like to see the governments that fund research get together and create a rule that your government funding requires that a public version of the paper be made available online before that paper could be submitted to a private publisher. This would help to separate the public availability of useful information paid for by the public issue from the academics' career-promotion-via-publication issue. That would, of course, mean that papers would appear prior to acceptance and peer review, which would speed up the pace of research at the cost (if peer review is of any value) of putting more shaky research out there. I doubt this would be a big problem, since researchers in the field know what is going on anyway (they get early copies or at least early discussion at pay-walled conferences already), and others who read the research could see that it had not yet been published in a journal and decide for themselves what to make of it. Papers that got peer reviewed and published would still have the published version used in citations, so you could see how far it had gone in the publishing process at time of citation. I wouldn't be surprised if people in the field knew how much credibility to give to a paper based on the researchers without waiting for the researchers' more established rivals to "review" it to death.
- bunderbunder 11y agoOTOH, I'm not sure if the peer review system isn't ripe for disruption anyway. Peer review is a system that's designed for the old dead-trees world, where space for publishing in print journals was extremely limited, publishing in a print journal was the only way to share knowledge, and you only got one shot at it because there's limited options for fixing errors after the plates are engraved. It's primarily there to ensure a minimum standard for the quality of the paper, not necessarily the research. So what it's really good for ensuring is that the paper explains the research well enough that someone who's reading it (and knows what they're doing) could attempt to replicate the work. What it is not designed to do, though, is ensure that the research is valid. Peer review can't reliably detect fraudulent data, nor can it reliably detect fabricated data. Heck, it can't even detect p-value fishing, which is a really sobering problem when you consider how many scientists really don't seem to understand why p-value fishing is such a problem in the first place. There's supposed to be a different mechanism for detecting that stuff: replication. Buy ironcially, replication is something the current journal system actively discourages. Space in journals is a scarce resource. Furthermore, journals are competing with each other for prestige. They've got very little reason to waste space on replicating old findings (booooooooring) when they could be publishing brand new stuff (exciting!). In turn, researchers have very little incentive to try and replicate each other's findings. It's already hard to justify spending money on replicating existing findings. But there's no way in hell a researcher is going to waste their precious resources on work that they wouldn't even be able to get published. So the long and short of it is, people place far too much trust in peer review. In fact, peer review is a terribly low hurdle. All too often complete junk gets through it about as easily as excellent science. The trick is that it just has to be well written junk. OTOH, a system that removes barriers to doing replication work - or better yet, starts actively encouraging it - could also do much of the work of peer review. Because then we'd have peers reviewing the actual research and not just things people write about research.
- NotOscarWilde 11y agoAs a related aside: Does anyone know why arXiv has no system of public comments or (even better) a public peer review system built in? Whenever this topic comes up at a (CS) conference, everyone is for that, and yet, arXiv is functionally the same for quite a few years now.
- xiaq 11y agoBecause it was intended as a repository of preprints instead of a publishing platform. It surely has the potential of becoming one, but that has not happened yet.
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoBesides, if you open up physics papers to public comments you'll be deluged by cranks who think they can prove Einstin woz teh rong!!!! with a bit of algebra and a lot of punctuation. I don't know how you'd do useful public peer review. By definition, "peer" assumes some professional domain competence. The current system is probably too restrictive, but it's hard to imagine a more open system that's at least as useful. Maybe someone should do a PhD on it. :)
- xiaq 11y agoMaybe it can work as follows: Support a concept of "reviewer group" that can be created by anyone but can only be joined on invitation. When you post a review, the groups you belong to are shown; you can also filter articles that are approved by a certain group. Eventually, some groups will gain reputation by producing quality reviews on certain fields and people will treat papers approved by them as high-quality. Heck, you can even create groups like "former reviewers of XXX journal" and as soon as you convince other people, gain reputation very quickly.
- Coding_Cat 11y agoMy idea would be to either restrict access (to certain areas, such as comments and reviews) to verified groups. Initially I would say to verify users through universities and/or use a computer automated system to rank each user, determining whose opinion to weight heavily and whose to dismiss. I would also make reviews public and name-and-shame any caught review fixing (if proper evidence is available), which would be the bigger problem imho. But again, I think this is something we should also be able to detect using proper algorithms. If a user Alice always rates the papers by Bob highly, even when others disagree, perhaps her opinion of Bob's work is not to trustworthy.
- newsposter123 11y ago"It is not unthinkable that if I would submit a love letter, it would be published sooner than an intelligent scholarly article by a young researcher."
- personjerry 11y agoAnyone else think that this (academia/research) sounds like an industry that could be disrupted?
- darkstar999 11y agoEvery industry can be disrupted.
- xiaq 11y agoIt surely is, but beware that unlike fields like social networking which makes money from idle and bored people, scientists have a lot of things to get busy and excited about and are much harder to convince, unless there is some real advantages coming up.
- cossatot 11y agoDon't conflate academic publishing with research. It's a facet of research, and there are those working on 'disrupting' it in some form or another (academia.edu, Mendeley (now owned by Elsevier...), Authoria, etc.). Academia, in some sense of the word, is facing MOOCs. Research itself is a process that is basically self-disrupting, although maybe not in the original Clayton Christensen sense of a newer, shittier, cheaper product moving up-market and displacing the incumbents. Typically, it's the newer, more expensive, better product displacing the older ones and then moving down-market.
- navait 11y agoThe commentators have only interpreted industries in terms of potential for disruption - the point however, is to disrupt it.
- acaloiar 11y agoI'm currently co-authoring a paper that will be submitted to an Elsevier journal because it is a good fit for our work. All of my time and that of one other co-author is funded by an NIH grant which of course is funded by US tax dollars. I'm fairly certain the Elsevier agreement stipulates that I cannot share my paper without their permission – assuming the paper is accepted. If I were the NIH, I would make it illegal for grant recipients to publish anywhere that does not support open access. [EDIT] There are some conditions under which sharing is permitted: http://www.elsevier.com/authors/journal-authors/sharing-and-promoting-your-article http://www.elsevier.com/authors/journal-authors/sharing-and-...
- Someone 11y ago"If I were the NIH, I would make it illegal for grant recipients to publish anywhere that does not support open access” Don’t they do that? https://publicaccess.nih.gov https://publicaccess.nih.gov: "To advance science and improve human health, NIH makes the peer-reviewed articles it funds publicly available on PubMed Central. The NIH public access policy requires scientists to submit final peer-reviewed journal manuscripts that arise from NIH funds to PubMed Central immediately upon acceptance for publication"
- Fomite 11y agoThey're allowed to drag their feet a little bit, but yes.
- acaloiar 11y agoThat is good news indeed! Thank you for letting me know. This is my first publicly funded work and I am not familiar with many of the policies. I will sleep better knowing that our work will not be holed up exclusively in the Elsevier-beast. Also of interest: http://www.elsevier.com/about/open-science/open-access/agreements/elsevier-nih-policy-statement http://www.elsevier.com/about/open-science/open-access/agree...
- escherplex 11y agoIn last week's Economist of London (June 27, p.56) there is an article titled 'The halo effect' which explores conclusions drawn by a recent Princeton University study of large firms prosecuted for corruption and amount of subsequent punitive damages as a function of perceived 'corporate social responsibility'. Interesting finding was that 'spending on employee and community relations had a much bigger impact on the prosecutors than did promoting diversity or being environmentally friendly.' When push comes to shove all human interaction, like politics, is parochial. So it's not surprising that within the first-world academic community all Elsevier effort at 'making developing world libraries flourish' by supplying discount textbooks coupled with programs to 'award women scientists in the developing world' has done little to mitigate perception of the firm as being both avaricious and elitist. Seems like a change in strategy is in order.
- lultimouomo 11y agoI find it amazing that such an article can be written without spending a single word about the craziness of open access. Let's repeat the core concept, in the words of the article: the university or the financier of the research pays to get published In my own words: the author of the research is the customer of the journal. It used to be that the reader was the customer, which paid the journal that provided him with the service of having the article reviewed and doing its best to make sure the research was solid. Now the emperor is naked, and it's finally official what's the purpose of academic journals: let people have their grants renewed.
- ricardobeat 11y agoAren't universities the main customer of journals already? They pay millions for subscriptions.
- sago 11y agoBut the financier of the research is already paying for the research to be done, rarely for their economic interest, but so that it gets out there, establishes the science, furthers knowledge, cements reputations, etc. For research done by economic interests the incentive is even stronger, a drug company, say, wants to get their drug out, proven, marketed. Your response seems high on derision, but you've not actually made any point about why it shouldn't be the people paying for the research's role to pay for the research's availability. The counter arguments is on availability, the hegemony of large institutions, and the lack of transparency of funding bodies. So, other than derision, accusations of naked emperors, and a variation of "didn't used to be like that", what actually is your problem with that model?
- lultimouomo 11y ago> So, other than derision, accusations of naked emperors, and a variation of "didn't used to be like that", what actually is your problem with that model? The fact that the interest of the journal is now naturally aligned with that of the writer, instead of with that of the reader. This makes it very useful for the writer, which pays[0], publishes and so gets to live another year having his grant renewed; it also makes it quite useless for the reader, which cannot count on a seriously curated publication. [0] "Pays" meaning "diverts part of his funding allowance"
- aswanson 11y agoWhy don't all universities just make all their professors papers available online. No journals, etc, just put the damn pdfs online and let people cite by hyperlink and normal inline citations. To hell with the publishers.
- Maken 11y agoMost people do that, and most publishers allow authors to publish preprints of their works. Google Scholar is the usual place for looking for citations. But all this rely on the good faith of the editor and universities preserving the author personal pages forever. And the entire system lacks any standardization or interoperability.
- PeterisP 11y agoThe people generally already do make the papers available, but that's still not a replacement for journals or indexed conferences; if I just put the paper online without it also being in a reputable publication, then from the point of carreer and future funding I might just as well thrown it in garbage. The same goes with low-ranked open access publication venues - publishing in them is worse than not publishing at all; since it prevents me from publishing that research in some place that matters.
- aswanson 11y agoWhat seems to be broken, though, is the question of why that place matters; it seems to be cabal-driven and to some extent corrupted. The results of research should be able to matter purely on their own merit, not because of a tag some committee put on it. Idealistic? Of course, but that doesnt mean that is not worth pursuing.
- ylem 11y agoThe following is interesting: http://www.energy.gov/articles/us-department-energy-increases-access-results-doe-funded-scientific-research http://www.energy.gov/articles/us-department-energy-increase... It will be interesting to see how this evolves. I also see more open access publications (where the publication is free for the public, but the author pays the publisher) these days--but I'm not sure if they have subsidies for researchers from smaller institutions.
- elektromekatron 11y agoThe wheels may turn slowly. But they turn.
- kanyethegreat 11y agoPractically speaking, asking them to resign their posts is kind of extreme. Food is a little more tangible than morality.
- jerven 11y agoThose are basically unpaid posts
- thegrif 11y agoI'm the former director of innovation for IEEE. I actually recruited many members of my team from HN. We were developing some great stuff to address many of the comments here. Unfortunately they just didn't have the stomach for it - and hardly none of it hit users (and the stuff that did was so watered down to protect current revenue streams that it's completely different (and in some cases silly). There were a handful of folks in this thread who said they'd be interested in building some new stuff to solve the era problems in how scientific knowledge is created and shared. If anyone wants to contact me directly, I'd be happy to organize those interested, capture ideas, and see if there's something common we all want to work on. I'm at tom@thegrif.net or www.linkedin.com/in/tomgriffin.
- kragen 11y agoThat sounds really interesting! What kind of stuff were you developing, and what kind of roadblocks did you hit?
- shmerl 11y agoReed Elsevier have a really nasty reputation. They also supported SOPA / PIPA.
- tomkat0789 11y agoThere's good arguements for and against a complete conversion to open access research. Ruining all the free fun of open access are charlatans from around the world creating open access journals from nothing and picking up free money and prestige. I'd like to abring up this website: http://scholarlyoa.com/ http://scholarlyoa.com/ It's run by a librarian in Colorado, and he has a set of criteria to determine whether a given open access journal qualifies as a "predatory" journal. Sometimes you see stuff like this gem: http://scholarlyoa.com/2014/11/20/bogus-journal-accepts-profanity-laced-anti-spam-paper/ http://scholarlyoa.com/2014/11/20/bogus-journal-accepts-prof... I can't find the link, but I once read a story where they published a paper titled, "Enter paper title". That's how reputable some of these outfits are. Open access won't be perfect.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- hitlin37 11y agoNot just Dutch universities, other universities within EU should join the effort.
- roelvanhintum 11y agoI'm surprised this isn't big news in The Netherlands. I have not seen a single thing about it in the news!
- bluenose69 11y agoThe main funding agency in my country is starting to demand that we publish in open-access journals. It seems like a wonderful thing, except for one little detail: the agency is not supplying any extra funding. The difference in cost between conventional and open-access grants is a significant fraction of the typical grant. Are researchers expected to publish less frequently, or to reduce students stipends?
- transcranial 11y agoOver 15,000 academics and researchers have already signed a petition boycotting Elsevier. The effort is but a drop in the bucket in terms of what's needed. http://thecostofknowledge.com/ http://thecostofknowledge.com/
- mierek4ever 11y agoNo whole world can't be like tiny Denmark. With size half-brooklyn you can afford being awkward. We can't.