4 ms·
Redistribution results in one thing: equal levels of misery. Re: Cuba, Venenzuela, pre-Deng Xiaoping China, the Warsaw Pact countries, Vietnam. Standards of liv
by briandear 11y ago
Redistribution results in one thing: equal levels of misery. Re: Cuba, Venenzuela, pre-Deng Xiaoping China, the Warsaw Pact countries, Vietnam. Standards of living are higher in capitalist countries, that's a fact. Aside from the insane, nobody in 1987 said, "Citizenship in the USSR would be so much I nicer than here in the U.S." Also interesting: the lines around US consulates to get immigrant visas-- they often extend around the block. Every single day. The line outside the Cuban embassy? None. If a redistributive economy is best, why aren't Latin Americans sneaking into Cuba instead of into the United States? Why aren't the Hondurans making the trip to Venenzuela instead of risking the danger of crossing through Mexico to get to the United States? I would offer that the poorest people in the world all want to go to the U.S. Not because of redistributive policies, but because of opportunity. You can't become rich in Cuba. You can't even start a business of any consequence there. You can't get capital loans. what's the incentive to innovate and work hard if the government is just going to steal your efforts. The government should have a regressive tax;bathe current tax system actually penalizes success and rewards failure.
- badsock 11y agoI don't get how some people seem to think that there's only two possible political systems in the world. When I say redistributive, I mean things like progressive taxation, estate taxes, and basic income. In terms of median household income, the US places 6th in the world (and dropping), behind 5 countries whose taxation systems are significantly more progressive, so I dispute your claim of "equal levels of misery": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Median_household_income https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Median_household_income I really do understand that incentives matter, and that progressive taxation is also progressively disincentivizing. However, the countries in the world that have a better quality of life for the majority of their people are to the left of America, not to the right. And I'm more swayed by data than abstract economic theories.
- lotharbot 11y agosince your argument is about the effect of taxes, "median household income ... before deduction of taxes" (which is what the wikipedia page shows) isn't really a useful metric.
- badsock 11y agoYou are 100% correct, thanks! Here's a more appropriate link: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_net_take-home_pay https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_net_take-... The US is 7th, behind a very similar group of steep-progressive-tax countries. I would say an even better metric is median quality of life indicators (which tell a similar story of the US trailing left-wing countries) but that's an understandably more controversial index.
- lotharbot 11y agoA further nitpick: pretty much any index of this sort (particularly QoL) also has to be corrected for demographic trends -- the US absorbs around 20% of the world's total immigrant population [0], and the majority come from much poorer countries (#33 Mexico, not-even-ranked China, India, Philippines, Vietnam, El Salvador, etc. [1]) Those are countries with much worse economies, health care outcomes, education systems, etc. -- all of which have significant effects on both "median" and "average" numbers for measures of the US as a whole. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_immigrant_population https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_immigrant... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_to_the_United_States#Demographics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_to_the_United_Stat...
- badsock 11y ago13% of the population of the US is immigrants; for Sweden it's 14%, and Norway it's 13% (source: Wikipedia).
- lotharbot 11y agoSweden gets around 10% of its immigrants [0] from Finland, which is nearly tied with it in the net take-home pay list above. Sweden gets an additional >10% of its immigrants from countries above it in the net take-home pay list, or more than 20% total from top-20 countries. The US, on the other hand, gets the vast majority of its immigrants from much poorer countries [1]. The US gets around 7% of its immigrants from top-20 countries. Particularly when it comes to median statistics, adding people at the bottom of the scale is going to skew the stats. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_to_Sweden#Country_of_origin_for_persons_born_abroad https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_to_Sweden#Country_... [1] http://cis.org/2012-profile-of-americas-foreign-born-population#birth http://cis.org/2012-profile-of-americas-foreign-born-populat...
- paulhauggis 11y ago"behind 5 countries whose taxation systems are significantly more progressive, so I dispute your claim of "equal levels of misery":" Maybe not equal levels of misery, but significantly less purchasing power (In Australia for instance, a small bag of chips and a 20 oz. of coke is $11 at the local 7-11 when I was there last year), less innovation, and less freedom beyond a corporate 9-5. When it takes a court case to fire an employee and taxes and restrictions are that large, how can 3 people in a dorm room possibly build a successful company? It's also pretty telling when venture capitalists pretty much avoid any of those countries. Here are average wages in Sweden for instance (2012): http://lostinstockholm.com/2012/01/10/average-salaries-in-sweden-by-occupation/ http://lostinstockholm.com/2012/01/10/average-salaries-in-sw... "estate tax and basic income" Everything you mentioned are just schemes for redistributing wealth. It's exactly what the op said they don't want. If I work my entire life to build my fortunes, why should the government get a large percentage before my family? I see it no different than theft.
- badsock 11y agoI dispute your purchasing power argument: http://www.statista.com/statistics/226956/average-world-wages-in-purchasing-power-parity-dollars/ http://www.statista.com/statistics/226956/average-world-wage... You'll note that Austria and Norway beat the US, and Sweden and Finland are in the ballpark. I'm not arguing about innovation or "freedom", I'm arguing about a better society - one with less crime, better social mobility, etc. - for the average person. Not the Internet startup lotto winner. And the government doesn't "get" a large percentage of your income - they don't keep any of it. Your fellow citizens get it. It goes to pay for the huge amount of infrastructure that you used while amassing your fortune (court system, transporation system, an educated healthy population to draw employees from, etc.). You view taxation as theft. I view people who use infrastructure and then don't want to contribute back as welchers.
- paulhauggis 11y ago"I'm arguing about a better society - one with less crime, better social mobility, etc." Those countries have less crime because they are very strict on immigration. Many people come to the US and instead of creating a new life and a new culture, keep the broken culture from the county they left, and in many cases, means an increase in crime. It's also easier to maintain because those countries have as many people as a large city in the US..so the comparison isn't really fair. "It goes to pay for the huge amount of infrastructure that you used while amassing your fortune (court system, transporation system, an educated healthy population to draw employees from, etc.)." Those are already paid through many other taxes, so this isn't really a valid reason. Most people that are wealthy already paid many more in taxes than they will ever use. Where did all that money go? "You view taxation as theft. I view people who use infrastructure and then don't want to contribute back as welchers." I view an estate tax as theft, not taxes in general. Stop putting words in my mouth to fit your agenda. Let me guess: You are in your early-mid 20s and don't have a lot of wealth? I run 2 very successful businesses and pay way more money in taxes than most people make in a year...and will continue to pay more in taxes than I will ever take from the system. We also don't really have any government accountability. If we could actually track where our money was going, there might not be all of this need to take more. "better social mobility" How do you think we achieve social mobility? One of the best ways is to start a company. You don't even need an education. In the US, you can pay less than $50 in most states to make your company official..or even just run it under your own name as a sole-proprietorship. In all of the countries you mention, there is virtually no social mobility and pretty much the only place to get a job is either at a large corporation or for the government. And lastly, I just don't trust the government to manage my tax money that well.
- notahacker 11y agoAnd redistributive Northern Europe is more miserable than non-redistributive sub-Saharan Africa? (Actually, on the subject of redistribution in notionally communist countries, it's pretty funny when you're sat round a beer stall in Saigon and its the citizens of the Socialist Republic of Vietnam that are loudly condemning the amount of money that gets redistributed to the indolent poor in the US because the biggest handout most of their own unemployed ever get is a 10% cut on any state lottery tickets they can sell...)
- mahyarm 11y agoThe USA is very redistributive, but is less efficient in doing so in many ways than other countries. For example the health care system in america is significantly less economically efficient then the health care system of Canada, which causes a lot of human misery in the USA. To 'redistribute' wealth, you don't have to directly take money in the form of taxes and directly give it to others. You can also redistribute wealth with 2nd order effects such as rent control, or limiting the supply of doctors through unrelated expensive requirements and so on. Much of the economic inefficiency in the US's health care system comes from these 2nd order policies. So am I leftist if I want the US to adopt single payer health care and to cut a lot of it's negative 2nd order policies? Or am I conservative/libertarian for wanting it?